Instream wood transport, and effects of forest harvest on geomorphology and fish, in northern Minnes...
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 55

Eric Merten Jacques Finlay* Heinz Stefan* Lucinda Johnson Raymond Newman Bruce Vondracek PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 96 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Instream wood transport, and effects of forest harvest on geomorphology and fish, in northern Minnesota streams. Eric Merten Jacques Finlay* Heinz Stefan* Lucinda Johnson Raymond Newman Bruce Vondracek.

Download Presentation

Eric Merten Jacques Finlay* Heinz Stefan* Lucinda Johnson Raymond Newman Bruce Vondracek

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Instream wood transport, and effects of forest harvest on geomorphology and fish, in northern Minnesota streams

Eric Merten

Jacques Finlay*

Heinz Stefan*

Lucinda Johnson

Raymond Newman

Bruce Vondracek

This work was funded by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Section of Fisheries, the Minnesota Forest Resources Council, the National Council for Air and Stream Improvement, the U.S. Forest Service, Minnesota Sea Grant, Minnesota Trout Unlimited, and the Minnesota Environment and Natural Resources Trust Fund as recommended by the Legislative Citizen Commission on Minnesota Resources.


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Forest harvest effects on the Pokegama Creek system: 1997 to 2007

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=up7-xHm6jlA

Ecohydraulics of wood transport in north shore streams


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Pokegama sampling help

Andy Arola

Daryl Arola

Brenda Asmus

Jason Bronk

Ryan Carlson

Jacquelyn Conner

Bill Coates

Carrie Dorrance

Sue Eggert

Art Elling

MaryKay Fox

Jo Fritz

Sarah Harndin


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Pokegama sampling help

Nat Hemstad

Becca Hunt

Deacon Kyllander

Marty Melchior

Steffen Merten

Mateya Miltich

Brittany Mitchell

Erik Mundahl

Elliot Nitzkowski

Ian Phelps

Lisa Pugh

Jeff Rice

Jeremy Steil

Sandy Verry

Dustin Wilman

Jason Zwonitzer


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

April Bebault

Ryan Carlson

Tracy Close

Levi Drevlow

Jo Fritz

Ryan Johnsen

Nicole Rath

Marty Rye

Nathan Schroeder

Rachael Stanze

Dustin Wilman

Wood

sampling

help

>6km surveyed every 10m

Rachael ongoing discharge data, Tracy Close sharing data


The many roles of trees

The Many Roles of Trees


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

  • Purpose: To evaluate Minnesota’s voluntary Best Management Practices (BMPs) for timber harvest (1996)


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

  • Local Research:

  • Merten (1999) found significant fine

  • sediment increase after harvest

  • Hemstad, Merten, and Newman (2008) found fine sediment levels persisted for several years

  • Hemstad and Newman (2006) found more eroding banks and fine sediment 0-2 years after harvest in the catchment


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Experimental design

  • Pre-harvest sampling in summer 1997

  • Forest harvest in winter 1997-1998

  • Post-harvest sampling summer 1998

  • through summer 2000

  • Natural recovery of sites

  • Post-harvest sampling in summer 2006

  • through summer 2007


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

  • Analysis

  • Repeated measures ANOVA using all

  • data from all sites

  • Tests for overall differences between

  • years, throughout the study area

  • Can not determine the causes of the

  • differences


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

FOREST HARVEST


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

C

FOREST HARVEST


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

D

FOREST HARVEST


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

, p= 0.05

, p= 0.05

, p= 0.00

, p= 0.03


Pokegama summary

Pokegama Summary

  • Canopy cover and eroding banks

    recovered nine years after harvest

  • Sediment inputs still present nine years

    after harvest, flushed in fall of 10th year

  • Years with warmer air temperatures may

    exacerbate effects of open canopy and fine

    sediment


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Ecohydraulics of wood transport in streams:

empirical models from the north shore

of Lake Superior in Minnesota


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Why study wood transport?

If a wood piece is exported from a stream reach, it no longer provides

geomorphic or ecological functions there


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Plunge pools

Lateral migration

Habitat complexity

Invertebrate substrate

Leaf litter retention

Transient storage

Hyporheic exchange


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Research questions for this project

Data collection

Data analysis

Results and discussion


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Location: managed forests in the interior U.S.


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Location: managed forests in the interior U.S.

Design: high resolution but still a field study


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Location: managed forests in the interior U.S.

Design: high resolution but still a field study

Predictors: examine relative importance of all known mechanisms


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Research questions for this project

Data collection

Data analysis

Results and discussion


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Mobilization

Entrapment


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Research questions for this project

Data collection

Data analysis

Results and discussion


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

~2000 hours sampling on nine streams


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Nine streams between

Duluth and Silver Bay


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Bankfull widths ranged from 3.3 to 25.1 m


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

963 pieces measured and tagged, many variables measured

4,190 m of stream surveyed every 10 m


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Braced against a live tree

Saldi-Caromile et al. 2004


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Research questions for this project

Data collection

Data analysis

Results and discussion


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

HEC-RAS model


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

HEC-RAS model


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Drag force ≈ (U 2/2) ρw Cd AN + (U 2/2) ρw Cf ASAcos3 θ

Lift force ≈ U 2/2 Clp ANcos θ + U 2/2 Clg ANsin θ

Braudrick and Grant 2000


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

“What factors determine whether or not a piece is mobilized/entrapped?”

Multiple logistic regression with mobilization as the response variable

-shows which variables are important for mobilization

Multiple logistic regression with entrapment as the response variable

-shows which variables are important for entrapment


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Research questions for this project

Data collection

Data analysis

Results and discussion


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Needs for wood transport studies

Location: managed forests in the interior U.S.

Design: high resolution but still a field study

This study examined individual pieces in the field at a fine spatial scale

and at a < 1-year temporal scale

Predictors: examine relative importance of all mechanisms

This study examined more and better predictors than any previous study


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Variables retained in the final model for mobilization;

n = 865 pieces of wood.

Overall model p < 0.001 and Nagelkerke’s r2 = 0.39


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Variables retained in the final model for mobilization;

n = 865 pieces of wood.

Overall model p < 0.001 and Nagelkerke’s r2 = 0.39


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Variables retained in the final model for mobilization;

n = 865 pieces of wood.

Overall model p < 0.001 and Nagelkerke’s r2 = 0.39


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Variables retained in the final model for entrapment;

n = 344 pieces of wood.

Overall model p < 0.001 and Nagelkerke’s r2 = 0.25


Eric merten jacques finlay heinz stefan lucinda johnson raymond newman bruce vondracek

Keep sediment out

Keep streams cool

Promote more wood

Conclusions

[email protected]


  • Login