1 / 12

Developing a research question and research topic

Developing a research question and research topic. Hans P. Binswanger- Mkhize Visiting Professor China Agricultural University May 3, 2013. Start with a policy-relevant question. Directly relevant: it answers a specific question how much to invest in agricultural research?

uyen
Download Presentation

Developing a research question and research topic

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Developing a research question and research topic Hans P. Binswanger-Mkhize Visiting Professor China Agricultural University May 3, 2013

  2. Start with a policy-relevant question • Directly relevant: it answers a specific question • how much to invest in agricultural research? • what incentives to provide to researchers to increase their productivity? • Whether to subsidize agricultural mechanization? • Indirectly relevant: It analyzes an underlying behavior or theory: • What motivates people to buy pension insurance? • Is the induced innovation theory correct? • You can test relevance of the question • What difference would it make if answer is yes or no

  3. How do you find such a question? • The question is important for your employer or funder • Risk research at ICRISAT; research on impact of credit at the World Bank • The question knocks at your door • Testing induced innovation hypothesis • Research on herbicides at ICRISAT • Research on decentralization, community empowerment, and rural development

  4. More ways to find a question • It can come up in your courses • Via knowledge of literature, and additional review • Research on: What is the historic origin of large scale farm systems around the world? • A major insight during research leads to new questions • Why do village money lenders not lend out deposits? • Led to work on covariant risk and production relations in agriculture • Other lucky breaks

  5. The answer should be unknown, i.e. not answered by previous research • A globally unsolved question • It is not easy to find such questions • or to answer them, • otherwise someone else would already have done so • Examples • Is the induced innovation theory of Hayami and Ruttan correct? • How does risk aversion influence investment of farmers? • What is the historic origin of large scale farms? • You will easily be able to publish in global journals

  6. Answer not known in your country, region or sector • Example: What are the recent changes in economies of scale in chinese farming? • Relevant to the proposed changes in land laws • Approaches and techniques are known • Publish globally or nationally, depending on how generalized the interest in the answer is • You must do the literature review • to find out whether the question is already answered • to find out how to answer the question

  7. Finding a question for an especially rich data set • Example: We may have a new especially rich panel survey of household incomes and behaviors and their rural governments • There are lots of questions that you can answer with such multi-purpose data sets. • But first you must have an interesting question • Try to figure out one for yourself • Dialogue with your advisors, or with another user of the data set. • Example: What is the impact of local government expenditures on household incomes, their farm production, health, education……?

  8. Finding a question for a specific technique • Eg: I want to use principle components analysis, an economic experiment, or a programming model • Not generally a good idea • Techniques are like tools: You use a hammer for putting in nails, and a screwdriver for putting in a screw. • There is nothing specially good about the hammer versus the screwdriver, or about econometrics versus experimental techniques • So you need to choose the tool to fit the question • Simple partial budgeting • Analysis of survey data • Econometrics • Controlled Experiments • Modeling

  9. But there are exceptions: • If you master a technique, people seek your help for their topic. You are their consultant and/or collaborator, and can become a co-author • Or a technique is very new, and there are many unanswered issues • Esther Duflo only uses randomized experiments to evaluate impact of approaches to development • She has the whole World to choose from for interesting problems • Example: Microfinance in Hyderabad: no impact on consumption, education, health, women empowerment, but impact on durable goods spending and new businesses

  10. Using the right data • First try to find data that is already available • But the right data may not exist • Measurement of risk, risk aversion in India • Adoption of mechanization in Africa • Impact of land rights in Africa • Impact of governance arrangements on village development in India or China • Then you have to develop the data from scratch • Or sometimes the data exist, but data components are missing: add the missing data • That is a lot of effort. Therefore • Make sure the data can answer the question • If not you are wasting your time

  11. How to establish causal relations Topic of my next lecture

  12. Summary Criteria for Research Question • Are you really interested in it? • Is it policy relevant, directly, or indirectly? • For whom? • What difference would alternative answers make? • Is the answer unknown? • Globally or locally? • In terms of methods and/or results • What data are needed? • Are they already available, or at least partially available • Do they have to be collected from scratch

More Related