1 / 12

The LLR Legal Study Update

The LLR Legal Study Update. Andrew Charlesworth Senior Research Fellow, Centre for IT & Law University of Bristol JISC MLEs for Lifelong Learning Programme Meeting Manchester 24 th June 2004. Purpose of Study. Identify & assess legal risks arising from the development of a national LLR.

ruana
Download Presentation

The LLR Legal Study Update

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The LLRLegal StudyUpdate Andrew Charlesworth Senior Research Fellow, Centre for IT & Law University of Bristol JISC MLEs for Lifelong Learning Programme Meeting Manchester 24th June 2004

  2. Purpose of Study • Identify & assess legal risks arising from the development of a national LLR. • Assess legal risks arising in relation to wider use of LLR data - linkages to external data sources. • Assess perceptions of legal/extralegal risks/benefits of LLR amongst stakeholders, regulators & other interested parties. • Liaise with & provide guidance & support to existing JISC MLE/LLR projects etc. • Produce strategic reports on the key legal issues likely to affect the direction and viability of the LLR

  3. Workpackages • The study will carry out 4 workpackages: • Project Killer Workpackage - legal risks to the main objectives of the LLR. Deliverable - Report. • Aspect Killer Workpackage - legal risks relating to wider use of LLR data. Deliverable - report & guidance documentation. • Legal Aspects of Metadata Workpackage - LLR transcript/PDP metadata - best practice for collection, processing & disposal of learner info. in line with relevant law. Deliverable - Report. • Application Profiles Workpackage - legal aspects of generic application profiles, including vocabularies. Deliverable - guidance documentation.

  4. Project Killer Report • Assessment of legal risks that could derail a national LLR system • Main areas of legal risk arising from the proposed LLR concept: • Administrative/management framework • Data protection, privacy and confidentiality • User accessibility and disabilities • The international dimension

  5. Context of Legal Risk • Legal system doesn’t operate in a vacuum – both development and application. • As with national ID cards much rests on perceptions of general public: • Valuable resource/administrative boondoggle • State or commercial intrusion into privacy • Discriminatory or exclusionary mechanism • Lack of info + lack of trust likely to mean legal problems.

  6. Difficulty of assessing legal risk • Purpose and functions of a national LLR system currently remain unfocussed. • Difficult to: • make definitive assessments of the nature and scope of legal issues, or • develop protocols for determining acceptable types of future data use/LLR system change • This will have to be addressed in order to: • provide reassurance to learners that their data will be fairly and lawfully dealt with, and • permit ESPs to undertake informed risk assessment and make provision for dealing with potential liability.

  7. Liability, Risk & Structure • Failure to understand & address potential legal risks to ESPs will hinder their ability to limit, or provide for, legal liability. • Early development of a practicable technical and administrative structure will be key to the success of a national LLR system. • Simply scaling up existing regional projects is unlikely to provide a suitable national framework without some form of centrally organised infrastructural support, e.g. back-up/archiving.

  8. Data Protection Law • A national LLR system will need adequate provision for requirements of DP legislation when: • transferring personal data between ESPs • supplying personal data to non-ESP 3rd parties. • Legal issues to be assessed: • Can purposes and functions envisaged for a national LLR system be achieved fairly and lawfully; • Can the technical & administrative structure provide data subjects with adequate means to enforce their legal rights within a highly distributed data system.

  9. User Accessibility • A national LLR system will have to be capable of meeting the requirements of • disabled users; • users for whom a LLR transcript/PDP in English is of little or no value; • users who have limited, or no, access to the technological base required to access electronically-held LLR data; and, • users with overseas qualifications, learning experiences, or employment which do not map easily/at all to the national LLR system schema

  10. International Issues • Education is increasingly a trans-national operation, esp. at FE/HE level, with fierce competition for students. • Lack of concerted co-operation between national/regional interest groups to assess legal risks arising at trans-national level • National LLR system will need to avoid an inadvertent conflict with: • EU free internal market in goods and services • International trade liberalisation in educational services.

  11. Overview • It is unlikely that UK law will provide a ‘project killer’ scenario for a national LLR. • It is likely that technical & administrative measures can be used to address or ameliorate potential legal problems. • Alternatively, UK government may adopt legal measures, via primary or secondary legislation, to provide such solutions.

  12. Recommendations • R1 - Widening Participation, Greater Publicity • R2 - Need for initial base Function & Purpose Model • R3 - Need for clear advance Technical & Admin. Infrastructure Planning • R4 - Data Protection guidance materials & instruction for LLR projects • R5 – Need for discussion forums for LLR interest groups at a European level to share experiences of legal problems and solutions

More Related