1 / 13

Privatisation: As Easy as ABC? - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

Privatisation: As Easy as ABC?. Prof Graeme Hodge Monash Centre for Regulatory Studies. Session Outline. Privatisation (definition, values and promises) Does Privatisation Work? Meta analytic international review Case Study: Victoria’s Electricity reforms

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' Privatisation: As Easy as ABC?' - tab

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript


As Easy as ABC?

  • Prof Graeme Hodge

  • Monash Centre for Regulatory Studies

Session outline
Session Outline

  • Privatisation (definition, values and promises)

  • Does Privatisation Work?

    • Meta analytic international review

    • Case Study: Victoria’s Electricity reforms

  • Transcending Privatisation Debate: The Rise of Independent Regulators

  • Challenges, observations & Implications

  • Conclusions

  • 1 privatisation definition values
    1. Privatisation – definition & values

    Privatisation world-wide trend ~

    $85b pa in ES

    A political movement, swept along by collapsed central economies

    Definition:“transfer of enterprises/service functions from public to private hands”

    (Private Sector Develop’t Strategy)

    Enterprise Sales


    Public-Private Partnerships

    Private Sector Model:

    • Individual choosing in markets, using Demand/price (closed private actions)

    • Search for market satisfaction (or exit)

    • Sovereign customers amidst competition

    Public Sector Model:

    • Collective choice in polity, using need for resources (open public actions)

    • Search for justice & equity

    • Sovereign citizens using voices amidst collective action in polity

    Economic (increase efficiency)

    Consumer(lower prices, better services, more choice)

    Political(eg reduce union power, smaller government, ‘free up’ SOEs)

    Fiscal (raise revenue, reduce deficit)

    Social (share owning democracy)

    Reduce Corruption

    Act on advice & increase confidence

    Placate External Bodies (- Banks)

    Ideology (... Our Belief )

    1. Privatisation – promises

    2. Does Privatisation Work?

    - International Meta Analysis

    • Hotly contested!

    • Meta-analysis of 162 empirical reports n=10,468 msrts

    • Productivity & Financial increases were significant- but so was performance of control firms not privatised

    • Labour productivity gains

    • No simple link between size of private sector & natnl eco growth

    • Other meta-reviews found ‘little evidence of systematic performance improvement…’ (Martin & Parker 1997), though not all…

    • Narrative reviews suggest consumer promises often not met

    • M/A of British Telecom found sig. service quality improvement, but regulatory intensity & public accountability were far stronger influences than ownership change

    • Winners & losers theme(investors vs citizens, Argentina vs NYSX)







    Degree of Competition



    2. Does Privatisation Work?

    - International Meta Analysis

    • Developing Countries

    • In 63% of firms, profitability improved

    • In 80% of firms, efficiency improved (Cook and Kirkpatrick, 2003)

    Most critical issue in the privatisation of SOEs is the effectiveness of new regulatory & competition arrangements

    2. Does Privatisation Work?

    - Victoria’s Electricity Reforms

    Now: additional generators

    Now: AER, ESC

    Now: 5 distributors / 15 retailers


    Customers had a charter of rights

    Prices down 14% from 1994 to 2000

    ‘Time-off-supply’ down by 31% (to 199 mins pa)

    Residential disconnections down by 2/3rds since 1995


    Unplanned outages up

    Price reduction was regulated (& after an SOE price rise of 10%)

    Disconnections rose markedly just before 1995 sales under new commercial practices

    2. Does Privatisation Work?

    - Victoria’s Electricity Reforms

    2. Does Privatisation Work?

    - Victoria’s Electricity Reforms

    • So;

      • Victorian politics - saw ‘pure’ policy designs flourish & reforms score a ‘credit’

      • Success depended on careful regulatory/market design before privatisation

    • The later CLCV/MCRS review in 2006 found

      price benefits from reforms were not equitably distributed (with gains mostly going to industrial/high volume users, and with low volume rural regional / domestic users missing out), … little reliable consumer price data… & a recent fall in disconnection figures (due to introduction of wrongful disconnection payment in 2004…)

    • What’s next?

    3. Transcending the Privatisation Debate: The Rise of Independent Regulators

    • People talk now about living with a regulatory state(law),regulatory governance(eco)& regulatory capitalism(pol sci)

    • The arrival of regulatory governance:

      • The privatisation era era of regulation

        • Regulator numbers tripled in 1990s

        • both in economic regulation(electricity, telecoms, competition…)& social regulation(food safety, pharmaceuticals, environment…)

        • We recognized ‘independent’ mechanisms better governed utilities (away from politics…) & ensured consumer gains after privatisation

    • International ‘knowledge consultants’ (US$170b & 463k staff across 140 countries) were crucial here

    The diffusion of agencies in 36 countries and 7 sectors

    (Gilardi, Jordana & Levi-Faur 2006)


    Codes / G-Ls

    Contracts / grants

    Econ $ €

    Information / transparency

    Markets / licenses/ accredtn

    • Gov’t

    • Independent Instns

    • Hybrid

    • Global

    • Self-reg

    • Co-reg

    • Meta-regltn

    • ‘Hard’ Law

    • Codes/guidelines

    • ‘Soft’ Regulation

    • (self-regulation)



    3. Transcending the Privatisation Debate: The Rise of Independent Regulators

    • Regulation is:

      • about reordering priorities & power, & policy permanency(not just risks)

      • ‘a distinctive mode of policy making’(Majone 1999)& an ‘alternative mode of public control’(Minogue ’02, p653)

    • We have been rethinking ‘regulation’. It;

      • covers multiple disciplines & is decentred

        across all sectors

      • includes huge range of regulatory mechanisms/tools

      • has international linkages…

  • Today’s paradox;

    • A professional regulatory technocracy exists

    • Yet regulatory activity is political activity

  • 4 challenges observations and implications
    4. Challenges, Observations and Implications

    • Keeping the Regulators (big ‘R’ and small ‘r’) accountable (to many stakeholders?)

    • Institutional ‘depoliticisation’ has shifted the debate arena

    • Regulatory discretion

      • the passive regulator

      • the active regulator

    • Other (eg reducing regulatory burdens, establishing ‘what works’…)

    4 conclusions
    4. Conclusions

    • In today’s age of regulatory capitalism;

      • Privatisation discussions continue reflecting our values/beliefs

      • Continued debate around the role of government

      • But it is regulatory sophistication & integrity that matters most

    • Lets remember;

      • Regulatory activity is political activity!

      • Arena shifting has occurred for debates

      • Regulators with greater legitimacy remain accountable

      • Regulatory discretion sees some regulators being passive and others active

    • Ministers need to remain vigilant, transparent and open to rediscovering the public interest (as well as ensuring business confidence!)