1 / 37

An Autopsy of the Financial System:

An Autopsy of the Financial System:. Accident, Suicide, or Negligent Homicide?. Suicide: Crisis happened to policymakers. Greenspan: “The roots of the crisis reach … to the aftermath of the Cold War … … that led to a dramatic decline of real long-term interest rates.

storm
Download Presentation

An Autopsy of the Financial System:

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. An Autopsy of the Financial System: Accident, Suicide, or Negligent Homicide?

  2. Suicide: Crisis happened to policymakers • Greenspan: “The roots of the crisis reach … to the aftermath of the Cold War … … that led to a dramatic decline of real long-term interest rates. … that in turn engendered a dramatic global home price bubble, which was heavily leveraged … … A classic euphoric bubble … Everybody missed it.” • Prince (former CEO of Citigroup): • “When the music stops … things will be complicated. But as long as the music is playing, you’ve got to get up and dance. We’re still dancing.”

  3. Accident: Crisis happened to policymakers • Greenspan, Bernanke, Paulson, Geithner, Romer: • It was a “hundred years” flood • Global savings glut • Massive capital inflows to the U.S. • Financial innovation, fraud, and herd behavior • Robert Rubin: • I’m sorry that [we] could not see the unprecedented market collapse that lay before us.”

  4. Negligent homicide: regulators caused the crisis • Negligent homicide: • “Willfully blind” • “Allowing avoidable dangers and risks to continue” • “Cause” includes not adapting to avoidable dangers • Innovation + old (good) regulations  reckless regulations • Senator Carl Levin: “The recent financial crisis was not a natural disaster; it was a manmade economic assault.”

  5. Outline • A few words on the suicide and accident views • Negligent homicide? • 5 policies • 1996-2006 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NOT 2007 – 2010

  6. A few words on the suicide and accident explanations

  7. There really was a boom. Perhaps a bubble

  8. But, was it simply suicide? • Regulators knew about the bubble. • … and NINJA loans • … and that housing prices fall (40% of years) • … and banks’ exposure to real estate

  9. Who was supervising the safety and soundness of the banking system?

  10. Suicide and accident explanations … • Valid, but incomplete • Deflect attention from policymakers

  11. Negligent homicide credit rating agencies (CRAs)

  12. Credit rating agencies • How did they become so pivotal?

  13. Credit rating agencies • SEC invents the Nationally Recognized Statistical Rating Organizations (NRSRO) designation in the 1970s to establish capital requirements on broker-dealers. • Cascade: • Fed and other domestic and foreign bank regulations • Insurance and pension regulators in U.S. and abroad • Other federal, state, and municipalities in U.S. and abroad. • All major purchasers of securities MUST use ratings • NRSROs start charging issuers instead of buyers.

  14. Conflicts of interest: 1 • Credit rating agencies sell “licenses,” not ratings. • Regulation and law protects CRAs from market discipline • Regulation mitigates reputational capital concerns • Legal liability not an issue because of law • Profits f{ quantity, not quality }

  15. Conflicts of interest 2: Why things deteriorated • Structured product boom late-1990s  quantity! • Rating agencies paid to structure: Consulting • And, then to rate those structures: Rating • The profits were enormous • Regulatory protections • + invention of structured products • + combining consulting and rating • = enormous profits … operating margins over 50%

  16. Credit rating agencies knew … • “These errors make us look either incompetent at credit analysis or like we sold our soul to the devil for revenue ...” • Moody’s MD in 2007 • “Let’s hope we are all wealthy and retired by the time this house of cards falters.” • S&P employee in 2004

  17. This was negligent homicide • CRAs created and protected by regulators • Congress prohibits regulators from monitoring rating methods. • Regulators maintain unique designation and reliance • Problems were well-known years before the crisis: • Accounting scandal… VERY similar. • There were conferences and articles. • Policymakers recklessly endangered the global economy

  18. Negligent homicide Credit default swaps and bank capital

  19. Example: Credit default swaps • JP Morgan developed CDSs in 1994 to: • Reduce bank credit risk • Free-up regulatory capital for more lucrative investments • Explosive growth: • By 2007, notional value of $62 trillion, yes that is correct • US banks transact in CDSs, reducing capital • AIG writes many CDSs to banks.

