Think Performance-Based PR Works? Think Again

1. Here’s Why Pay Per Performance PR Doesn't Work PR Advice From NYC PR Agency BP{M- PR Firm Why Pay-Per- Performance PR Doesn’t Work — And What to Do Instead I “Only pay when we land you coverage!” f you’ve been Googling how to get media placements for your brand or how to get press for your brand, chances are you’ve come across a tempting pitch all over Beyoncé’s internet: It sounds glamorous. Strategic. Risk-free. But here’s the truth: Pay-per- performance PR (also known as pay-to-play PR) isn’t a smart shortcut—it’s a fast track to wasted time, weak visibility, and stalled brand growth. It’s easy to edit text, change fonts, and add beautiful graphics. Use paragraph styles to get a consistent look throughout your document. For example, this paragraph uses Body style. You can change it in the Text tab of the Format controls. “At BPM-PR Firm, we’ve spent 20 years helping brands go from quiet to category-dominating. We’ve seen every trend in the book. And we can confidently say: this model doesn’t work. 1

2. Here’s Why Pay Per Performance PR Doesn't Work Here’s exactly why. 1. You Get What You Don’t Pay For To secure real media placements, you need real firepower—and that means tools like Muck Rack, Cision, top-tier newswire distribution accounts, editorial databases, and pro-grade tracking software. These aren’t luxuries. They’re the lifeblood of serious PR. They’re how we stay ten steps ahead in a media landscape that changes by the hour. With these tools, we know the moment an editor switches beats or leaves a publication—so your pitch doesn’t get lost in a dead inbox. We uncover rising- star journalists before they blow up, so your story lands while their byline is fresh. We track your competitors, analyze what press they’re landing, and craft angles that elevate you above the noise. We build hyper-targeted media lists in real time —not from guesswork, but from intel. This is how you get press that actually performs. But pay-per-performance PR firms? They skip all of it. Why? Because those tools cost money—and you can’t invest in a premium PR tech stack when you’re only getting paid after something hits. So they pitch blind. They pitch late. They pitch 2

3. Here’s Why Pay Per Performance PR Doesn't Work generic. And you pay the price in missed opportunities, low-tier placements, and stories that never get told. 2. No Budget for Newswires or Quality Content When it comes to jumpstarting a campaign, one of the best ways to amplify visibility is through press releases distributed via top-tier newswires (like PR Newswire or Business Wire). But here’s the thing: pay-to-play PR teams almost never use them. Why? Because a well-distributed release costs hundreds— sometimes thousands—to publish. And even if they do write a release, it’s often rushed, dry, and not optimized for engagement or syndication. Meanwhile, real PR firms… Craft press releases that editors actually want to read • Craft creative pitch letters • Track your competitors news • A/B test subject lines, angles, and distribution windows • Copywrite and format for both search and pickup • Set up desksides • Manage sample sends • Use data to track views, opens, and pickup post-release • Expand your campaign far beyond press and media outreach • None of this is possible in a pay-per-hit model. There’s simply no time or resources to deliver content that performs—and poor content means poor results. 3. Low Budget = Low Results Pay-to-play PR might claim to get press for your brand, but check the receipts. The placements often appear on low-traffic, low-SEO, low-ranking sites. Many are articles ghostwritten by the publicist under a pseudonym. Google the headline? It doesn’t exist beyond that one page. No syndication. No pickup. No traction. That’s not real press. That’s performance theater. 3

4. Here’s Why Pay Per Performance PR Doesn't Work 4. Real Media Relationships Take Years You can’t fake credibility. The best earned media placements come from relationships—editors, writers, and producers who trust us to bring them solid, timely stories. These relationships aren’t built overnight. They’re built over time— and pay-per-performance campaigns don’t have time to build anything lasting. If you want relationships that deliver, you need a strategic PR partner committed to consistency and excellence. 5. Great Follow-Up Takes Work Landing top-tier media doesn’t come from hitting “send” on a pitch. It’s about follow-up. Strategy. Knowing how and when to circle back. But when you’re only getting paid per placement? That kind of high-touch, high-skill effort falls by the wayside. At BPM-PR Firm, we use detailed media outreach calendars and tracking to keep the momentum going—long after the first pitch. 6. It’s a Transaction—Not a Transformation Pay-per-performance PR treats visibility like a vending machine. Drop in a coin, get a clip. But real PR is layered. It’s strategic. It’s transformative. It’s not just about getting media placements—it’s about shaping your brand’s story in the public eye. From corporate communications to product storytelling, we look at the full ecosystem to build lasting impressions. 7. You’re Paying for Expertise, Not Just Exposure When you work with a seasoned PR firm, you’re tapping into years of experience —not just from one publicist, but an entire team of experts. That depth is what ensures your PR campaign doesn’t just start, it scales. Our leadership team and trained senior staff ensure every project is handled with precision from day one. 8. When PR Works, It Snowballs—Fast The right strategy creates momentum. One great feature leads to another, then another. Suddenly, your brand is trending, syndicated, and everywhere. But if you’re paying per placement? That snowball becomes unaffordable fast. Real success shouldn’t come with a growing invoice every time you win. 4

