1 / 27

Science & Politics

Science & Politics. Science & Politics. a centrally important topic a large and manifold topic many meanings: science policy academic politics micropolitics of gender etc. political implications of science here: “scientific politics”. Science & Politics. this lecture:

scott
Download Presentation

Science & Politics

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Science & Politics

  2. Science & Politics • a centrally important topic • a large and manifold topic many meanings: • science policy • academic politics • micropolitics of gender etc. • political implications of science • here: “scientific politics”

  3. Science & Politics this lecture: • history of scientific politics • protests against scientific politics • critique & alternative view

  4. 1. scientific politics • roots in Enlightenment • the project of Enlightenment • science and social progress • reason in public affairs

  5. 1. scientific politics Montesquieu (1689-1755): • l’Esprit des Lois (1748) • climate & polity • scientific basis: • Boerhaave’s physiology • his own experiments

  6. 1. scientific politics Turgot (1727-1781): • physiocrat • vs. tradition&privilege • for economic reforms, rational government • based on a science of man and of society • minister to Louis XVI

  7. 1. scientific politics Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832): • utilitarianism • the greatest happiness for the greatest number

  8. 1. scientific politics • later 19th and 20th century incarnations: • Marxism • positivism • Technocracy movement (Thorstein Veblen) • Scientific Management (Taylorism) • 2 less known examples

  9. 1. scientific politics Pieter Eijkman (1862-1914) • physician • World Capital near The Hague • Peace Palace • scientific academies & research institutes • like social medicine

  10. 1. scientific politics Pieter Eijkman (1862-1914) • physician • World Capital near The Hague • Peace Palace • scientific academies & research institutes • like social medicine

  11. 1. scientific politics Pieter Eijkman (1862-1914) • physician • World Capital near The Hague • Peace Palace • scientific academies & research institutes • like social medicine

  12. 1. scientific politics • Jan Burgers: • background as communist • cultural pessimism • science and values • Study Center for Social Issues (1946) • influence postwar government • Central Planning Bureau

  13. 1. scientific politics • H.G. Wells: • SF author • influence • World State • science/ scientists experts

  14. 2. protests • Mary Shelley, Frankenstein (1817) • background • story • Edmund Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790)

  15. 2. protests • Aldous Huxley, Brave New World (1932) • background • story (incubators, classes, soma, stability, happiness, science) • ambiguity? • anti-Wells

  16. 2. protests • Jurgen Habermas: • decisionistic society • experts no longer ‘on tap’ but ‘on top’ • depolitization • technocracy

  17. 3. critique • common elements advocates and critics: • science as one best way • presumed one way traffic: science  politics • objections: • history scientisms: various political orientations • as much politics inside as outside science • two historical examples

  18. 3. critique Example 1: • Royal Society program of experimental science around 1650 vs • Thomas Hobbes

  19. 3. critique • competing understandings of natural philosophy (aim, place of experiment, certainty, publicness) • opinion/fact • context of Restoration England

  20. 3. critique • competing understandings of natural philosophy (aim, place of experiment, certainty, publicness) • opinion/fact • context of Restoration England

  21. 3. critique Example 2: • Lavoisier’s ‘new’ chemistry around 1780 vs • Phlogiston chemistry

  22. 1. critique • new table of elements • new nomenclature: e.g. “oxygène de fer” • theory • single experiments • quantification

  23. 3. critique • context of physiocracy & state policies • FR and Napoleon

  24. 3. critique Conclusion: • expert diversity • Politics in science/science in politics • impossibility of technocracy

More Related