From spatial regularization to anatomical priors in fmri analysis
Download
1 / 28

From Spatial Regularization to Anatomical Priors in fMRI Analysis - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 105 Views
  • Uploaded on

From Spatial Regularization to Anatomical Priors in fMRI Analysis. Fragmented Map. Regularized Map. Wanmei Ou William Wells Polina Golland. Core 1 Meeting – May 23 rd , 2006. Main Contributions. Propose new spatial regularization method: Incorporating Anatomical Information

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' From Spatial Regularization to Anatomical Priors in fMRI Analysis ' - tait


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
From spatial regularization to anatomical priors in fmri analysis

From Spatial Regularization to Anatomical Priors in fMRI Analysis

Fragmented Map

Regularized Map

Wanmei Ou William Wells Polina Golland

Core 1 Meeting – May 23rd, 2006


Main contributions
Main Contributions Analysis

  • Propose new spatial regularization method: Incorporating Anatomical Information

  • Empirically Compare proposed methods with traditional methods


Road map
Road Map Analysis

  • Background and Motivation

  • Markov Random Field (MRF) and Anatomical Guided MRF Model

  • Mean Field Approximation Solver

  • Experimental Evaluation

  • Conclusions


Road map1
Road Map Analysis

  • Background and Motivation

  • Markov Random Field (MRF) and Anatomical Guided MRF Model

  • Mean Field Approximation Solver

  • Experimental Evaluation

  • Conclusions


From fmri images to fmri analysis
From fMRI Images to fMRI Analysis Analysis

Image Acquisition

MRI

fMRI

Task protocol: Auditory, Vision, etc.

Spatial

Regularization

Voxel-by-voxel detector

Threshold

Activation Map

Scatter activation


Road map2
Road Map Analysis

  • Background and Motivation

  • Markov Random Field (MRF) and Anatomical Guided MRF Model

  • Mean Field Approximation Solver

  • Experimental Evaluation

  • Conclusions


Goal and approaches
Goal and Approaches Analysis

Goal: Recover True Activation through Spatial Regularization

Our Approach:

  • Incorporate MRF into General Linear Model (GLM) Statistic

  • Include Anatomical Information into MRF


Detailed approaches
Detailed Approaches Analysis

Our Approach:

  • 1. Incorporate MRF into GLM Statistic

    • Capture spatial dependency

    • Overcome over-smoothing effect

  • 2. Include Anatomical Information into MRF

    • Activation is more likely in gray matter

    • Spatial dependency is strong within tissue type

Activation Maps

MRF

MRI

Synthetic Ground Truth

Segmentation

Gray, White, Other


General linear model glm
General Linear Model (GLM) Analysis

Protocol-Independent Signal

Two Hypotheses

Not-active voxel

Active voxel

Protocol-Dependent Signal

GLM

ML Estimate

F or T statistic

P-value

Traditional Approach

General Log Likelihood Ratio (Cosman, 04)

Our Approach


Markov random field
Markov Random Field Analysis

Spatial Priors:

Likelihood:

-- Hidden Activation State

-- Noisy Observation/Statistic

MAP Estimate:


Incorporating anatomical information
Incorporating Anatomical Information Analysis

Combine activation state & tissue type

MRI

Segmentation

-- Hidden Activation State

-- Tissue Type

MAP Estimate:

-- Segmentation Label

-- Noise Statistic


Markov random fields solvers
Markov Random Fields Solvers Analysis

  • Binary MRF Min-Cut/Max-Flow (Min-Max) Binary MRF Only

  • Gibbs Sampling Slow

  • Simulated Annealing Slow

  • Belief Propagation Fast, Approximation

  • Mean Field Fast, Approximation


Road map3
Road Map Analysis

  • Background and Motivation

  • Markov Random Field (MRF) and Anatomical Guided MRF Model

  • Mean Field Approximation Solver

  • Experimental Evaluations

  • Conclusion and Future work


Mean field
Mean Field Analysis

  • Approximate by

  • Iterative up-date rule

Belief: Prob. Of voxel is active

  • Approximated MAP


Mean Field Analysis

Similar up-date rule while incorporating anatomical information

Approximated MAP


Alternative anatomically guided filters
Alternative Anatomically Guided Filters Analysis

  • No smoothing with Anatomical Information

    • Suppress all activation in the non-gray matter.

  • Anatomically Guided Gaussian Filter

    • Adjust weights based on segmentation labels.


Road map4
Road Map Analysis

  • Background and Motivation

  • Markov Random Field (MRF) and Anatomical Guided MRF Model

  • Mean Field Approximation Solver

  • Experimental Evaluation

    • Synthetic Data

    • Real fMRI Data

  • Conclusions


Low snr fragmented activation maps

Experiments – Synthetic Data Sets Analysis

Low SNR Fragmented Activation Maps

Noise

SNR = -6.3dB

Noise

SNR = -9.3dB

Activation Maps

Threshold:

False positive = 0.05%

Forward

Model

GLM

Detector

+

Synthetic Ground Truth


Experiments – Synthetic Data Sets Analysis

Noise

Forward

Model

GLM with different

smoothing methods

+

Synthetic Ground Truth

  • No Smoothing

  • No Smoothing w/ Anatomical Info

  • Gaussian Smoothing w/o Anatomical Info

  • Gaussian Smoothing w/ Anatomical Info

  • MRF w/o Anatomical Info

  • MRF w/ Anatomical Info


Roc analysis
ROC Analysis Analysis

Without Anatomical Information

Min-Max (Exact Solver) vs. Mean Field (Approximation)

SNR = -6dB

SNR = -9dB


Roc analysis1
ROC Analysis Analysis

Without Anatomical Information

MRF (Mean Field) vs. Gaussian Smoothing

SNR = -6dB

SNR = -9dB


Roc analysis2
ROC Analysis Analysis

With Anatomical Information

MRF (Mean Field) vs. Gaussian Smoothing

SNR = -6dB

SNR = -9dB


Road map5
Road Map Analysis

  • Background and Motivation

  • Markov Random Field (MRF) and Anatomical Guided MRF Model

  • Mean Field Approximation Solver

  • Experimental Evaluation

    • Synthetic Data

    • Real fMRI Data

  • Conclusions


Evaluation on real data
Evaluation on Real Data Analysis

“Ground Truth”

GLM

Majority Voting

GLM

8 task epochs

comparisons

GLM with various spatial regularizers

2 task epochs


Activation maps comparison
Activation Maps Comparison Analysis

Anat No Smoothing Gaussian MRF

“Ground Truth” No Smoothing+Anat Gaussian+Anat MRF+Anat

Three Epochs

sm007ep3


Activation maps comparison1
Activation Maps Comparison Analysis

Anat No Smoothing Gaussian MRF

“Ground Truth” No Smoothing+Anat Gaussian+Anat MRF+Anat

Three Epochs

sm007ep3


Activation maps comparison2
Activation Maps Comparison Analysis

Anat No Smoothing Gaussian MRF

“Ground Truth” No Smoothing+Anat Gaussian+Anat MRF+Anat

Three Epochs

sm007ep3


Conclusions Analysis

  • New Spatial Regularization method

    • Anatomical Bias

  • Empirical Evaluation

    • ROC analysis

    • Activation maps

  • MRF + Anatomical Information

    • Increase detection accuracy with reduced-length signal


ad