1 / 42

FORENSIC & APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY SEXUAL OFFENDING - RAPE

FORENSIC & APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY SEXUAL OFFENDING - RAPE. Dr Ann Henry Tues 5 th November 2013. Last Lecture. Theories of crime. Lecture overview. Sexual Offending (part 1) – Rapists. Definitions of Rape. Howitt (2009 ) defines rape as:

studs
Download Presentation

FORENSIC & APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY SEXUAL OFFENDING - RAPE

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. FORENSIC & APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGYSEXUAL OFFENDING - RAPE Dr Ann Henry Tues 5th November 2013

  2. Last Lecture • Theories of crime

  3. Lecture overview • Sexual Offending (part 1) – Rapists

  4. Definitions of Rape • Howitt (2009) defines rape as: • Unwanted penetration of the vagina, anus or mouth of another person. • This means that women who abuse children or adults are covered by the most recent Sexual Offences Act (2003) • Statutory rape is penile penetration of any child below the age of consent to sexual intercourse • Issue of ‘consent’ has been controversial

  5. Legal Aspects • Sexual Offences Act (2003) includes a legal definition of ‘consent’ • Active consent of the parties, free from factors that might mitigate against the freely given choice such as threats of violence, drugs, alcohol or being asleep. • No longer sufficient for someone to ‘assume’ that consent had been given. • New approach is based on presumption that consent had ‘NOT’ been given.

  6. Frequency of Rape • Difficult to assess frequency of rape as much under reporting (dark figure of unreported crime • Estimated between 75-95% of rapes are not reported to the police (Her Majesty’s Inspector of Constabulary, 2007)

  7. Frequency of rape • Occupational police culture that treats with suspicion allegations of rape (Reiner, 2000) • Controversy over how many allegations of rape are false (between 1%-50% in various studies (Rumney, 2006)

  8. Frequency of rape • Hence, the frequency of rape cannot be assessed with certainty. • British Crime Surveys – random surveys of households which attempts to assess the rate of crime, including those not reported to the police. • 4 women in a 1,000 described incidents that could be classified as rape in previous year

  9. British Crime Surveys • 49 women in 1,000 claimed to have been raped since age of 16 years. • 9 women in 1,000 claimed to have suffered some form of sexual assault victimisation in the previous year • 97 women in 1,000 had suffered some form of sexual assault since the age of 16

  10. British crime survey • Victims of rape usually know the rapist • 45% of rapists were the women’s current partner • 16% were acquaintances • 11% were ex-partners • 11% were dates • 10% were other intimates • Women raped by a stranger more likely to report it to the police (36% agreed in survey, whereas only 8% reported rape by known man) • Howitt (2012)

  11. Home Office (2010)

  12. AN OVERVIEW OF SEXUAL OFFENDING IN ENGLAND AND WALES (2013) MINISTRY OF JUSTICE, HOME OFFICE & THE OFFICE FOR NATIONAL STATISTICS ALSO AVAILABLE ON THE MINISTRY OF JUSTICE, HOME OFFICE AND OFFICE FOR NATIONAL STATISTICS WEBSITES AT WWW.JUSTICE.GOV.UKWWW.HOMEOFFICE.GOV.UK/RDS/INDEX.HTMWWW.ONS.GOV.UK

  13. Home Office (2013)

  14. Estimated Numbers of Victims (2013)

  15. Sex offenders as specialists/ generalists? • General Theory of Crime (Gottfredson & Hirschi, 1990) • Argues that offending is a manifestation of a broader & more pervasive antisocial character which involves not just crime, but other similar behaviours. • E.g. employment instability, absenteeism from work, alcohol & drug abuse, cigarettes, irresponsible driving, marital instability, truancy & unprotected sex.

  16. Specialist sex offenders • Harris, Mazerolle & Knight (2009) • Argues that sex offenders largely specialise in sexual crimes & do not engage in other types of activity. • They argue that there is an ‘implicit’ assumption that those who commit sex offences are not the same as non-sexual offenders.

  17. generalist or specialist sex offenders? • Leclerc, Cale & Proulx (2007) • Argue that sex offenders include both ‘generalists’ and ‘specialists’ • Case for generalists is compelling e.g. previous histories of non-sexual offending is common amongst sex offenders • When they reoffend, it’s likely to be for a non-sexual offence.

