Theory and practice of fertilizer subsidies in africa
Download
1 / 26

Theory and Practice of Fertilizer Subsidies in Africa - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 84 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Theory and Practice of Fertilizer Subsidies in Africa. B. L. Bumb Policy and Trade Specialist Consultant IFDC AAMP Regional Workshop for Agricultural Journalism Dar es Salaam, Tanzania June 30-July 2, 2010. Outline of the Presentation. The Need for Mineral Fertilizers

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha

Download Presentation

Theory and Practice of Fertilizer Subsidies in Africa

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Theory and practice of fertilizer subsidies in africa
Theory and Practice of Fertilizer Subsidies in Africa

  • B. L. Bumb

  • Policy and Trade Specialist Consultant

  • IFDC

  • AAMP Regional Workshop for Agricultural Journalism

  • Dar es Salaam, Tanzania

  • June 30-July 2, 2010


  • Outline of the presentation
    Outline of the Presentation

    • The Need for Mineral Fertilizers

    • Rationale for Fertilizer Subsidies

    • Pros and Cons of Subsidies

    • Market Friendly Alternatives to Subsidies

    • Subsidy Programs in Malawi, Tanzania, and Zambia

    • The Way Forward


    Food production and fertilizer use
    Food Production and Fertilizer use

    Food production

    Replenishing the nutrients removed by harvested crops

    Facilitating the adoption of high-yielding varieties

    Natural Resource Management- Soils

    Maintenance of nutrient stocks



    East asia south asia south america sub saharan africa total fertilizer use 1980 2006
    East Asia, South Asia, South America, Sub-Saharan Africa Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005Total Fertilizer Use1980–2006

    Source: Derived from FAO data.


    Nutrient mining in agricultural lands of africa
    Nutrient Mining in Agricultural Lands of Africa Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    1995–97

    2002–04


    Role of policy
    Role of Policy Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    Environmentally Sound Fertilizer Use depends on the Trinity of :

    Products

    Practices

    Policies


    Role of subsidy in promoting fertilizer use
    Role of Subsidy in Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005Promoting Fertilizer Use

    • It improves incentives for fertilizer use and thereby helps in promoting food production and agricultural growth

    • It reduces risk in the use of a new product

    • It helps poor farmers in the learning process


    Theory and practice of fertilizer subsidies in africa

    Price Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    S

    A

    Subsidy = P1–P2

    P1

    C

    B

    P2

    D

    O

    Q0

    Q1

    Q2

    Quantity

    Fertilizer Subsidy System


    Limitations of subsidy
    Limitations of Subsidy Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • It distorts the functioning of the market

    • It prevents the development of competitive markets

    • It creates fiscal burdens

    • It promotes rent-seeking and political interference


    Market friendly alternatives to fertilizer subsidies
    Market Friendly Alternatives to Fertilizer Subsidies Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Reduce supply price by shifting the supply curve to the right

    • Provide purchasing power support (PPS) to the poor

    • Make Social Investment in Acidic Soils


    Theory and practice of fertilizer subsidies in africa

    The SSCR Approach* Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    *Shifting the Supply Curve to the Right.


    The five pillars of market development
    The Five Pillars of Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005Market Development

    Policy

    Finance

    Market

    Information

    Regulation

    Human Capital


    Other supporting measures
    Other Supporting Measures Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Integration of multi-country markets—developing business linkages

    • Technology transfer efforts

    • Infrastructure improvement—ports, rural roads and railway capacity


    Pps to the poor
    PPS to the Poor Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Market development is “necessary but not sufficient” for improving food security in the rural areas.

    • Market development efforts should be supplemented by PPS to include poor people in the market process—The Voucher System.


    Subsidy vs pps
    Subsidy vs. PPS Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    Subsidy is for a product

    PPS (for inputs) is for the people

    “Support the people, not the product”

    Empowering people to participate in the marketplace through input vouchers will kill two birds with one stone—alleviate hunger and poverty and develop markets


    Schematic diagram of the targeted voucher system
    Schematic Diagram of Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005the Targeted Voucher System

    Coordinating

    Entity

    Voucher

    Recommendations for selection of farmers

    Banks

    Voucher

    Reimbursement

    MOA/NGO

    Input

    Dealer

    Extension

    Department

    Community

    Organization

    Voucher

    Best Management Practices

    Best Management Practices

    Voucher

    Farmer

    Fertilizer Supplies


    Fertilizer subsidies in malawi
    Fertilizer Subsidies in Malawi Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Vouchers are distributed to targeted farmers

    • Voucher value- 2 bags of fertilizer and 10 kg improved seed

    • Average subsidy- over 70%

    • 1.5 million farmers were targeted

    • Imports by private sector; tenders by GOM; and distribution by ADMARC

    • Cost $150-180 M


    Impacts of the program
    Impacts of the Program Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Increase in maize production; promoting food security

    • Destruction of small agro-dealers

    • Negative impact on the market development

    • High fiscal costs

    • The Dependency Syndrome

    • Delays in voucher redemption


    Fertilizer subsidies in zambia
    Fertilizer Subsidies in Zambia Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Fertilizer Support Program (FSP)/Farmer Input Support Program (FISP)

    • Private sector imports; supplies to GOZ on tenders

    • Product is distributed to district agricultural committees/camp agricultural committees (CACs)

    • Farmers pay 50% of the cost

    • 4 bags now (8 bags before) for each smallholder; 500,000 farmers targeted


    Impacts of the program1
    Impacts of the Program Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Increase in maize production (2.7 M tons)

    • Negative impact on the private sector and market development

    • No agro-dealer development in rural areas

    • Dual pricing system- subsidized product coming back to the market

    • Farmers do not have an easy access to fertilizers

    • Delays in tender process


    Purchasing power support in tanzania
    Purchasing Power Support in Tanzania Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • 1.5 million farmers are targeted

    • PPS to smallholder farmers- 2 bags of fertilizers or equivalent and seed

    • Promoting the use of domestic resource- MPR

    • Agro-dealers are involved in redeeming vouchers

    • MNB is responsible for redeeming vouchers


    Impacts of the program2
    Impacts of the Program Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Increase in food production

    • Delays in voucher redemption

    • Targeting of the poor- political

    • Very poor are not reached

    • Fiscal sustainability


    The way forward
    The Way Forward Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    • Focus on improving the efficiency and effectiveness of the market

    • Develop PPS for the poor but no free lunch

    • Involve private sector in voucher redemption

    • Provide good mechanisms for redemption of vouchers by banks


    Theory and practice of fertilizer subsidies in africa

    THANK YOU VERY MUCH Fertilizer Use, 1961-2005

    FOR YOUR ATTENTION


    ad
  • Login