The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 41

The Role of Taxes and Education Funding in Charting Michigan’s Economic Future: PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 49 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

The Role of Taxes and Education Funding in Charting Michigan’s Economic Future:. Richard G. Sims Sierra Institute on Applied Economics Carson City, Nevada November 2006. A quick look at Michigan state and local tax effort, by taxpayer income catagory. Richard G. Sims

Download Presentation

The Role of Taxes and Education Funding in Charting Michigan’s Economic Future:

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

The Role of Taxes and Education Funding in Charting Michigan’s Economic Future:

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics

Carson City, Nevada

November 2006


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

A quick look at Michigan state and local tax effort, by taxpayer income catagory

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Michigan Taxes

Source: Who Pays?: A Distributional Analysis of the Tax Systems of All 50 States, Second Edition, Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, 2003.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

…and how they have changed.

Source: Who Pays?: A Distributional Analysis of the Tax Systems of All 50 States, Second Edition, Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, 2003.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

FY 2004-2005

Source: Michigan Department of Management & Budget, Comprehensive Annual Financial Report, and Senate Fiscal Agency, Updated March 2006.


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

What Public Policies Influence State Economic Growth?

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Do low business taxes lead to economic growth?

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Chart A: The 10 Fastest Growing States’ Corporate Income Tax Rates: Average7.1%

NOTE: States in italic are "no income tax" states; Rates are in percent and are those in place 1/1/2004.

SOURCE: Income data from U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis; tax rates from Federation of Tax Administrators, www.taxadmin.org.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Chart B: The 10 Slowest Growth States’ Corporate Income Tax Rates: Average6.25%

NOTE: States in italic are "no income tax" states; Rates are those in place 1/1/2004.

SOURCE: Income data from U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis; tax rates from Federation of Tax Administrators, www.taxadmin.org.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


In fact over the last decade

In fact, over the last decade…

High growth states actually had comparatively high average corporate income tax rates.

Slow growth states had corporate tax rates below the U.S. average.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

But doesn’t being “Business Tax Friendly” or being seen as having a favorable Business Climate encourage a states economic growth?

Let’s see--

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


Chart a states ranked most business tax friendly

Chart A: States ranked MOST ‘Business Tax Friendly’

Tax Foundation Rankings

SOURCE: Tax Foundation, Inc.,State Business Tax Climate Index

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


Chart b states ranked least business tax friendly

Chart B: States ranked LEAST ‘Business Tax Friendly

SOURCE: Tax Foundation, Inc.,State Business Tax Climate Index

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

In addition, the Actual Effective Rates that Corporations pay on their Profits has Declined Substantially Over the Last Several Years…

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Source: Data from Federation of Tax Administrators and the U.S. Department of Commerce.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

How about the effect of the overall “Business Climate”…

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Site Selection Magazine, November, 2006


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Only 7 of the Top Ranked 25 states grew as fast a the US average-

Only 2 of the Top Ranked states were in the top 10 growth states-

7 of the Top Ranked states were among the 10 slowest growing states.

Site Selection magazine, Nov. 2006; Bureau of Labor Statistics website; calculations by the author.


One reason corporate income taxes don t have much influence on state s comparative growth

One Reason Corporate Income Taxes Don’t Have Much Influence on State’s Comparative Growth-

Rates Don’t Vary Greatly from State-to-State--

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

State Corporate Income Tax Rates

Maximum Corporate Tax Rate

¾ of states have rates between 6%-9%

IOWA

Mid-Point 7.5%

MINNESOTA

ILLINOI

S

WISCONSIN

The 45 States with a Corporate Income Tax

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

From the previous chart

Lowest rate– Kansas, 4%: growth rank 26th

Highest rate—Iowa, 12%: growth rank 27th

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


Another reason corporate income taxes don t determine a state economic growth

Another Reason Corporate Income Taxes Don’t Determine a State Economic Growth…

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics

Source: U.S. Department of Commerce, National Income and Product Accounts, 2003.


What firms say are their major cost considerations when relocating

What Firms Say Are Their Major Cost Considerations When Relocating

Source: Robert M. Ady, “The Effects of State and Local Public Services on Economic Development,” New England Economic Review, March/April, 1997.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Similarly, taxes on individuals don’t appear to determine states’ growth…

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

In general, states with high economic growth had relatively higher taxes.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


A note on international comparisons

A note on international comparisons--


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Elementary & Secondary Spending

Average growth for the 50 states and DC: 4.1%

SOURCE: Education spending data from National Center for Education Statistics, http://nces.ed.gov; income data from U.S. Bureau of the Census, Bureau of Economic Analysis.


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

ELASTICITIE$

How revenues grow over time determines states’ ability to fund futureservices-

Typical Long-Term 50 State Averages

Personal Income Tax1.04

Corporate Income Tax0.95

Sales Taxes0.97

Property Taxes0.96

Cigarettes (avg. all states)0.48

Lottery (avg. all states)0.52

These all grow slower than the economy

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Heavy reliance on sales and excise taxes and lotteries constrain state’s ability to fund future services, many of which are crucial to economic growth and development.


A look at economic interaction between taxes spending and state economic growth

A look at economic interaction between taxes, spending and state economic growth.


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

A Dynamic General Equilibrium Analysis of a Balanced Budget Tax and Spending Increase

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

A Dynamic General Equilibrium, Balanced Budget Analysis of Proposal 5

Source: Richard Sims, using the REMI economic model for Michigan.


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Source: The Long-Term Effects of TABOR on the Michigan Economy, Sierra Institute on Applied Economics, September, 2006..


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Source: The Long-Term Effects of TABOR on the Michigan Economy, Sierra Institute on Applied Economics, September, 2006..


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Source: Tax Limitations, Education Funding Measures and Economic Growth: A Look at Michigan, Sierra Institute on Applied Economics.


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

Source: The Economic Impact of the Georgia Lottery, Carl Vinson Institute of Government, University of Georgia.


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

“I know of no valid economic theory that suggests that tax cuts provide more economic stimulation than would a similar amount of government spending.”

Former Congressional Budget Office Director, Robert Reischauer

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

So, why does education spending have such a large impact on job creation?

Near-Term:

-Labor intensity

-Local purchase intensity

-Larger share of total business costs

Long-Term:

-Amenity value

-Source of productivity

-Source of competitiveness

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


A concern for michigan s future

A Concern for Michigan’s Future

Over the decade of the 1900’s, Illinois lost 121,000 college graduates to other states.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


The role of taxes and education funding in charting michigan s economic future

CONCLUSIONS

  • Low taxes are not the key to creating jobs and income in a state.

  • Low taxes are associated with low levels of public services.

  • Spending on K-12 education can be a significant contributor to economic growth.

Richard G. Sims

Sierra Institute on Applied Economics


  • Login