1 / 22


Geoarchaeology. Studying Ancient Environments. Ancient Environments. Geology: numerous techniques for studying ancient environments (four main approaches) Petrology : studying characteristics of stone Geomorphology : studying ancient landforms Sedimentology : studying soil processes

Download Presentation


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.


Presentation Transcript

  1. Geoarchaeology Studying Ancient Environments

  2. Ancient Environments • Geology: numerous techniques for studying ancient environments (four main approaches) • Petrology: studying characteristics of stone • Geomorphology: studying ancient landforms • Sedimentology: studying soil processes • Climatology: studying ancient climate change

  3. Petrology • How rock changes over time (weathering, erosion) • Can help with determining age of material culture • Source Areas (where raw materials originated) • Thin Section Analysis • Looking for characteristic inclusions and crystals • Analysis of trade, exchange, social interaction, migration • Trace Element Analysis • X-Ray fluorescence, Neutron Activation Analysis, etc. • Energize sample to stimulate emission of characteristic trace element spectra; can then be tied to a source area

  4. Thin Section Examples Pottery Stone

  5. Geomorphology • Today’s landscape not always what it was in the past • Landscape one factor in determine available resources • Plants, animals, stone, etc. • Understanding landscape and resources helps us understand what sort of world ancient people lived in • Changes in landscape affect archaeological record • Patterns of deposition/erosion bury or destroy sites • e.g., Glaciation, River Erosion, Flood Deposition

  6. Geomorphology of Ancient Shorelines

  7. Sedimentology • Nearly all archaeological sites buried • Need to understand soil processes • How deep do you have to dig? Depends on nature of soils (key to research design; determines how one surveys for and excavates sites) • Floodplain (deeply buried); Terrace (intermediate); Uplands (shallow deposition) • What comprises culturally sterile deposits? • North America: e.g., glacial gravels • Classification of soil stratigraphy • Plowzone (Ap), A horizon, B horizon, C horizon; “buried A horizons”

  8. Soil Stratigraphy

  9. Climatology • Climate: another major factor in determining available resources • Desert, forest, swamp, prairie, etc. • Ecofacts: primary means of determining climate • Floral and Faunal Analysis • Dendrochronology (a record of climate as well as time) • Recovery by flotation • Seeds, microfauna, wood frags., nut frags., etc. • Pollen/Palynology; Phytoliths • Isotopic evidence • Stable Oxygen isotopes in Ice Cores • Ice Age(s) example

  10. Environmental Indicators Pollen Phytoliths Animal Bone Plant Remains

  11. Case Study in Geoarchaeology The Sphinx: How Old is It?

  12. “Great Sphinx” • Located on Giza Plateau, outside Cairo • Memphis Necropolis (includes Great Pyramids)

  13. Age Debate • Mainstream History of Monument • Built at same time as nearby Pyramid of Khafre (Khaf-Ra, Chephren) in about 2540 BC (face thought to be Khafre) • Early documentary references: 1500 BC • Construction of monument part of the same program monument construction during the first five centuries of the Old Kingdom (2575-2134 BC) • Origins of Pharaonic dynasties • Monuments as legitimating social hierarchy

  14. Age Debate • Controversial Reinterpretations: “Old Sphinx” • John Anthony West (“Amateur” Egyptologist): weathering patterns consistent with water, not wind • Especially for lower levels of monument (supposedly buried by sand longest, so contain most evidence of “water-weathering”) • Area has been arid since 10,000 BC, so Sphinx must be at least that old (and related to “Atlanteans”) • Some geologists (e.g., Robert Schoch) have supported the weathering theory • Graham Hancock: pyramids and sphinx locations relate to 10,500 BC stellar alignments • No recorded builder or building date (minor references that it may predate pyramids, but not by how long)

  15. West and Schoch (Never trust someone wearing a pith helmet)

  16. Age Debate (cont.) • Gauri et al. (geoarchaeologists): similar patterns to West’s “water-weathering” occur in arid environments also • West and Schoch ignore basic geology of area • Sphinx carved out of local bedrock; geologic characteristics of upper layers (head) different than bottom (body) – increase in porosity in lower parts • salt crystals form in rock pores; causes exfoliation due to hydrostatic pressure; same patterns as West’s “water-weathering”

  17. Age Debate • Critiques of Old Sphinx argument • No associated artifacts older than 2,600 BC • If a technologically sophisticated culture existed prior to that, you would expect to find some traces beyond a single monument; Where’s their garbage? • West argues that Sphinx water weathered, while other monuments wind weathered • Why haven’t “wind weathering” patterns obliterated older, “water weathering” patterns?

  18. Geology of the Sphinx

  19. How to spot Pseudoscience • Prior Plausibility: how well does a theory fit with what we already know? • Occam’s Razor: simpler explanations should be preferred over complex • Non-sequitur argument: “They laughed at <insert name>, and he was right, so I must be right also” • Public Verifiability: can other people apply the ideas and get the same results? • Authority: who is the person making the argument? • Humility: not to say that all good scientists are humble, but a crackpot is almost never humble • $$$: is someone getting rich off of their claims?

More Related