The basest instincts or the noblest intentions? An interview study of survivors of emergencies and disasters John Drury, Chris Cocking & Steve Reicher BPS SPSAC06 Popular images of mass emergencies and evacuations ‘Panic’: ‘Instinct’ overwhelms socialization Emotion outweighs reasoning
Related searches for The basest instincts or the noblest intentions? An interview study of survivors of emergencies and disasters
Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.
John Drury, Chris Cocking
& Steve Reicher
The evacuating/emergency/disaster crowd as a social (not individualised/instinctual) phenomenon
‘Sociality’ is limited to that of the small group:
A possible explanation for some aspects of mass emergency behaviour
Shared fate in relation to threat/emergency creates sense of we-ness (Clarke, 2002)
Drawing on the SCT account of help/cohesion to explain behaviour in mass emergencies:
H1: In the face of danger there is a perception of shared fate, and hence a common identity emerges
H2: The common identity means that those in danger help others, including strangers
H3: if there is no common identity, there will not be this level of help.
Most who described a sense of threat (13 vs 1) also referred to a sense of unity (12 vs 7) in relation to this threat:
TC: Oh yeah of course I I get on the train every day. So a train journey you would normally take is, you know, I myself get on the train at ten to seven in the mornings, sit down, open the paper and there might be one or two people talking out of a completely packed carriage.
TC: So, you know, that that sort of thing and the perception… of of being involved in that, and everyone’s involved and let’s do, let’s group together’
Most who described a sense of unity (12 vs 7) also described giving help to others (12 vs 6) and, even more so, cited examples of others helping others (18 vs 3) – sometimes at a clear cost or risk to the personal self:
‘the behaviour of many people in that crowd and simply trying to help their fellow supporters was heroic in some cases. So I don’t think in my view there was any question that there was an organic sense of… unity of crowd behaviour. It was clearly the case, you know.. it was clearly the case that people were trying to get people who were seriously injured out of that crowd, it was seriously a case of trying to get people to hospital, get them to safety .. I just wish I’d been able to.. to prevail on a few more people not to.. put themselves in danger.’
At the Fatboy Slim beach party, while some felt in danger (from the tide and the crush) and described a sense of unity, for another interviewee there was no perceived danger, and others present were perceived as not part of a common group and indeed were seen to behave as competing individuals:
’It wasn’t a group thing, it was a very individual lots of individuals together... I felt like I was with my .. five or six friends and that was it.. and it was like the others were the enemy [ ] It wasn’t like ‘oh I was at Fat Boy Slim, I experienced all the the bad times with my fellow clubbers,’ it wasn’t like that, it was the opposite.’
‘the fact that people were trying to barge past me, I thought that was really selfish. No-one was letting me go first. There was no courteousness at all’
(Fatboy Slim 3)
Newspapers (victims’/witnesses’ accounts):
Our interviews. Process: Threat, shared fate, unity, co-operation
LB1: There was people generally giving what they had … you might have a bottle of water or something they would have given them straight away to the other people but you know there [ ] was definitely empathy and unity among everyone on the train
CC: can you say how much unity there was on a scale of 1-10?
LB1 I’d say it was very high I’d say it was 7 or 8 out of 10
CC: ok and comparing to before the blast happened what do you think the unity was like before?
LB1 I’d say very low- 3 out of 10 I mean you don’t really think about unity in a normal train journey, it just doesn’t happen you just want to get from A to B, get a seat maybe [ ] I felt that we’re all in the same boat together [ ] … yeah so I felt exactly I felt quite close to the people near me