  18. generalist or specialist sex offenders? • Harris et al (2009) found that – • There is a group of generalist (versatile) sex offenders – more likely to show signs of ‘psychopathy’ • There is a group of ‘specialist’ sex offenders who are likely to show emotional congruence with children, preference of male victims, victims known to them & sexual preoccupation.

  19. generalist or specialist sex offenders? • Harris et al (2009) • Rapists are ‘generalist’ offenders • Child molesters are ‘specialist’ offenders • Study based on sample of 572 sex offenders in Massachusetts between 1959- 1984. • Considered a ‘specialist’ if the majority of their crimes are of a particular type. • Within their sample, they found that ‘specialist’ rapists were rare, but specialist child molesters were more common.

  20. Victim category cross-over • Cross-over is the extent to which a sex offender offends against victims in a variety of categories. E.g. adult women, girl children, boy children. • The more the cross-over, the harder to explain the sexual offending in terms of different patterns of conditioning or social learning. • Also harder to predict future sexual offending.

  21. Victim category cross-over • Cann, Friednship & Gozna (2007) • Looked at cross-over of sexual offenders in terms of victim age, gender & relationship to offender • Sample – 1,345 adult male sex offenders who had offended against multiple victims & sentenced to min of 4 years. • Found 25% of offenders showed cross-over on a min of 1 dimension • Cross-over offenders higher risk of re-offending according to Static-99 (risk assessment)

  22. YouNG Sex offenders • Childhood abuse commoner in sex offenders • Rape often associated with anger • Worling (1995) adolescent sex offender. • Those who offended against women rather than peers had experienced more physical &/or sexual abuse as children. • Those sexually abused by men as children, lead to abuse against younger children • Victims of female sexual abuse tended to become offenders against peers and older women.

  23. Young Sex Offenders • Haapasalo & Kankkonen (1997) • Self-reported experiences of childhood abuse in men whose victims were over 18 years • Compared with violent offenders with no record of abuse. • Matched on number of family problems, being in care, parental divorce, parents who were substance abusers etc.

  24. Young sex offenders • Haapasalo & Kankkonen (1997) • Found that sex offenders • claimed to have experienced more psychological (verbal) abuse e.g. yelling, threatening, ridiculing etc. • Experience of psychological rejection & isolation was more common • Parents more openly hostile & negative towards them as children • Tended to be ignored, siblings favoured • Were locked up in closed environments • Mother/ father belittled them, did shameful things to them • Didn’t want them near them etc.

  25. Patterns in rape • Different characteristics in rape behaviour • Australian study have explored what happens during the rape (e.g. type of penetration (vaginal, oral, anal), language used in assaults (e.g. caring, abusive, angry, revenge). McCabe & Wauchope (2005)

  26. Patterns in rape • Canter et al (2003) • British study explored the verbatim transcripts made by rape victims & classified the rape characteristics as: • Control- about a tenth of rapes (victim bound or gagged or blindfolded, weapon used etc) • Theft – about a twentieth of rapes (goods demanded & stolen from the victim) • Involvement – about a third of rapes (victim complimented about her appearance & kissed & implies that he knows the victim) • Hostility – about a quarter of rapes ( victims clothing removed in violent manner, victim threatened, attempted anal penetration, victim demeaned or verbally insulted) • Some rapes showed mixed patterns

  27. Types of rapists • Groth, Burgess & Holmstrom (1977) • Power-assurance rapist • Power-assertive rapist • Anger-retaliatory rapist • Anger-excitement rapist

  28. Power assurance rapists • Howitt (1991a) argues that sexual deprivation is not an essential component of rape • Power-assurance rapist is the most common type • Rape deals with insecurities about masculinity • Rape only provides short term reassurance about masculinity, so needs to rape again • Force is not great & threats may be involved, but weapon not used • Rape is planned – prior surveillance of victim • If victim is passive enough, sexual fantasies might be expressed during rape • Trophy items of clothing might be taken for future masturbation

  29. Power assertive rapists • Howitt (1991a) • Offender is usually sexually confident • Rape expresses his virility & sexuality & power over women • Victims may be found in social locations e.g. discos, pubs or parties • Initially his manner might be friendly, but changes very quickly • Violence is extreme, especially in later stages • Offences may be scattered & irregular in terms of frequency

  30. ANGER-RETALIATORY RAPIST • Howitt (1991a) • High levels of anger towards women • Involves short intense attacks (blitz) • Often a similarity between the victim & the woman he has the grudge against • Attacks may be fairly regular as a consequence of the build-up of anger

