1 / 50

The Phosphorus Cycle

The Phosphorus Cycle. Jen Morse morsej@caryinstitute.org 10 January 2013. Is the Phosphorus Cycle important?. Global P cycle in Schlesinger 1997: 3 pages (vs 13 for N) Terrestrial P cycling in Chapin 2002: 4 pages (vs 18 for N) Phosphorus cycling is: A) Simple B) Boring C) Not important.

Download Presentation

The Phosphorus Cycle

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Phosphorus Cycle Jen Morse morsej@caryinstitute.org 10 January 2013

  2. Is the Phosphorus Cycle important? • Global P cycle in Schlesinger 1997: 3 pages (vs 13 for N) • Terrestrial P cycling in Chapin 2002: 4 pages (vs 18 for N) • Phosphorus cycling is: • A) Simple • B) Boring • C) Not important

  3. Questions to consider • What makes phosphorus important? • Phosphorus cycling: • How does global cycle P differ from N? • Forms, pools, fluxes • P cycling in soils vs. inland waters vs. marine systems • Controls on availability & interactions with other elements • Why care about ecosystem P inputs and losses?

  4. Biological importance of PEnergy and evolution • DNA, RNA • ATP  energy transformations • Phospholipids  cell membrane structure • Bones and teeth of vertebrates ATP DNA

  5. Phosphorus basics: • 11th most abundant element on land, 13th in seawater (Smil 2000) • Elemental P: highly reactive • Isolated from urine by Hennig Brandt in 1669 • Glows and spontaneously reacts: alchemy... matches... explosives • Only 31P is stable; radioisotopes include 32P,33P • Stable isotope ecology methods don’t apply for P

  6. Calliergon giganteum. Photo by F. R. Wesley.

  7. P has similar oxidation states to N... R-NH2, NH4+ NO3- NO2- NO N2O N2 +2 +5 +3 +1 0 -3 PO43- (inorganic), P(=O)(OR)3 (phosphate esters) P(OR)3 (phosphite esters) Elemental P (highly reactive) PH3(phosphine) +2 +1 +5 +3 0 -3 ... but no critical redox transformations or significant gas phase.

  8. Questions to consider • What makes phosphorus important? • Phosphorus cycling: • How does global cycle P differ from N? • Forms, pools, fluxes • P cycling in soils vs. inland waters vs. marine systems • Controls on availability & interactions with other elements • Why care about phosphorus inputs and losses?

  9. Nutrient inputs Internal cycling Ecosystem Nutrient losses Chapin et al. (2002)

  10. Chemical weathering of rocks • Biological fixation • Deposition from atmosphere • Fertilizers • Transfer of nutrients • Between plants/primary producers and soil/benthos • Between organic and inorganic forms • Changes in ionic forms • Biological uptake • Interactions with mineral surfaces • Leaching • Trace gas emissions • Wind and water erosion • Fire • Harvest Nutrient inputs Internal cycling Ecosystem Nutrient losses Chapin et al. (2002)

  11. Chemical weathering of rocks • Biological fixation • Deposition from atmosphere • Fertilization • Transfer of nutrients • Between plants/primary producers and soil/benthos • Between organic and inorganic forms • Changes in ionic forms • Biological uptake • Interactions with mineral surfaces • Leaching • Trace gas emissions • Wind and water erosion • Fire • Harvest P inputs Internal cycling Ecosystem P losses Chapin et al. (2002)

  12. N most abundant in atmosphere... (N fluxes in Tg/yr) Chapin et al. (2002) Fig. 15.4

  13. ... most P stored in soils, sediments, ocean (P fluxes in Tg/yr) Chapin et al. (2002) Fig 15.6

  14.  P becomes available at LONG time scales Thousands to millions of years Decades, Accelerated by human activities

  15. Biologically available P is limited by parent material and supply • Relatively scarce (localized) in mineral form, low solubility in water • Ultimately tends to limit production: • In aquatic systems • Terrestrially at long time scales Bennett & Schipanski (2013) redrawn from Walker & Syers (1976) and Vitousek et al. (2010)

  16. Nutrient limitation during ecosystem development Fertilization experiment: Hawai’ian tree diameter across chronosequence plots Younger soils more N-limited Oldest soils more P-limited (but co-limitation is important) Model applies to terrestrial ecosystems: Tropics vs. temperate zones Vitousek & Farrington (1997)

