closing the door on solicitor litigation n.
Skip this Video
Loading SlideShow in 5 Seconds..
Closing the Door on Solicitor Litigation PowerPoint Presentation
Download Presentation
Closing the Door on Solicitor Litigation

Closing the Door on Solicitor Litigation

263 Views Download Presentation
Download Presentation

Closing the Door on Solicitor Litigation

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript

  1. Closing the Door on Solicitor Litigation The Need For And Advantages Of the Model Solicitation Ordinance

  2. Most Municipalities Have Ordinances Regarding Door-to-Door Solicitation “To protect the local citizenship against crime and to preserve the private property, peace, and comfort of the occupants of the private residen[ces] in the City.”

  3. Solicitor Litigation Case StudyPacific Frontier v Pleasant Grove • Sellers of Kirby vacuum cleaners brought suit against Pleasant Grove in November 2002. • Plaintiffs alleged the Solicitation Ordinance was burdensome and unconstitutional. • Plaintiffs sought a preliminary injunction.

  4. Preliminary Injunction • Fingerprinting requirement. • Cash bond in the amount of $1,000. • Special license fee of $100 per year (District Court declined to address).

  5. Litigation Results • United States District Court granted preliminary injunction, holding that as to the bond and fingerprint requirements, that there was a substantial likelihood of success on the merits. • Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed. Pacific Frontier v. Pleasant Grove City, 414 F.3d 1221 (10th Cir. 2005).

  6. Mediation Dynamics • District Court’s preliminary injunction decision strongly indicated that the Court would find the ordinance unconstitutional. • Plaintiffs’ damages claims were weak. • 42 U.S.C. § 1983 provides for attorney fees to prevailing plaintiff, even without damages. • Continued defense increases attorney fees. • Approximately 30 similar suits were pending against municipalities statewide. • Unknown amount of potential liability should plaintiffs sue other cities.

  7. Mediation Results(Settlement Agreement) • Cash settlement. • Defendants agree to adopt Model Ordinance. • Plaintiffs release Defendants and all other non-defendant cities who: • Immediately cease enforcement of solicitation ordinances other than the Model Ordinance, and • Enact the Model Ordinance within 180 days (6 months).

  8. Model Solicitation Ordinance • Model Ordinance is a compromise and negotiation in drafting between Plaintiffs’ counsel and Defendants’ counsel. • Workable, if far from perfect. • The only ordinance that carries with it a bar to suit by Plaintiffs.

  9. 000-002 No Other City License or Approval Required • “Registered solicitors and persons exempt from registration need not apply for, nor obtain, any other license, permit, or registration from the city to engage in door-to-door solicitation.”

  10. 000-003 Definitions (4) Applicant means an individual who is at least sixteen (16) years of age who applies for a certificate permitting door-to-door solicitation. (6) BCI means an original or copy, dated no older than 180 days prior to the date of the application, of either (1) a Bureau of Criminal Identification verified criminal history report personal to the Applicant; or (2) verification by the Bureau of Criminal Identification that no disqualifying status exists for the Applicant.

  11. 000-003 Definitions (cont.) (10) Charitable organization includes any person or entity that is: (A) benevolent, educational, voluntary health, philanthropic, humane, patriotic, religious, or eleemosynary, social welfare or advocacy, public health, environmental or conservation, or civic organization; for the benefit of a public safety, law enforcement, or firefighter fraternal association, or established for any charitable purpose; and (B) Tax exempt under the Internal Revenue Code

  12. Disqualifying StatusConviction (by plea or jury) orPending Criminal Charges for: • Felony homicide • Physically abusing, sexually abusing, or exploiting a minor • Sale or distribution of controlled substances • Sexual assault of any kind

  13. Disqualifying Status • Felony conviction within last ten years. • Incarcerated in federal or state prison within last five years. • Conviction within last five years of misdemeanor involving moral turpitude, violent or aggravated conduct towards persons or property.

  14. Disqualifying Status • Final civil judgment within five years of fraud, intentional misrepresentation, or a non-dischargeable debt in bankruptcy. • Current parole or probation. • Outstanding arrest warrant. • Current protective order based on physical or sexual abuse.

