1 / 23

Lecture 4

Lecture 4. Introduction to Tax Laws Income on Ordinary Concepts. Isolated Transactions. Myer ME business - retailer, here financing t/a sold pty to sub for lump sum to be repaid at interest assignment of income stream to Citicorp for approx. $45M. Isolated Transactions.

vaughn
Download Presentation

Lecture 4

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Lecture 4 Introduction to Tax Laws Income on Ordinary Concepts

  2. Isolated Transactions • Myer • ME business - retailer, here financing t/a • sold pty to sub for lump sum to be repaid at interest • assignment of income stream to Citicorp for approx. $45M

  3. Isolated Transactions • Myer - High Court held it was income • Isolated business or commercial transaction • Entered into with the intention or purpose of making a profit or gain • Potential Issues • are all receipts of a business ordinary income?

  4. Isolated Transactions • Post Myer Case • Moana Sands (1988) • dual purpose of acquisition - sand mining and potential resale at a profit • compulsory acq’n by Govt • profit assessable as ordinary income - even though profit realised by a different means to that intended. • Ct said sufficient fulfillment of the profit making purpose

  5. Post Myer Cases • Spedley Securities • Merchant bank engaged to raise finance • cancellation of agreement re finance raising • capital receipts • evidence that SS’s reputation (goodwill) may have been damaged. • Part of receipt may have been for commission- but non-distinguishable portion- McLaurin & Allsops principle applied

  6. Post Myer Cases • Westfield (important case) • taxpayer’s business “constructing,designing,letting and managing shopping centres” • acquired options over certain land - option exercised • purpose - was to hold land as part of “land bank” • land sold at a profit • capital amount • redefinition of Myer

  7. Post Myer Cases • Hill J - Where t/a is outside the ordinary course of taxpayer’s bus. - profit not income unless: • transaction of commercial or business nature • at the time of entering into the t/a - taxpayer had a profit making intention • taxpayer did profit by the means which it intended to profit

  8. TR 92/3 - Profits from an Isolated Transaction • TR92/3 - • Para 6 - general rule • para 7 - objective analysis of a subjective purpose • para 13 - when does a t/a have bus or commercial character • potential discrepancy - para 14 and Westfield

  9. Mere Realisation vs Carrying on a Business • Property development focus: • Californian Copper Syndicate (1904) (UK) • acquisition of copper bearing land • land sold in exchange for shares in the purchaser company • LJ Clerk * comments in study guide • income - speculative business

  10. Mere Realisation cont.. • Scottish Australian Mining (1950) • land acquired for a coal mining purpose • after coal expired - active dev’pt activity • tp’r constructed roads, a railway station and set side land for school,church and park • “mere realisation in an enterprising way” • Not good authority after Westfield

  11. Mere Realisation cont.. • Whitford Beach (1982) • land originally acquired for purposes of access to beach • new owners - change of M + A -change of purpose • Gibbs J • focus on shareholders intentions/purpose re acquisition of shares • more than mere realisation

  12. Whitford Beach (1982):- • Mason J • size and scale of project • massive expenditure • Profit emerging basis of assessment - net profit not gross profit

  13. Mere realisation cont.. • Statham (1989) • small scale development • no active role of taxpayer • pty not acquired for purposes of resale at a profit • capital

  14. Mere realisation cont.. • Limited involvement of taxpayer • Active role of council in disposing of the land

  15. Trading on Know-how • General Principles - know how can be a capital asset of a business • once for all disposal vs trading on know how. • Evans Medical • pharmaceutical business in Burma • extinguishment of business • capital

  16. Know-how cont.. • Rolls Royce • large number of agreements to sell know related to airplane engines etc. • amounted to expansion of business of taxpayer • repetition of activity • income

  17. Know-how cont.. • Murray • exclusive license arrangements • taxpayer gave up rights to conduct business in those countries • capital • Consider Capital Gains Tax (CGT) • CGT Event K1 • definition in Div 373

  18. Know-how cont.. • Sec 6(1) definition of royalties • royalties are assessable as ordinary income and under Sec.6-5/15-20 ITAA 97

  19. Compensation for contractual losses • General Principles - what is the comp’n for? • Capital assets of business v lost profits • Californian oil products (payment for cessation of agency business - capital) • Cf: Heavy minerals (payment for cancelling a trading contract - income)

  20. Compensation for Contractual Losses • When is a contract part of the business structure? • Van Den Bergh • contracts formed part of the structure of the business • “the contracts were not ordinary commercial contracts but related to the fundamental structure of the profit making business” • Question of Degree - Allied Mills Industries • these contracts had no element of permanence about them.

  21. Income Substitution Payments • Phillip’s • MD of a theatre company for a period of 10 years. Contract cancelled after 6 years. • Myer • The receipt of the interest income would have been assessable anyway.

  22. Consideration for restrictive covenants and trade ties • Employment Relationships - Higgs v Olivier - FCT v Woite • Business Relationship - Dickenson

  23. CGT and Restrictive Covenants • CGT - CGT Event D1 - CGT Event H2 • Nb: Trades Practices Act

More Related