1 / 15

P-saturated Ochre: Performance as a Fertiliser and Environmental Acceptability

P-saturated Ochre: Performance as a Fertiliser and Environmental Acceptability. K.E. Dobbie, K.V. Heal and K.A. Smith School of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh. Introduction.

toki
Download Presentation

P-saturated Ochre: Performance as a Fertiliser and Environmental Acceptability

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. P-saturated Ochre:Performance as a Fertiliser and Environmental Acceptability K.E. Dobbie, K.V. Heal and K.A. SmithSchool of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh

  2. Introduction • P-saturated ochre prepared by repeatedly mixing with H2PO4- in solution until no further P was removed • P-saturated ochre (available P = 0.94 g kg-1) then added to low-P soil • Pot experiments • grass and barley grown in soil mixed with varying amounts of P-saturated ochre (Jul-Oct 2002) • spruce and birch seedling trial (Mar-Nov 2003) • Field experiment • acid grassland and barley field trial (Mar-Sep 2003)

  3. Experimental design – pot experiment • P treatments (5 replicates)

  4. Experimental design – field experiment • barley and acid grassland (4 replicates) – seedling experiment • pot experiment with one year old spruce and birch seedlings (5 replicates)

  5. Analysis • Soil analysis (at start and end of experiment) • total and available P • total metals • (Al, As (end only), Cd (start only), Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb, Zn) • pH • Plant analysis • biomass • barley/grass – above ground (stems, heads) and below ground (roots – pot experiment only) • seedlings – tree volume at start and end of experiment • total P, metals

  6. Results … Total P concentration in soil c b a,b a a a • Total P increases with increasing amounts of ochre

  7. Available P concentration in soil • CP and O(1) not significantly different at start • O(1) > CP at end →less depletion of available P in ochre treatments →more P available for future crops P-saturated ochre acts as a slow release fertiliser

  8. Metal concentrations in soil • Al, Cr, Ni, Zn – no significant differences between treatments • Cu, Pb – no significant differences between ochre treatments or between CP and O(1) • Fe, Mn – increases with increasing ochre concentration but no significant difference between CP and O(1) • As – v. low < 2 mg kg-1 dry soil • Cd – below limits of detection

  9. Are soil metal concentrations potentially hazardous? Maximum permissible concentrations of PTEa in soil after application of sewage sludge to agricultural land (MAFF, 1998) • As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Pb, Zn < guideline values • Ni ~ guideline values (but not significantly different from CO)

  10. Soil pH • pH increases with increasing ochre content (ochre pH = 8.7) → treatments O(1), O(2) & O(5) are sig. higher than untreated soil • NV = 8 % CaO equivalent → 40 t ochre ha-1 is equivalent of 3.2 t CaO ha-1

  11. Plant response to available P in soil • CP treatment • lower yield than ochre treatments but not sig. • Ochre treatments • no differences in yield despite initial range of soil available P conc. • O(0.5) > CP • P released from ochre during growing season Critical soil P content above which increasing P does not significantly increase yield → no adverse effects on crop production using P-saturated ochre as a fertiliser

  12. Elemental concentrations in vegetation • P concentration in plants increases with increasing soil ochre concentration • no significant difference in P concentration between plants grown in conventional fertiliser and those grown in the equivalent amount of P-saturated ochre • No significant difference in Cd and Pb concentrations in barley grain between plants grown in conventional fertiliser and those grown in the equivalent amount of P-saturated ochre

  13. Are plant metal concentrations potentially hazardous? • European Commission regulation No. 466/2001 • limits for Cd & Pb in foodstuffs of 0.2 mg kg-1 wet weight • Barley grain from ochre amended soils in field • 0.01 ± 0.01 mg Cd kg-1 • 0.09 ± 0.07 mg Pb kg-1  below regulation values  not significantly different from CP grain no adverse effect on plant metal concentrations

  14. Conclusions • P-saturated ochre can be used as a P fertiliser • increases the total and available soil P • no adverse effects → on crop yield → on soil metal concentrations → on plant metal concentrations • Other advantages • less frequent application required • reduced lime requirement • replacement for valuable natural sources of P • waste product being reused

  15. Publication in Soil Use and Management Dobbie KE, Heal KV & Smith KA (in press). Assessing the performance as a fertiliser and the environmental acceptability of phosphorus-saturated ochre. Acknowledgements Andy Gray, Rab Howard, John Mormon, Graham Walker

More Related