Resilience trauma and narrative
Sponsored Links
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
1 / 27

Resilience, Trauma and Narrative PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 64 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Resilience, Trauma and Narrative. Dr Nigel Hunt Institute of Work, Health & Organisations University of Nottingham International Reader in Traumatic Stress Studies, University of Helsinki. Aims. Conceptualising resilience in the context of traumatic stress The importance of narrative

Download Presentation

Resilience, Trauma and Narrative

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Resilience, Trauma and Narrative

Dr Nigel Hunt

Institute of Work, Health & Organisations

University of Nottingham

International Reader in Traumatic Stress Studies, University of Helsinki


Aims

  • Conceptualising resilience in the context of traumatic stress

  • The importance of narrative

  • Transforming trauma


‘Traumatic Event’

  • An event that involves death, serious injury, or is life-threatening

    • To self or others

  • War, disaster, rape, sexual abuse, other violent crime, , unexpected death of loved one, becoming a refugee, etc

    • Controversial list

    • What is traumatic to one person isn’t to others


History of trauma

  • Relatively recent construct

    • Though widely written about: Iliad, Battle of Marathon

  • From shellshock to PTSD

    • WWI to Vietnam

  • Emphasis on the social construct

    • Serves different purposes across time

      • Physiological to psychological

      • Need for compensation


Problems with trauma research

  • Growing expectation of negative outcome

  • ‘symptoms’ are often normal distress

    • Overemphasised by self-report measures

    • ‘interest’ rather than ‘intrusion’

  • We think what we are told to think

  • Minority get PTSD


Adaptiveness

  • Historical evolutionary perspective

  • We are adapted to cope with stressful and traumatic events

  • We learn from such experiences

  • ‘positive growth’

  • ‘resilience’


Defining resilience

  • The ability to bounce back or recover after a setback

  • Positive capacity of people to cope after a catastrophe

  • A return to homeostasis

  • Adaptive system, using stress to provide resistance to future stressful events


Terms used in Psychology

  • Resilience

  • Psychological resilience

  • Hardiness

  • Resourcefulness

  • Mental toughness

  • Emotional resilience

  • Ability to thrive

  • Note the focus on the individual


Resilience

  • Distinct uses:

  • Negative:

    • Outcome (of stress & coping processes)

    • Process

      • Internal factors (eg biological, personality)

      • External factors (environment, events, people)

  • Positive

    • Humanistic psychology – thriving, fulfilling potential despite stressful events

    • Stress as challenging and opportunities for growth


Trauma and resilience

  • 3 key areas for research

    • Recovery

    • Resistance

    • Reconfiguration

      • PTG, PTSD, neutral change

  • Individual differences

    • Between and within

  • Develop resilience through experience

    • Build personal resources

    • Remove risk factors

  • Schnurr (2004)

    • Protect against war-related PTSD with: older age, more education, higher SES, positive paternal relationship (pre-war), social support (post-war)


Narrative

  • We are all storytellers

  • coherence

  • Meaning making

  • Audience

  • Theory and method

  • Janet

    • From traumatic memory to narrative memory

  • Bruner

    • Narrative and paradigmatic psychology


Resilience and narrative

  • We can see successful narrative development as a resilience factor

  • Two forms

    • Narrative of resilience

      • Teaching people that they can cope

    • Post-trauma narratives

      • Helping people to rebuild their lives

  • Examples of narrative to show how resilience can be built/aided


Narrative coherence

  • Burnell, Hunt & Coleman

  • Interview research with war veterans

  • Higher levels of coherence linked to lower level of symptoms

  • Those with disjointed or incomplete narratives experienced more PTSD symptoms


Narrative Exposure Therapy

  • Developed for use with refugees

  • Combination of CBT and testimony therapy

  • Good evidence for effectiveness

    • Systematic review

  • Used in China with victims of earthquake


NET and Earthquake survivors

  • Yang, Hunt & Cox

  • Pilot study

  • 22 survivors of Szechuan earthquake with significant symptoms of PTSD

  • NET Adapted for Chinese use


Method

  • Measures: IES-R, GHQ, HADS, CiOQ, coping and social support

    • Translated into Chinese

  • Delayed control design, 4 test points

    • Pretest

    • Gp 1 intervention Gp 2 control

    • Test

    • Gp 1 control Gp 2 intervention

    • Test

    • 2 month follow up


PTSD symptoms


General Health Questionnaire


Anxiety & Depression


Negative thoughts


Positive thoughts


  • No change for coping or social support

  • Demonstrates effectiveness of NET

  • Can teach/help people to tell the story of their trauma, to become more resilient

  • Further research includes larger scale study of NET, Pennebaker paradigm, interviews & questionnaires


Developing narratives in Baghdad

  • Jaber, Hunt & Sabin-Farrell

  • Development of learning package for Baghdad students

    • Understanding trauma

    • Understanding symptoms

    • Understanding how to deal with symptoms


Method

  • Experimental and control groups

    • Simplified due to violence in Baghdad

  • 125 participants (45M, 80F)

    • high PTSD score

  • Ps work through learning package

  • Pre- and post-test measures

    • HADS, IES-R, COPE


Findings

  • Significant reductions in PTSD symptoms and anxiety and depression

  • Changes to coping styles

    • Increased use of:

      • Active coping, venting, positive reframing, planning, acceptance

    • Decreased use of:

      • Self-distraction, use of emotional support, humour, religion, self-blame


Interpretation

  • Learning package helped Ps deal with symptoms

  • Recognition that their feelings were not their fault

  • Making meaning, learning resilience

  • Changes to coping reflect recognising which strategies are more effective

    • Yang coping measure too basic?


Conclusions

  • Narrative is important resilience factor

    • Can help rebuild meaning structure after a traumatic event

  • Resilience linked to making sense of stressful or traumatic events

    • Improving coping skills

    • Understanding what traumatic events do to a person

  • Importance of the other

    • Audience/social support


  • Login