Pyrosequencing Is an Effective Tool for Rapid Detection of Extensively Drug Resistant Tuberculosis Lin S-Y G 1 , Nguyen D 1 , Arroyo F 1 , Kaping J 2 , Rodrigues C 3 , Coetzee G 4 , Victor T 5 , Crudu V 6 , Gler T 7 , Garfein R 2 , Catanzaro A 2 , and Desmond E 1 .
of Extensively Drug Resistant TuberculosisLin S-Y G1, Nguyen D1, Arroyo F1, Kaping J2, Rodrigues C3, Coetzee G4, Victor T5, Crudu V6, Gler T7, Garfein R2, Catanzaro A2, and Desmond E1 .
CA Dept of Public Health1, UC San Diego2, Hinduja National Hospital, India3, National Health Lab Services, South Africa4, Stellenbosch Univ, South Africa5, Institute of Phthisiopneumology, Moldova6, Makati Medical Center, Philippines7
1). Used PyroMark Assay Design software to design 8 sets of primers for amplification and sequencing.
2). Tested 166 isolates from 4 sites (India, S. Africa, Moldova and Philippines) using PyroMark Q96 ID.
3). Performed phenotypic drug susceptibility testing using MGIT 960.
Background: Extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis (XDR TB) poses a threat to the global effort to combat tuberculosis (TB). The need for early detection of drug resistant TB is urgent. Molecular detection of mutations associated with drug resistance is a valuable new tool for rapid screening for XDR TB. We developed 8 assays for detecting mutations using pyrosequencing (PSQ), and characterized the performance of these assays.
Method: This study included 166 strains submitted from 4 international laboratories serving areas with high MDR TB prevalence. Eight PSQ assays were to identify Mycobacterium tuberculosis targeting IS6110, and to detect mutations associated with drug resistance that defines XDR TB. The gene targets are katG, inhA promoter and ahpC-oxyR intergenic region for isoniazid (INH), rpoB core region for rifampin (RIF), gyrA for moxifloxacin (MOX) and ofloxacin (OFX) and rrs for amikacin (AMK), kanamycin (KAN) and capreomycin (CAP). The 8 assays were performed under the same PCR & PSQ conditions. The PSQ results were compared to drug susceptibility testing (DST) results using MGIT 960 and the critical concentrations recommended by WHO.
Results: The overall agreement between PSQ and MGIT DST, and the sensitivity and specificity for detection of resistance to each drug are shown in the table. Because the specificity for INH, OFX, AMK and KAN was 100%, when a mutation is detected, the accuracy of prediction for resistance to those drugs is also 100%. Among the 14 different mutations we detected in rpoB, D516Y (n=3) and H526N did not confer RIF-resistance as determined by MGIT DST.
Conclusion: This study shows PSQ is a rapid method with reliable performance for screening for drug resistance. PSQ by generating sequence data is extremely useful for identifying predominant mutations, novel mutations and mutations that are known not to confer resistance, thus preventing incorrect prediction of drug resistance.
Keywords: Pyrosequencing, drug resistance mutations, XDR TB.
Acknowledgment: This study was funded by NIAID (U01 AI 82229-03; PI: A. Catanzaro) through the Global Consortium for Drug Resistant TB Diagnostics (GCDD).
1). To develop assays for detection of mutations in genes associated with XDR TB by using pyrosequencing technology.
2). Tocharacterize the performance of those assay for rapid detection of XDR TB.
* Mutations in rpoB are not always associated with RIF resistance. With establishment of RIF MIC for each mutation, the specificity for RIF is 100%.
Conclusions & Discussions