Recent developments in productivity measurement
1 / 28

Recent developments in productivity measurement - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

Recent developments in productivity measurement. Paul Schreyer OECD Statistics Directorate Canberra, 20 November 2012. Introduction. Productivity = output/input Issues: Identifying , measuring and aggregating inputs and outputs Level of measurement ( economy , industry , firm )

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' Recent developments in productivity measurement' - yehudi

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Recent developments in productivity measurement

Recent developments in productivity measurement

Paul Schreyer

OECD StatisticsDirectorate

Canberra, 20 November 2012


  • Productivity = output/input

  • Issues:

    • Identifying, measuring and aggregating inputs and outputs

    • Level of measurement (economy, industry, firm)

  • Academiccommunitydealingwithproductivitymeasurement and analysis

  • World KLEMS network

  • NSOs: no clear trend

This presentation
This presentation

Bringing nature into the productivitypicture

The firmlevel: productivitymeasurementwith micro-data

No claim for comprehensivepresentation of recentdevelopments

Bringing nature into the productivitypicture

Bringing nature into the picture input side 1
Bringing nature into the picture – input side (1)

  • Typical inputs: labour, produced capital, intermediate inputs

  • Often neglected: non-producednatural assets:

    • Mineral resources

    • Soil/land

    • Timber

    • Aquatic resources

    • Water

Bringing nature into the picture input side 2
Bringing nature into the picture – input side (2)

  • Why important?

    • Assessing contribution of naturalassets to economicgrowth

    • Measuringproductivitycorrectly

    • Policy implication: isgrowthdriven by MFP or by naturalassets

    • Note: withoutmeasurement, direction of biasunknown

Volume index of subsoil asset removals australia 1989 100
Volume index of subsoilassetremovals, Australia, 1989=100

Source: OECD calculations, based on ABS data.

No unambiguous direction
No unambiguous direction

Effect of includingnaturalresource input on measuredproductivitygrowth:

  • Traditional MFP > adjusted MFP if :

    • naturalresource input growth > traditional input growth

    • i.e., total input growth has been understated

    • i.e., traditional MFP growth has been overstated

  • And vice versa

Norway difference between adjusted and traditional mfp growth
Norway – Difference between adjusted and traditional MFP growth

Traditional MFP over-stated

Traditional MFP under-stated

Source: OECD, work in progroess.

Challenge quality of natural resource input
Challenge: growthquality of naturalresource input

Capture changingmarginal extraction costs (whichmaybeincreasing)

Capturingchangingquality in the resourceitselfegdecliningsoilquality

 failing to do sowilloverstatemeasured contribution of naturalresource to output and understate MFP

Effects on productivity measures australia s mining industry
Effects growth on productivitymeasures: Australia’sminingindustry

Study by Productivity Commission (Topp, Soames, Parham, Bloch 2008):

Similar in spirit except that mining output is adjusted for declining yields

Underlying rate of productivity growth is around 2.5 per cent p. a., compared with stagnant standard MFP (1974 to 2007)

Natural resource input has grownlessquicklythanother inputs, so MFP wasunderstated by traditionalmeasure

Bringing nature into the picture output side 1
Bringing growth nature into the picture – output side (1)

  • Production processesoftenaccompanied by undesirable outputs, e.g., emissions

  • Fromproducer and MFP measurement perspective:

  • Relevant in presence of environmentalpolicies:

    • explicit price (e.g., tax) or

    • implicitprice (marginal abatementcosts due to regulation)

  • Are traditional MFP measures over-or understated?

Again no unambiguous effect on measured productivity 1
Again growth, no unambiguouseffect on measuredproductivity (1)


  • Given inputs (labour, capital,…)

  • Risingtraditional output

  • Constant emissions

  • adjusted MFP > traditional MFP

  • Productivitygrowthwasrequired to keepemissionsatbay

Again no unambiguous effect on measured productivity 2
Again growth, no unambiguouseffect on measuredproductivity (2)

But overstatement of traditional MFP if emissionsgrowquickerthantraditional output

For manypollutants (NOx, Sox, CO2,…) relative decoupling in many OECD countries

 Understatement of traditional MFP

Private and social valuation
Private growth and social valuation

  • Producer perspective = privatevaluation

    • marginal abatementcost for producer

  • Welfare perspective = social valuation

    • marginal cost to society = producercosts + consumer costs + externalities

  • Both perspectives meaningful but should not be mixed up

  • If productivitymeasurementisbased on producertheory, producer perspective iscalled for

Oecd work in this area
OECD growthwork in this area…

  • As part of green growthindicatorwork

    • MFP adjustmentwithnaturalasset inputs

    • MFP adjustmentwithundesirable outputs

    • Index of naturalresources

Important international development seea
Important international growthdevelopment: SEEA

  • System of IntegratedEnvironmental and EconomicAccounts

  • Adoptedat UN level in 2012

  • Consistent accounting for environment-economy interaction

  • Basis for indicatorwork

  • Unifyingelement: balance sheets

    • Stocks, additions, removals

    • Physical and monetaryvaluation

  • Major taskahead: implementation

The growthfirmlevel: productivitymeasurementwith micro-data

Firm level measurement
Firm-level measurement growth

  • Drawbacks

    • No prices, capital proxy, employees, incomplete sector coverage, short time-spans

  • Avantages

    • Entry, exit, reallocation

    • Within-firm cycle/growth

    • Understanding/measuring both firm-level levers and environmental factors driving growth

Stylised facts from micro estimates 1
Stylised growthfactsfrom micro estimates (1)

  • Hugeproductivity dispersion

    • Evenwithinverynarrowlydefined industries

    • Firm size plays an important role

    • But how accurately are outputs measured?

Uk labour productivity by firm size
UK: Labour productivity by firm size growth

Source: J. Saleheen, Bank of England 2012

Stylised facts from micro estimates 2
Stylised growthfactsfrom micro estimates (2)

Reallocation or resources to high-productivityproducers important

Competition—consumers can easily switch suppliers

Labor and capital market flexibility

Summary measure of reallocation: correlation between productivity and market share

Correlation between productivity and market share
Correlation between Productivity and Market Share growth

Source: Ch. SyversonNovember 2012

Firm level measurement requires dealing with
Firm growth-levelmeasurementrequiresdealingwith…

  • Large volumes of data

  • Confidentiality issues

    • Small countries

    • Narrowlydefined industries

  • No international standards – reducedcomparability

  • NSOs have taken up issue

Conclusions growth

Conclusions 1
Conclusions (1) growth

Nature of productivityimplies cumulation of measurement challenges

Quality of source data (national accounts, firm-level data) key

Integratingproductivitymeasurementinto official statistics important but not yetwidespread

Conclusions 2
Conclusions (2) growth

  • Tricky output measurement in particular in:

    • Financial services

    • Health, education, general administration

    • Undesirable outputs

  • Tricky input measurement:

    • Hoursworked by industry and by skills

    • R&D capital (new in national accounts)

    • Natural capital

  • Intangibles

Thank growthyou!