  15. 000-004 Exemptions • Prior invitees, • State licensees, • Deliveries on prior orders, • Persons advocating religious belief or political position, and • Representatives of charitable organizations.

  16. 000-005 Solicitation Prohibited • Broad definition: • Door-to-door solicitation • Home solicitation sale • Sale of Goods or Services • Includes all methods of payment. • Applies whether sale is made or not. • Time of payment is immaterial.

  17. 000-007 Application FormsEach application shall require disclosure of the following: • Review of Written Disclosure information, • Contact Information • Proof of Identity • Proof of Registration with the Department of Commerce • Special Events Sales Tax Number • Marketing Information

  18. 000-007 Application FormsEach application shall require disclosure of the following: • Marketing Information • BCI Background Check* • Responses to Questions Regarding “Disqualifying Status” • Fee ($15 is agreed to be reasonable) • Execution (signature)

  19. 000-010 Issuance of Certificates • A temporary (25-day) certificate shall be issued upon: • Submission of completed application; • Payment of required fee; • Proof of identity; • Completed application form that does not affirmatively show a disqualifying status; • BCI does not show disqualifying status; and • Applicant has not previously been denied for a reason that still constitutes a disqualifying status.

  20. 000-010 Issuance of Certificates • Annual Certificates • Within 25 days of issuance of a temporary certificate, the City shall take whatever steps it deems necessary to verify the truthfulness and completeness of the application; and • Issue written notice either that the certificate will be issued or that it will be denied, listing grounds for denial.

  21. 000-014 Denial of Certificate • Temporary certificate shall be denied for failure of any requirement for issuance. • Annual certificate shall be denied for: • Incomplete or incorrect information on application. • Previously unknown or undisclosed disqualifying status. • Failure to complete payment of fee. • Applicant’s newly disqualifying status since applying. • Substantiated Report of misconduct received subsequent to application.

  22. Notice of Denial or Suspension • Written notice of denial or suspension shall be sent in the manner indicated on the application, and shall specify grounds and documentation and availability of review, and 10-day period for appeal, and the date the denial or suspension will take effect. • Absent exigent circumstances such that continued licensing threatens health, safety or welfare of any individuals or entities within the City, denial or suspension shall not be effective before 2 calendar days after notice is sent.

  23. 000-015 Appeal • Must be submitted in writing within 10 days. • Review by appeals officer is de novo. • Decision on appeal must be rendered within 15 calendar days from the date the appeal was taken.

  24. 000-016 Deceptive Soliciting Practices Prohibited • No materially false or fraudulent statements; • Solicitors must immediately disclose • Solicitor’s name; • Name and address of entity represented; and • Purpose of contact. • Solicitors shall not represent that certificate implies endorsement by city.

  25. 000-017 No Solicitation Notice • Occupants may post “no solicitation” notices on or near main entrance door or property line adjacent to sidewalk leading to residence. • Solicitors have the responsibility to check for “no solicitation” notice. • It is a violation to knock, ring doorbell, or otherwise attempt to attract attention of an occupant of a residence with a no solicitation notice.

  26. 000-018 Duties of Solicitors • It is a violation to employ a ruse, deception, or fraudulent concealment of a purpose to solicit. • Solicitor must immediately and peacefully depart at any time when asked to leave, and not continue repeated soliciting after a person has communicated clearly and unequivocally lack of interest. • Solicitor shall not intentionally or recklessly touch another person without consent. • Solicitor shall not enter a residence without the resident’s explicit consent. • Solicitor shall not use obscene language or gestures. • Solicitation only after 9:00 a.m. and before 9:00 p.m.

  27. 000-021 Penalties • Violation of the ordinance is a class B misdemeanor.

  28. Issues • Same business day issuance of temporary certificates and identification badge. • Paper carrier seeking to increase subscriptions. • Realtors.

  29. Conclusion • The Model Solicitation Ordinance is not perfect, but it is a workable compromise between the Kirby litigation plaintiffs and the defendants’ counsel in those cases. • The Model Ordinance is not the only ordinance that will pass constitutional scrutiny, but it is the only ordinance to adopt that will bar suit.