  17. Atmospheric P inputs • Sources: • Arid lands in Asia and N. Africa • Deposition zones: • *highly weathered, humid tropical forests • Amazon • Caribbean • Congo • *Open ocean

  18. P cycling in soils High pH biota Ca-P (soil solution) Active SOM Fe/Al-P Low pH Passive Adapted from Brady & Weill (1999) INORGANIC P ORGANIC P

  19. Mineral P forms in soils Fixation by hydrous oxides of Fe, Al, and Mg Brady & Weill (2001)

  20. Sources of P in soils: Weathering Ca5(PO4)3 + 4H2CO3 5Ca2+ + 3HPO42- + 4HCO3- + H2O Apatite (mineral) Bio-available P Weathering factors: Climate Parent material Topography Time Biota (Jenny 1941) Carbonic acid (CO2 from respiration e.g. plant roots)

  21. Sources of P in soils: Mycorrhizal fungi  organic and inorganic P Brady & Weill (1999)

  22. Sources of P in soils: (Phosphatase) enzymes  organic P Species A Species B Species C Species D Dissolved phosphate Monoester (labile org P) Diester Inosotol P (refractory) Hypothesis of increasing investment in organic P acquisition Turner (2008)

  23. How important are P inputs relative to internal cycles? Chapin et al. (2002) – Table 8.1

  24. P cycling in water Forms of P in water: DOP • Movement: • water • wind (dust) • animals PIP POP DIP uM P POP Total P (filter) PIP DOP TDP (Total dissolved P) DIP (PO43-) Key additional control: Redox related to element interactions D/P = dissolved/particulate I/O = inorganic/organic

  25. Redox affects P via Fe: Internal eutrophication External P load ↑ production Mixing (without re-ppt) Sedimentation and decomposition ↑ anoxia ↑ sediment P and Fe2+ release Fe3+ reduction in absence of DO (or NO3-) Loss of sorption ability ↓ FeOOH with associated PO43- Bottom water chemistry Fe2+ DIP DO Classic studies: Mortimer, Einsele Current Netherlands focus: Smolders et al. (2006) review Time

  26. As Fe increases in sediments, P may increase ... and may be released under reducing conditions. Fe/Al-P Smolders et al. (2006)

  27. Sulfur can intensify internal eutrophication: SO42- HS- • Alkalinity  • Greater decay rate (acid neutralization) • HCO3- competes with PO43- for anion exchange sites ↑ HCO3- ●= sulfate addition (all in waterlogged conditions) ↑ NH4+ ↑ PO43-

  28. Smolders et al. (2006)

  29. P like N: • Internal cycling dominates P available for plant uptake P unlike N: • No P-focused oxidation-reduction reactions (redox controls are via interactions with other elements) • Using N to obtain P: Microbes (incl. mycorrhizae) & plants produce phosphatases to access organic P • No important gas phase • Main pools in soils/sediments Cycle essentially uni-directional

  30. Questions to consider • Why phosphorus? • Phosphorus cycling • How does global cycle P differ from N? • Forms, pools, fluxes • P cycling in soils vs. inland waters vs. marine systems • Controls on availability & interactions with other elements • Why care about phosphorus inputs and losses?

  31. Humans have modified the P cycle • Flows of P have tripled since 1960 (Milennium Ecosystem Assessment) • P mining expected to peak ~2030 (Cordell et al. 2009) Data from Smil (2000)

  32. Greater accumulation of P in soils… World Cropland P Balance Manure Will long-term P-accumulation drive future exports to surface waters? Extra P Fert. Loss Animal Crop After Bennett et al. (2001)

  33. Leads to greater streamwater P in agricultural and urban areas... Orthophosphate (mg/L) Total P (mg/L) Muhller & Spahr (2006): USGS National Water-Quality Assessment Program, Scientific Investigations Report 2006–5107 Mixed Ag Partial Urban Undevel

  34. Why care about nutrient inputs to aquatic systems? • Eutrophication: “...anthropogenic nutrient loading to aquatic ecosystems (i.e., cultural eutrophication; Hasler 1947) from both point and nonpoint sources typically results in rapid increases in the rate of biological production and significant reductions in water column transparency and can create a wide range of undesirable water quality changes in freshwater and marine ecosystems.” (Smith et al. 2006)

