Ragnar arnason a review of international experiences with itqs
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 5

Ragnar Arnason: A Review of International Experiences with ITQs PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 92 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Ragnar Arnason: A Review of International Experiences with ITQs. Background information United States is the 5 th largest fishing nation. Basic fisheries management law in US is Magnuson – Stevens Fishery and management act. (8 regional mgt. councils).

Download Presentation

Ragnar Arnason: A Review of International Experiences with ITQs

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Ragnar arnason a review of international experiences with itqs

Ragnar Arnason: A Review of International Experiences with ITQs

Background information

  • United States is the 5th largest fishing nation.

  • Basic fisheries management law in US is Magnuson – Stevens Fishery and management act. (8 regional mgt. councils).

  • ITQs established in 4 fisheries in 1990s with some degree of success, two more proposed in late 1990s, blocked by congress

  • Currently only three ITQ managed fisheries in USA.

    Three fisheries are (1) Ocean quahog and surf clams fisheries

    (2) Atlantic wreckfish fishery

    (3) North Pacific Halibut/Sablefish fisheries


Ragnar arnason a review of international experiences with itqs

Discussion of (1) Ocean quahog and surf clams fisheries.

  • Initial allocation based on historical catch record

  • Ownership of a vessel is not a requirement for holding a quota

  • ITQs are freely tradable, anyone can hold ITQ, no upper limits on size of ownership except to the extent it may violate US Antitrust Laws.

  • Substantial trade in quotas => in first two years number of vessels reduced from 128 to 59, and then in next few years down to 35.

  • Following intro of ITQ, enforcement costs plummeted. A lot of detailed conservation regulations became redundant, could be scrapped.


Ragnar arnason a review of international experiences with itqs

Discussion of (2) Atlantic Wreckfish fishery.

  • ½ of initial allocation based on vessel owner catch record

  • ½ divided equally to all that had a history of participation in fishery.

  • ITQs are freely tradable

  • Substantial trade in quotas => vessels reduced from 90 to 40 in first two years, and in next few years down to 9.

  • Cost of enforcement reduced under ITQ. Coupons followed the landed fish through purchasing chain, thus making it possible to verify landing receipts.

    Question: What about the fact that only 1/10 the vessels remain? Author did not mention this.


Ragnar arnason a review of international experiences with itqs

Discussion of (3) North Pacific Halibut/Sablefish fisheries.

  • Initial allocation only to vessel owners and lessors that had landings in at least one of the years 88-90.

  • Quota associated with a vessel. Owner has to be on vessel when quota is caught. Transferability restricted to the same vessel class.

    Question: When above restrictions diminish value of quotas, who’s interest do they serve?

  • ITQ trade/holdings subject to a number of restrictions that are constantly evolving.

  • Cost of enforcement decreased. Everyone gets a debit card.


Ragnar arnason a review of international experiences with itqs

Summary: Anecdotal evidence of increased compliance and increased resource stewardship under the three ITQ systems.

e.g. Fisherman voluntarily removed bottom longlines known to damage corals from their arsenal.

Question: Why does the US only have three ITQ managed fisheries?


  • Login