1 / 22

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). We can work it out! . Presented by: Keith Gagnon, MBA, VCO Procurement Management Account Executive Department of General Services Division of Purchases & Supply. Session Agenda. What is ADR ADR Law and Policy in the Commonwealth Types of ADR

virote
Download Presentation

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Alternative DisputeResolution (ADR) We can work it out! Presented by: Keith Gagnon, MBA, VCO Procurement Management Account Executive Department of General Services Division of Purchases & Supply DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  2. Session Agenda • What is ADR • ADR Law and Policy in the Commonwealth • Types of ADR • Neutrals • Advantages/disadvantages of ADR • Interagency Dispute Resolution Advisory Council • DPS ADR in procurement survey • Other resources DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  3. What is ADR? • Alternative Dispute Resolution • Any method of settling a dispute outside of adjudication (i.e. outside of court) • Dispute Resolution Proceeding • means any structured process in which a neutralassistsparties to a dispute in reaching avoluntarysettlement by means of dispute resolution processes such as mediation, conciliation, facilitation, partnering, fact-finding, neutral evaluation, use of ombudsmen or any other proceeding leading to avoluntary settlement. For the purposes of this chapter, the term "dispute resolution proceeding"does not include arbitration. • Code of Virginia §2.2-4115 DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  4. Avoidance Dispute Resolution Spectrum No dispute AdministrativeProcess ADR Litigation Violence DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  5. What is ADR? • Essential Elements of ADR (O’Leary and Raines, 2001) • The parties must agree to participate in the process. • The parties, or their representatives, must directly participate in the process. • A neutral third party may facilitate the process, but cannot impose a solution (i.e. does not include binding arbitration.) • The parties must agree on any outcome or any solution to the dispute. • Any party may withdraw from the process at any time and seek resolution of the dispute through other means. DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  6. ADR and the Code of Virginia • VADRA – Virginia Administrative Dispute Resolution Act (§2.2-4115 through 4119) • Encourages the use of ADR by local governments and state agencies across a broad range of governmental functions • Requires each executive branch agency to appoint a Dispute Resolution Coordinator • Creates an Interagency Dispute Resolution Advisory Council • Requires each agency to develop ADR policies • Excludes binding arbitration (§2.2-4115, §2.2-4116) DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  7. ADR and Our Manuals • APSPM 11.4 • Hand out contains section 11.4 • DPS allows ADR for contractual disputes (post award) only • Note: VITA allows ADR for pre award and post award disputes • General Term and Condition B • Hand out contains General T&C B • Vendor’s Manual 9.17 • Same language as APSPM 11.4 DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  8. Types of ADR • Partnering • No third party • Preventative technique • “Workshop” held shortly after a contract is signed to: • Engage in teambuilding before any issues arise • Develop relationships to avoid conflict • Identify potential future disputes • Tailor resolution methods for each potential dispute • Proactive DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  9. Types of ADR Interest-Based Problem Solving • No third party • Separate the person from the problem • Parties agree to use an interest based model: • Set communication & decision ground rules • Define identify issues, criteria for success • Brainstorm • Proactive DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  10. Types of ADR Fact-Finding • Expert Neutral used to investigate/resolve disputed facts • Used to resolve technical/factual issues • May be a precursor to additional ADR DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  11. Types of ADR Early Neutral Evaluation • Neutral evaluates merits of each party’s position on a dispute when it first arises • Neutral is a subject matter expert • Neutral presents opinion • Parties negotiate a solution after hearing the Neutral’s opinion DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  12. Types of ADR Mediation • Mediator (neutral) facilitates a structured process in which parties negotiate resolution • Mediator is an impartial facilitator and does not decide anything • Self-determination is an integral to the process • Goals of mediation: • Help parties see each other’s perspective • Clear up misunderstandings • Determine underlying interests • Help parties create their own solution based on overlapping interests DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  13. Types of ADR Arbitration • Adjudication using a private judge • Can be binding or non-binding • Arbitrator (or arbitration panel) agreed to by parties • Arbitrator, not the parties, make the decision Arbitration is expressly excluded from VADRA DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  14. Types of ADR Other Types of ADR • Many other methods • You may use (or develop) any that is appropriate • As long as both parties agree to the method • As long as costs of the ADR proceeding are shared equally • As long as the process is non-binding • As long as you get approval of your legal representative DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  15. Neutrals • Neutral means an individual who is trained or experienced in conducting dispute resolution proceedings and in providing dispute resolution services • The Interagency Advisory Council on ADR is in the process of creating a shared pool of neutrals • Types: • Ombuds, Facilitator, Mediator, Arbitrator, etc. DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  16. Advantages of ADR • Avoids litigation • Avoids setting precedents • Faster than litigation • Cheaper than litigation • Easier, less formal • Less adversarial/confrontational • Creative process tailored to the specific conflict • Parties retain control through consensual process • Can be more confidential (see § 2.2-4119) • Relationship can be preserved • Either party can stop process at any time DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  17. Disadvantages of ADR • Avoids litigation (when it is desired/needed) • Avoids setting precedents (when one is needed) • Requires commitment/buy-in from both parties • Can create imbalance of power/two-tier justice • It is not a completely public process (when public proceeding is desired) DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  18. Interagency DisputeResolution Advisory Council • Created by VADRA • Chaired by the Secretary of Administration • Powers and duties: • Create training seminars and education programs • Publish educational materials • Report on ADR activities • http://www.vadra.virginia.gov DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  19. DP&S ADR Survey • Survey of agencies under DPS procurement purview regarding ADR utilization • Utilization of ADR for procurement/contracting down in FY07 from previous years for agencies under DPS purview • Encourage agencies to use ADR for preventing and resolving disputes DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  20. Additional Resources • Interagency Dispute Resolution Advisory Council www.vadra.virginia.gov • Your agency’s Dispute Resolution Coordinator • Your OAG representative • American Bar Association - Section of Public Contract Law • NIGP • DGS/DPS DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  21. References • O’Leary, R., & Raines (2001). Lessons from Two Decades of Alternative Dispute Resolution at the Environmental Protection Agency. Public Administration Review, 61(6), 683. • Virginia's Interagency Advisory Council on ADR. VADRA website, www.vadra.virginia.gov DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

  22. QuestionsandDiscussion DGS: Division of Purchases and Supply

More Related