  35. Effects of eutrophication • Marine dinoflagellates: red tides (fish kills, neurotoxins in shellfish) • Freshwater cyanobacteria (neurotoxins, hepatotoxins) • Phytoplankton blooms • Hypoxia/anoxia • Toxicity to wildlife

  36. Cause of eutrophication which nutrient(s)? C? N? P? Classic and ongoing scientific investigations…

  37. P linked to eutrophication in L. Washington... Chl-a Nutrient diversion Total P Year ... but soap/detergent interests suggested that decreases in phytoplankton had caused the decrease in P. Edmondson (1970, 1991....)

  38. Next step: Whole-lake fertilizations, Experimental Lakes Area • P consistently limited growth • C could be obtained from atmospheric inputs C + N P Chlorophyll Total P Schindler (1977)

  39. Why not N limitation? • N fixation greater where TN is low rel. to TP • Cyanobacteria alleviated N limitation inlakes Total N Planktonic N fixation Total P TN:TP loading ratio (molar) Data from Howarth et al. (1988); Schindler (1977)

  40. Why P limitation? P sediments rapidly out of water column • P sediments out: • with organic matter • as precipitates with CaCO3, Fe, Mn • Legacy effect of re-mobilization: • Anoxic conditions  release Fe-P • Elevated CO2  release Ca-P 0-2 m PERCENT 32P SEDIMENTS Levine et al. (1986) DAYS AFTER ADDITION

  41. Schindler et al. (2008) • Fertilization • High N:P (12:1) • Low N:P (4:1) • III-V. no N fertilization • IV. Predatory fish (pike) present TP TDP TN TIN TN:TP TIN:TDP

  42. Are estuaries and coastal zones N or P limited? • Yes: P mgmt is needed in estuaries: • evidence in some estuaries of N fixation, and of production in response to P; • need whole-ecosystem approach before making costly decisions No: N limitation in many estuaries • low N fixers at high salinities – likely b/c SO4 inhibits N-fixer growth • mixing of low N:P waters (from offshore, & b/c of high coastal denitrification) promotes N limitation • greater P availability in estuaries than lakes • nutrient loads often at low N:P, increasing N limitation

  43. “...controlling the eutrophication of coastal zone waters will likely require careful basin-specific management practices for both N and P.” (Smith 2006) P limitation Redfield ratio (16:1 by moles) N limitation Smith (2006)

  44. Redfield ratio: marine algae = water column = N:P 16:1 P limitation [NO3-] (μmol kg-1) N limitation Orig. by Redfield (1934) [PO43-] (μmol kg-1)

  45. Marine nutrient limitation more variable • N:P ~16:1 (molar) = Redfield ratio • N:P < 16(-20): N limitation • N:P > 16: P limitation • N limitation typical in coastal zones (Howarth & Marino 2006) • (Terrestrial: N-limited in temperate zone; P-limited on older tropical soils) Chapin et al.(2002) – Fig. 10.7, from Valiela (1995)

  46. Break (15 min)Discussion (Childers et al. 2011)and summary

  47. P sustainability challenges: human food Pools and fluxes Key P flows • P mining • Agricultural P use • non agricultural P uses • P in food • A) P recycled in farm operations • B) P lost from farm fields • C) P lost in food processing • /transportation • A) P composted in food waste • B) P in human excreta • P lost to landfills • A) P from sewage P treatment recycled as fertilizer • B) P discharged in sewage treatment Childers (2011)

  48. P sustainability challenges: human food • What is meant by “non-substitutability” of P resources? • What are the prospects for increasing P availability to agriculture? • What are benefits and obstacles of different strategies to close P cycle? • GMO pig to reduce P in animal waste?

  49. Species identity and the P cycle • In what ways is species identity important to ecosystem functioning in • The terrestrial P cycle? • The aquatic P cycle? • The agricultural P cycle?

  50. Summary of the P cycle • Soil/sediment-focused, ~unidirectional at human time scales • Limiting element in aquatic systems (particularly freshwater) and at long time scales • Complex interactions with other elements • Altered considerably by human activities (like all the cycles)

More Related