Allocation in application layer networks
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 24

Allocation in Application Layer Networks PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Exploring Decentralized Resource. Allocation in Application Layer Networks. T. Eymann, M. Reinicke Albert-Ludwigs-University, Freiburg (DE) O. Ardaiz, P. Artigas, L. Díaz de Cerio, F. Freitag, R. Messeguer, L. Navarro, D. Royo Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, Barcelona (ES).

Download Presentation

Allocation in Application Layer Networks

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript

Allocation in application layer networks

Exploring Decentralized Resource

Allocation in Application Layer Networks

T. Eymann, M. ReinickeAlbert-Ludwigs-University, Freiburg (DE)

O. Ardaiz, P. Artigas, L. Díaz de Cerio, F. Freitag, R. Messeguer, L. Navarro, D. RoyoUniversitat Politècnica de Catalunya, Barcelona (ES)

CATNET project – Open Research, Evaluation(3/2002-3/2003)

Problem and objective

Problem and objective

  • Problem: Provisioning services

    • Requiring (huge amount of) resources

    • From large number of computers

    • CDN, Grid and P2P

  • Objective: evaluation of decentralized mechanism for resource allocation, based on economic paradigm: Catallaxy. (compare against a centralized mechanism using an arbitrator object)

  • A concrete case for an application is, for instance, the distributed provisioning of web services for Adobe’s Acrobat (for creating PDF files) in an Akamai-like application layer network.

Application layer networks aln

Application Layer Networks (ALN)

  • Application layer networks are software architectures that allow the provisioning of services requiring a huge amount of resources by connecting large numbers of individual computers. They are built over a base network that is used to support this second network, “layered” upon the underlying infrastructure.

  • Motivation:

    • ALN have dynamic demands

  • Deployment/Allocation Requirements:

    • Programable Infrastructure:

      • Nodes with BW, Storage & Processing Resources.

    • Deployment/Allocation Mechanisms:

      • Resource Allocation Algorithm, ….

Aln lifecycle

ALN Lifecycle

  • Phases:

    • Deployment: initial positioning of resources. Deployment can also be economically modeled, although we treat as if done.

    • Allocation: main focus here.

      • Allocates resources for the demands.

      • Changes resource locations:

        • Migrate

        • Clone

Catallaxy basics

Catallaxy Basics

  • Catallaxy is an alternative word for “market economy” (Mises and Von Hayek of the Neo-austrian economic school)

  • “Fundamentally, in a system in which the knowledge of the relevant facts is dispersed among many people, prices can act to co-ordinate the separate actions of different people in the same way as subjective values help the individual to co-ordinate the parts of his plan.” (Friedrich A. von Hayek, The Use of Knowledge in Society, 1945)

  • “The Market” as a technically decentralized, distributed, dynamic coordination mechanism

    • Adam Smith’s “invisible hand”

    • Hayek’s “spontaneous order”

    • Walras’ “non-tâtonnement process”



  • Coordination mechanism for systems consisting of autonomous decentralized devices.

  • Based on constant negotiation and price signaling

  • Based on efforts from both agent technology and economics

  • Agents are able to adapt their strategies using machine learning mechanisms

    • Evolution of software agent strategies, a stabilization of prices throughout the system and self-regulating coordination patterns

  • Earlier work has used economic principles for resource allocation in distributed computer systems, but most of these approaches rely on using a centralized auctioneer

Catallaxy properties

Spontaneous order of the participants

„Unplanned result of individuals' planful actions“ (Hayek)

Constitutive Elements of the Catallaxy

Access to a Market

Knowledge about availability of resources is transported through price information

Constitutional Ignorance

Self-interest and autonomy of participants

Ability to choose between alternative actions


Dynamic Co-Evolution

Income expectations and price relations stabilize development


Tragedy of commons

Free riding

Catallaxy properties

Catnet properties

Catnet Properties

  • Agent-based solution is always inferior to analytical optimization

  • Information

    • The more information is available, the more accurate are the choices

    • The more agents, the more information exists

  • Computation

    • Computation is fully parallel (no central bottleneck)

    • Solution always exists in the system (no non-allocated resource)

Agents state

Agents State

  • Agents genotype:

    • Acquisitiveness

    • Satisfaction

    • Price Step

    • Price Next

    • Weight Memory

    • Reputation

  • For each service:

    • Price Distribution

  • For each negotiation:

    • Negotiation History

Parameters to measure

Parameters to measure

  • Social Welfare (SWF):

    • Sum of all utilities over all participants, in a given timespan

      • Clients subjectively value SC access

      • Prices change due to “supply and demand”

    • Individual utility = transaction price – market value

  • Also: Response Time (REST), Resource allocation efficiency (RAE), Communication cost (CC), Client-Resource assignment distance.

Experimental simulator

Experimental Simulator

  • Abstracts from a concrete application and implementation.

  • Allows „plug-in“ of different „middleware“ resource allocation mechanisms.

    • Allows easy changes of

      • Decentralized agent strategies

      • Centralized allocation mechanisms.

Simulation of alns






In an “abstract” simulator





, ad







node density








A few, powerful

A lot, modest


Simulation of ALNs




  • The Catnet simulator is build over JavaSim, JavaSim is a network simulator based in autonomous components.

  • Javasim models almost every aspect of a real network: latency, bandwith, lost packets, routing, …

  • It has some of the more common internet protocols like DV, TCP, UDP, …

  • So our components can be easily modified to work in the real world changing the middleware to real sockets.





Port 101

Port 102

Port 103


  • On top of the physical nodes, a number of different software agents are created, which form the application layer network:

    • Client (C): computer program at host, requests service

    • Service Copy (SC): instance of service, hosted in a resource computer

    • Resource (R): host computer with limited storage and bandwidth

  • Independent on each other at javasim level

  • Running as programs with a socket on a computer

  • Configuration made at startup script



Catallactic message flow

Catallactic Message Flow



Generic behaviour on messages

Using generic functions:

- Bargain/RecommendedAction

- Price management

So changing strategies is easy

Particular behaviour on some messages



  • We use TCl to set-up the experiments:

    • Topology

    • Node configuration: wich components (C/R/SC/MSC) should be on each node.

    • Application Layer Network initialitzation

    • Agent parameters: bandwith, price ranges, money balance, genotype, …

    • Current experiment parameters

Output 1

Output - 1

Output 2

Output - 2

(Catallaxy shows development over time)

Output 3

Output - 3

Soundness of criteria

Soundness of Criteria

  • Interdepencies

    • SWF and RAE are dependent

      • Every transaction adds to SWF

      • More transactions add to RAE

    • SWF and CC are dependent

      • Higher CC lowers SWF

    • SWF and REST are dependent

      • Higher REST means more transactions

      • More transactions add to RAE and SWF

  • SWF captures all costs and revenues

  • Dependencies are an emergent feature of the system

    • No direct links have been implemented: economic reasoning works „bottom-up“ in an ACE sense



  • Initial simulation results prove that a decentralized, economic model works better in certain situations.

    • “Better” is a combination of factors (SWF)

  • Promising:

    • Large scale

    • Dynamic

    • Saturation



  • Future research work:

    • Agent technology layer

    • Application-specific layer

      • Both are linked in a feedback loop.

  • Also:

    • A lot of influencing parameters apart from Density and Dynamism, not fully evaluated due to time constraints.

Allocation in application layer networks


  • Any questions?

  • More info on

  • Login