?
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 30

האם תוכניות יעודי קרקע אכן מתממשות ? מתודולוגיה להערכת ישום תוכניות יעודי קרקע באמצעות ממ"ג PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 94 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

האם תוכניות יעודי קרקע אכן מתממשות ? מתודולוגיה להערכת ישום תוכניות יעודי קרקע באמצעות ממ"ג יונתן אלמגור. Do Plans Get Implemented? A Review of Evaluation in Planning (1996) Emily Talen “ Planning needs to develop its own brand of evaluation research

Download Presentation

האם תוכניות יעודי קרקע אכן מתממשות ? מתודולוגיה להערכת ישום תוכניות יעודי קרקע באמצעות ממ"ג

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


2812677

?

"


2812677

Do Plans Get Implemented? A Review of Evaluation in Planning (1996)

Emily Talen

Planning needs to develop its own brand of evaluation research

that is sensitive to the physically, spatially referenced side of planning-specifically, the making of plans that seek to guide the future physical development of cities .

It is often said that there is no theory for planning or plan-making in particular, perhaps this is because there is no firm understanding of what planning has, in fact , Done.


2812677

Research in Planning Implementation:

Measuring the Level of Implementation

Implementation of Urban Land Use Plans (1978)

Rachelle Alterman; Morris Hill

Comparing outline plans of the Krayot area with 84 detailed plans over the years 1964-1974.

Evaluating Plan Implementation: A conformance-Based Methodology (2004)

Lucie Laurin et al

Linkages between plan policies and permits; and evaluation of policy implementation

with each permit.

Does Planning Work? Testing the Implementation of Local Environmental Planning in

Florida (2005)

Samuel D. Broody and Wesley E. Highfield

Comparing clusters of permits granted for wetland development with comprehensive plans,

using GIS.


2812677

Planning Implementation Evaluation

.

:

Conformance based approach

.

. .

Performance based approach

.

. ,

.


2812677

.


2812677


2812677

"

:

?

" " " " ?

?

?

?


2812677


2812677

'


2812677


2812677

' :

1989, 17 .

4 .

' 31 .

/6671 1993

6386 1992

/668 1989

60%

,

.

.


2812677

14 ,

: 11 .

1979

1987

1993

.

,

".


2812677

  • ?

'


2812677

2. " " " " ?

'

'


2812677

.

.


2812677

3. ?

" - " .

"

10 Dunam* 0.36 =

(10 Dunam Area of roads)*0.36 =

- "

.

10 Dunam* 0.36 -BuildArea ' =

(10 Dunam Area of roads)*0.36} - BuildArea= '


2812677

3. ?

Comparing the plan potential area of a certain land use

with the non-conformance area of that land use

'


2812677

4. ?


2812677

1986-1992

1976-1986

40%


2812677

5. ?

.

: ,

.


2812677

1999-2006

1992-1999

1988-1992

: 12.9

: 9.2

: 13.5

: 9.2

: 5.7

: 6.2

1988-1992 1999-2006

((P <0.05 .

.

usage of cell potential

usage of cell potential

usage of cell potential

1999-2006

1992-1999

1988-1992

: 9

: 5.4

: 14.2

: 13

: 18.5

: 10.9

usage of cell potential

usage of cell potential

usage of cell potential

usage of cell potential


2812677

  • ' 80-90%.

  • " " , . " .

  • " . : ", , .

  • " ", .


2812677

" 3 -


2812677

12

11 ".

133 "

10% .

1980, 1990, 2000, 2006.


2812677

"

" 3

" 3/21

"-"

"


2812677

" - 1990-2000

37%.

12 .

* -


2812677

?

.

.


2812677

.


2812677

" 3

1980-1990

1980-1990

: 10,151

: 2,316

: 7,323

: 1,055

p=0.23)) 1980-1990

.

1990-2000

1990-200

- 1990-2000, (p<0.01).

.

: 5,555

: 504

: 11,382

: 1,220


2812677


  • Login