  20. Regulators knew of growing problems • Geithner was very concerned • Formed task force headed by Corrigan (NY-Fed / Goldman) • Tried to negotiate with banks • Accumulating evidence, 1996-2007, made BofG concerned • Counterparty risk associated with CDS • Risk to banks associated with mortgage-related instruments. • FBI warns of an “epidemic of fraud” in sub-prime mortgages, on which many CDSs were based. • Internal reports at the BofG indicate that this was very well-known.

  21. Regulators knew of growing problems, • but chose not to act.

  22. FED could have argued the following • FED does not have ability to assess counterparty risk. • … neither, does it have confidence in credit rating agencies. • FED is responsible for safety/soundness of banking system • Therefore, the FED will not allow banks to reduce capital. • The issue is not the 1996 decision. • The issue is the Fed maintained its policies.

  23. Negligent homicide More on CDSs

  24. The Warning by Brooksley Born • OTC derivatives – including CDSs -- subject to • Fraud, Manipulation, Failure, Opacity • E.g., Orange county, Gibson Greeting Cards, Proctor & Gamble, • E.g., exploitation of unsophisticated school districts & municipalities, • E.g., LTCM, impossible to assess systemic ramifications. • OTC derivatives involve hundreds of trillions of dollars • Commodity Future Trading Commission • Calls for greater transparency • Concerns (obvious concerns) about systemic risk

  25. The Response by the “Oracle” • Stop move toward transparency • Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000 • Exempted OTC derivatives from oversight • Policy enforced ignorance of an enormous, systemically important market

  26. Negligent homicide The SEC and investment banks

  27. Total failure • All five major investment banks “fail” in 2008. • “We have a good deal of comfort about the capital cushions at these firms at the moment” • Christopher Cox, SEC chairman, 3/11/2008. • 3 days before FED provided emergency $25 billion loan to Bear Stearns.

  28. 3 Coordinated SEC policies in 2004 • Exempt 5 major broker-dealers from net capital rule. • SEC to provide consolidated supervision of big 5 • Consolidated Supervised Entities (CSEs) • Holding company and all affiliates. • Complex, systemically important responsibility • Decide not to build capability • 7 people to oversee holding companies with $4 trillion • Eliminate risk management office • Fail to complete any inspections in18 months before Bear Stearns • Weaken enforcement

  29. And, they ask Congress to lay-off “The bill should be amended to recognize the unique ability of the Commission to comprehensively supervise the consolidated groups … the Commission has established a successful consolidated supervision program” • SEC’s Deputy Director testimony before the U.S. House of Representatives Financial Services Committee, 4/25/2007. • 18 months later, all of the “consolidated groups” vanished.

  30. My verdict • Willful blindness & • Reckless endangerment

  31. Negligent homicide Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

  32. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, HUD, FHA, etc. • GSEs facilitate housing through secondary market by • Purchasing, Guaranteeing, Securitizing • Purchasing and holding • GSEs make money by • Borrowing cheaply, helped by government guarantee              • Lending more expensively via buy and hold mortgages              • “Selling” guarantees • GSE Profits • Limited by the size of market • Threatened by potential regulatory interventions • So, they …         

  33. Expand market & deflect threats!! • Expand market in the mid-1990s • Quantitative application of Community Reinvestment Act • GSEs pushed/rush into sub-prime type mortgages • Thus, there was a change. • Political threats assuaged through: • Campaign contributions and • other emoluments.

  34. Subprime-trait mortgages  Boom • By 2001: No down payment mortgages • 45% of GSE purchases have subprime traits: 2005-7 • Low FICO Scores and High LTV ratios • Negative amortization and low documentation • Triggers low quality lending throughout system • September 7, 2008 • $7 trillion institutions fail • Estimated losses … $400 billion and counting

  35. Postmortem of the GSEs • Policymakers created incentives for massive risk-taking • Did not respond as GSEs became systemically fragile • There were press warnings for the decade before the failed • Greenspan warned Congress in 2004 • Congress defeated legislation to reform GSEs

  36. Lessons

  37. Autopsy results • There is a systemic problem with financial regulation • The crisis was not only an accident or bubble • Nor primarily a lack of information or power by regulators • The problem was not primarily associated with most of the targets of the financial reform bill • Policymakers implemented and maintained bad policies • for the 10-15 years before the crisis • even as they learned of the effects of their policies. • Systemic change requires greater check and balances • On regulators • On bank executives

More Related