1 / 22

Basic Challenges to Organizational Design

Basic Challenges to Organizational Design. Chapter 4. Challenges to Organizational Design ***. 1. How to manage differentiation 2. How to balance differentiation & integration 3. How to balance centralization & decentralization 4. How to balance standardization & mutual adjustment.

tillie
Download Presentation

Basic Challenges to Organizational Design

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Basic Challenges to Organizational Design Chapter 4

  2. Challenges to Organizational Design*** 1. How to manage differentiation 2. How to balance differentiation & integration 3. How to balance centralization & decentralization 4. How to balance standardization & mutual adjustment.

  3. Differentiation • Division of labor or degree of specialization • Establishment of task & authority relationships • Allocation of resources & people to tasks • Simple organization differentiation is low • Complex organization differentiation is high

  4. Challenge #1Managing Differentiation • Roles • Functions • Support Adaptive • Production Managerial • Maintenance • Divisions • Responsible for producing one G or S • Self-contained divisions • Organization

  5. Control When individuals: • Understand roles/ responsibilities(accountability) • Are coordinated • Are motivated.

  6. Core Competences • Skills & abilities unique to an organization that give it a competitive advantage • May be in 1 or more functions • Want to allocate more resources to the functions or divisions where core competences exist. Examples: • McDonalds’ production process • Southwest’s customer service

  7. Horizontal The way an organization groups tasks into roles & roles into subunits Establishes division of labor Vertical The way an organization designs hierarchy of authority & creates reporting relationships to link roles & subunits Establishes distribution of authority Differentiation

  8. Challenge #2Balancing Differentiation & Integration • Problem: Specialization (HD) limits communication resulting in loss of coordination & cooperation Subunit orientation • Solution: Integration Increase coordination, communication & cooperation between subunits.

  9. Integrating MechanismsPage 96 • Hierarchy (most simple) • Direct face-to-face contact • Liaison roles • Task forces • Teams • Integrating roles • Integrating departments (most complex)

  10. Keep in Mind… • Differentiating and integrating too much is expensive. Why? • Cost of employing managers & cost of time spent on coordination efforts called: • Bureaucratic Costs

  11. Challenge #3Balancing Centralization & Decentralization • Problem: Hierarchy of authority can mean: inability to make decisions shirking responsibility & risk  slowed decision-making  inflexible organization • Solution: • Decentralize authority • The challenge is to decide how much decision-making authority to delegate to each level of hierarchy.

  12. Centralized Authority Advantages: • Maximum control over subordinates • Top-mgmt coordinates everything & keeps organizational members focused on goals Disadvantages: • Top-mgmt become overloaded on day-to-day decision-making & have no time to develop long-term strategy • Lack of freedom & initiative to respond to problems as they arise.

  13. Decentralized Authority Advantages: • Promotes responsibility & responsiveness (on the spot decisions) • Lower level managers can use skills/ competences (keeps them motivated) • Innovation Disadvantages: • Managers can pursue own goals at expense of organizational goals • Coordination & planning are difficult • Loss of control over decision-making process.

  14. Challenge #4Balancing Standardization & Mutual Adjustment • Problem: Employees’ over reliance on written rules, policies & SOPs (standardization) inability toadapt to a new, unpredictable situation  no room for creativity or innovation in response to customer demand • Solution: Mutual Adjustmentusing judgment, creativity to solve problems

  15. Standardization ---Means following rules & norms to make decisions so work activities are predictable • Formalization= written rules & procedures to standardize operations • No room for mutual adjustment • Typically means centralized authority • Socialization= understood norms or generally agreed upon standards for behavior to guide conduct

  16. Summary • Managers need to create a balance so employees will be both creative and responsible!! • In general, people at higher levels of hierarchy in functions that perform complex, unstructured tasks rely more on mutual adjustment or standardization?

  17. Mechanistic Organizational StructuresPage 115 • Designed to induce people to behave in predictable ways • Employees are highly specialized, & work separately • Employees closely supervised • Easier to hold employees accountable for work • Hierarchy of authority is clearly defined(most commonly used integrating mechanism).

  18. Mechanistic Organizational Structures • Communication is top-down • Work process is standardized(rules, SOPs,policies) & predictable • Effective in unchanging, stable environments(low uncertainty) • Authority (D/M) is centralized • CONTROL!

  19. Organic Organizational Structures • Designed to promote flexibility & ability to adapt To what? • Employees cross-trained, work together; roles loosely defined (joint specialization) • Task forces & teams (face-to-face) are most commonly used integrating mechanisms (high integration needed to coordinate).

  20. Organic Organizational Structures • Authority (DM) is decentralized • Problem solving by way of mutual adjustment • Encourages creativity & innovation • Work process is unpredictable • Effective in dynamic, changing environments(high uncertainty).

  21. Summary • We design an organizational structure to control uncertainty in external environment • Rapidly changing environment more uncertainty requires higher levels of differentiation requires higher levels of integration requires more complex structure demands organic structure • Lower level employees need to be empowered to make on the spot decisions • Rapid communication & information sharing necessary to coordinate activities to meet changing customer demands & develop new products.

  22. Growing Pains Page 113

More Related