1 / 12

The Lessons of the Lotus MarketPlace: Implications for Consumer Privacy in the 1990's

The Lessons of the Lotus MarketPlace: Implications for Consumer Privacy in the 1990's . Mary J. Culnan . Lotus MarketPlace: Households . Joint venture between Equifax (Credit Bureau) Lotus (software)

twila
Download Presentation

The Lessons of the Lotus MarketPlace: Implications for Consumer Privacy in the 1990's

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Lessons of the Lotus MarketPlace: Implications for Consumer Privacy in the 1990's Mary J. Culnan

  2. Lotus MarketPlace: Households • Joint venture between • Equifax (Credit Bureau) • Lotus (software) • Provide names, addresses, demographic and prior purchase behavior data for 120 million U.S. consumers on a CD-ROM

  3. Consumer Objections • Secondary use of identifiable personal information without their consent • Equifax had no plans to notify consumers that personal data from their credit reports would be used in a new direct marketing product, MarketPlace

  4. Violates Fundamental Privacy Principle Personal information collected for one purpose should not be used for other purposes without the consent of the individual . 1973 "Code of Fair Information Practices"

  5. Lacked Centralized Database Controls • End-user owned the database and controlled its use • Could build lists using selection criteria • Lists could be exported for unrestricted use

  6. Consumer Perspective“How Did They Get My Name?” • Consumers clearly want to control who has the right to access their personal information • The ability of a large company to collect and sell personal data clearly surprised and shocked most consumers when they learned about MarketPlace, resulting in a storm of complaints • More than 30,000 individuals exercised the option to "opt out."

  7. Corporate Perspective: "What's the Big Deal?" • Lotus- “MarketPlace was only providing small businesses with a means to access the same information that was already available to larger firms “ • Equifax survey - majority of consumers believe that individuals have lost all control over how personal information is circulated and used by companies.

  8. Mailing Lists Consumers do not understand the: • scope of the mailing list business in the United States • extent to which personal information is currently collected, merged, sold or exchanged • mechanisms that exist for having one's name removed from mailing lists

  9. Lobbying in the Information Age: "It's a Brand New Ballgame" • New age of the electronic grassroots lobbyist • Much of the opposition to MarketPlace was mobilized, individual by individual, on "the net" • Power of the electronic media to effectively mobilize a national constituency independent of any of the traditional "big money" special interest groups should not be underestimated

  10. Lessons:Where do we go from here? • Proper information agreement between the public and list compilers • Individuals who speak out can effect change • Patronizing firms with good privacy practices • Direct Marketing Association (DMA) • Develop voluntary privacy protection programs

  11. Firms need to do a better job of educating the public • Consumers should be informed of recordkeeping practices and should be provided with options about the subsequent of use personal information

  12. Firms can gain competitive advantage from their privacy policies • Detailed knowledge about consumer preferences is increasingly valuable to decision makers in the competitive global environment • Enhanced capabilities for surveillance, storage, retrieval, analysis, and communication of personal information

More Related