5. Here’s Why Pay Per Performance PR Doesn't Work Learn more about how we build campaigns that snowball. 9. Real PR Goes Beyond Press Releases Award submissions. Thought leadership. Creative angles. Brand partnerships. Event opportunities. Supporting influencer and celebrity collaborations. All of this makes up a strong PR ecosystem. Pay-to-play PR firms don’t (and can’t) offer this kind of scope. They’re focused on delivering just enough to get paid. At BPM-PR Firm, we’re focused on delivering complete visibility—not just one-off clips. 10. Overworked, Underpaid = Underperforming Let’s be honest—teams working under a pay-per-hit model are stretched thin. They’re scrambling to hit numbers, not elevate your narrative. That pressure leads to corner-cutting, not campaign-building.  Paying to Play Is Playing It Small Let’s say it louder for the people in the back: Paying to play is playing it small. It’s reactive, not proactive. It’s transactional, not visionary. And it’s the exact opposite of what powerhouse brands do to dominate their space. So ask yourself: Is playing it small your end vision for your brand?
 Or do you want to be remembered, quoted, and celebrated across real media channels that move markets? Brands that rise don’t chase one-off mentions. They build momentum, drive narratives, and own their authority. 5

6. Here’s Why Pay Per Performance PR Doesn't Work  Final Thought Next time a publicist sends you coverage—Google the headline.
 If that article has zero pickup, no SEO value, and no engagement, you’re not getting PR. You’re getting pretend reach.  The BPM-PR Firm Difference We don’t chase headlines. We create impact.
 We build strategic campaigns that position your brand to win in the media, the market, and the minds of your ideal audience. We specialize in high-impact PR for high-performing brands—or brands that are ready to become high-performing within both the media and sales. So if you’re ready to ditch the gimmicks and invest in visibility that actually moves the needle—we’re ready to build something powerful. Let’s make your brand unmissable. Contact us today at BPM-PR Firm by emailing info@bpm- prfirm.com or calling 1.877.841.7244. for more information visit www.bpm-prfirm.com BPMPRFirm #PRThatPerforms #MediaVisibility #EarnedMediaStrategy #HighImpactPR #StrategicPR #PRForBrands #PublicRelationsFirm #NYCPRFirm #PRThatWorks #SalesDrivenPR #MediaCoverageMatters #BrandAcceleration #ThoughtLeadershipPR #CorporatePRExperts #DTCMarketing #LuxuryBrandPR #PRForFounders #HighGrowthBrands #TopPRFirm #ExecutivePR #CreativePRStrategy #BrandPositioning #PressWithPower #PRResults #BusinessVisibility #GrowthMarketing #ProductLaunchPR #ReputationManagement #ElevateYourBrand #PRandMarketingStrategy #AuthorityBuilding #MediaStrategy #PRCampaigns #PRConsulting #DigitalPR #BrandReputation #PRInsights #StorytellingStrategy #CrisisCommunications #ContentThatConverts #MediaRelations #InfluencerStrategy #BusinessPR #MarketingStrategy #CreativeMedia #PRGoals #BrandStorytelling 6

7. Here’s Why Pay Per Performance PR Doesn't Work #PressThatMatters #VisibilityStrategy #CommunicationsStrategy #PublicityThatSells #ScaleWithPR #BestPRFirm #BestPRAgency #NYCMarketingFirm #CMOMarketing #CMOStrategy #CMOGrowth #CMOVisibility #CMOLeadership #CMOPRTools #PRForCMOs #ExecutiveCommunications #B2BMarketingPR #TopNYCPRFirm 7