  31. Anger-excitement rapist • Howitt (1991a) • Least common type • Rapist gains pleasure & sexual excitement from the distress of the victim • Infliction of pain is common & high levels of violence. Victim may be killed & torture is common • Careful, methodical planning • Will bring blindfold, gags & ropes to the rape • Victims are usually total strangers to offender • Photographs & video recordings might be taken • Attacks are usually irregular

  32. Rape Myths • Burt (1980) work on cultural myths concerning rape • She develop the ‘Rape Myth Acceptance Scale’ • Based on victim-blaming & notions that women deserve to be or want to be raped • E.g. “if a girl engages in necking or petting & she lets things get out of hand, it’s her own fault if her partner forces sex on her” • “ if a girl gets drunk at a party & has sex with a man she’s just met there, she’s fair game for other males at the party who want to have sex with her” • “ a woman who is stuck up & thinks she is too good to talk to guys on the street, deserves to be taught a lesson”

  33. Socio-cultural factors • Hall & Barongan (1997) • Explored rape statistics in 50 states in the USA • Cultural spillover – measured in terms of ‘Legitimate Violence Index e.g. acceptance of corporal punishment in schools • Gender inequality – economic, legal & political status of women e.g. proportion of the state’s senate that were women, average income of employed men & women • Social disorganisation- stability of population e.g. divorce, lone parent families & religiosity.

  34. Sexual fantasy & sexual offending • Conflicting evidence of the role played by sexual fantasies & sexual offending. • Williams et al (2009) found that rates of sexual fantasies in offender & non-offender populations were similar (using university students) • Maniglio (2010) did a systematic review of 7 studies involving 171 sexual murderers. Concluded that sexual fantasies might lead to sexual murder when the offender had a traumatic early life experiences and/or more extreme social/ sexual dysfunctions.

  35. THEORIES OF RAPE • FEMINIST THEORY • Ellis (1989) argues that rape is built into the gender structure of society • Rape is likely to be associated with disparities in social status & power • Rape motivated primarily by desire for power & dominance, rather than desire for sex • Rapists hold more rape-prone attitudes to women than non-rapists – but not supported by recent research.

  36. Theories of rape • Social learning theory • That rapists learn to be rapists • Ellis argues that pornography is key factor in this theory • Rapists hold more favourable attitudes to rape & violence than other men

  37. Theories of rape • Evolutionary theory • Adaptive transmission of one’s genetic material to the next generation • Forced copulations should impregnate victims • Rape victims primarily of reproductive age • Victim should vigorously resist rapist • Rapist should be less likely than other males to attract voluntary sex partners

  38. Useful references • Harris, D.A. Pedneault, A. & Knight, R.A. (2012). An exploration of burglary in the criminal histories of sex offenders referred for civil commitment, Psychology, Crime & Law, pp. 1-17. • Howitt, D. (2009). Introduction to Forensic & Criminal Psychology, 3rd edition, Harlow, Pearson Education Ltd. • Norton, R. & Grant, T. (2008). Rape Myth in true & false rape allegations. Psychology, Crime & Law, vol.14 (4), pp 275-285. • Philip N.S. Rumney (2006).False allegations of rape. The Cambridge Law Journal, 65, pp 128-158. doi:10.1017/S0008197306007069.

  39. Useful references (CONT) • Strickland, S.M (2008). Female Sex Offenders: Exploring Issues of Personality, Trauma and Cognitive Distortions, J Interpers Violence, 23; pp. 474-489. • Swart, M.D., De Keseredy, W.S., Tait, D. & Alvi, S. (2006). Male peer support & a feminist routine activities theory: understanding sexual assault on the college campus, Justice Quarterly, vol. 18 (3), 623-649.

  40. USEFUL WEBLINKS • A gap of a chasm? Attrition in reported rape cases – Home Office Research Study 293, February 2005 • http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110218135832/rds.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/hors293.pdf • 70 • The Stern Review: A report by Baroness Vivien Stern CBE of an independent review into how rape complaints are handled by public authorities in England and Wales –Home Office, 2010 • http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110608160754/http:/www.equalities.gov.uk/PDF/Stern_Review_acc_FINAL.pdf • Providing anonymity to those accused of rape: an assessment of evidence – Ministry of Justice Research Series 20/10, November 2010 • www.justice.gov.uk/publications/research-and-analysis/moj/2010/anonymity-rape-assessment-evidence • 71

More Related