1 / 17

Sub-Regional Workshop for the North Pacific: Integrating MDGs into National Development Strategies and Budgets

Sub-Regional Workshop for the North Pacific: Integrating MDGs into National Development Strategies and Budgets. PRO-POOR POLICIES What Are They? How Do They Contribute to the Achievement of the MDGs? David Abbott Regional Macroeconomic and Poverty Reduction Advisor UNDP Pacific Centre

ronny
Download Presentation

Sub-Regional Workshop for the North Pacific: Integrating MDGs into National Development Strategies and Budgets

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Sub-Regional Workshop for the North Pacific:Integrating MDGs into National Development Strategiesand Budgets PRO-POOR POLICIES What Are They? How Do They Contribute to the Achievement of the MDGs? David Abbott Regional Macroeconomic and Poverty Reduction Advisor UNDP Pacific Centre david.abbott@undp.org regionalcentrepacific.undp.org.fj

  2. What is Pro-Poor Policy • Pro-poor policy aims to target those who are most disadvantaged, in income, opportunity or hardship • Pro-poor policies will lead to: • An increase in the income levels of the poor faster than the average rate of growth in income as a whole • A reduction in recorded poverty levels: MDG 1 and national poverty lines • An improvement in other MDG indicators, and • An improvement in the HDI and HPI indicators • MDG Reports suggest that growth has NOT been pro-poor - or at least not sufficiently pro-poor to be making a real impact on poverty and MDGs

  3. “Good” Pro-poor Policy • Policy may be pro-poor when: • It is labour rather than capital intensive • Targets sectors in which the poor are employed or engaged • Rural: agriculture and fisheries (rural) • Urban: labour intensive sectors including construction, services • It creates income and employment for the poor and disadvantaged: • Youth and other unemployed (low-skilled) • Women • Other disadvantaged groups (elderly, disabled, displaced people, rural/urban migrants) • Targeted at individual disadvantaged and poor groups • Serves to reduce inequality • Growth is a necessary but not sufficient condition for poverty reduction

  4. Growth and MDGs: A Two-way Causality • Growth Human development and poverty reduction • Human development and poverty reduction Growth  MDGs are an end in themselves but also a means to achieving high quality, sustainable growth

  5. MDG-based National Development Strategy: Principles • Adopt pro-MDGaction programs: do not rely on “trickle down” (economic growth). • Adopt pro-poor, MDG-focused policies that will be pro-growth in the long run. • Ensure consistency between macro and growth policies, and pro-poor, MDG-focused policies. • Set localised targets and standards for key groups or regions: don’t rely on national averages. • Earmark funds for pro-por, MDG-focused policies in annual federal, state and local authority budgets and protect them from budget cuts.

  6. Economic and Social Policy Issues 1 • Low rates of economic growth • High rates of population growth • Declining per capita incomes • Weak fiscal situations and poorly defined budget parameters and priorities • Budget allocations are not priority or policy driven • Not always (often) linked to national strategies • Inequity in access to, and quality of, basic services between rural and urban areas

  7. Economic and Social Policy Issues 2 • Governance standards are often weak • Standards of basic service delivery are often poor • Weakening of social environment • Changing attitudes to traditional roles, customs and responsibilities: • Exposure to outside influences including: money, “western values” in social relations, alcohol/drugs, DVD/videos, access to information and knowledge etc • Weakening of traditional family discipline and ties • Increasing social and domestic tension • Lack of clearly defined pro-poor and sustainable development strategies to address these key issues

  8. Economic and Social Policy Issues 3 • Impact of economic reforms • Increases in user charges for government services • Changes in taxes and tariffs may lead to increases in basic food prices and other “essentials” • Increasing monetisation of subsistence economies • Lack of economic opportunity in the outer island/rural areas leads to urban drift/migration • Increasing dependency ratios in rural areas • Decreasing rural agricultural production • Urbanisation, deterioration in environmental health and rising social tensions • Increasing youth unemployment

  9. Linking National Strategies, Pro-poor Policy and the Budget • National Sustainable Development Strategies • Vision: 10 – 15 years • Pro-poor / sector priorities, policies and strategies • Strategic outcomes: 3 - 5 year time frame, may be longer • Sector interventions and investment • Need to prioritise and set timetable • Annual budgets should reflect national priorities • MTEF: needs to integrate national priorities and strategies and annual budgets through clearly costed pro-poor policies

  10. Costing Pro-poor and Other Policy 1 • Policy interventions must be properly costed • Policy costing methodology should be identified • Should give clear realistic costs and benefits • Casual forecasts/estimates are not sufficient • MTEF must be a deliberate planned and costed future programme • Links planning, policy, budgeting into an overall framework

  11. Costing Pro-poor and Other Policy 2 • Design and Implement Targeted Policies and Other Interventions • Targeted Interventions • How should they be targeted • direct transfers • subsidies • other policy influence/interventions • Assess the Impact of Policies on the Poor • Economic growth • Pro-poor budgeting; taxes and tariffs, user charges • Equitable social expenditure • Other targeted interventions including MDGs

  12. Costing Pro-poor and Other Policy 3 • Pro-Poor Budgeting and Social Spending • Who uses public services (health and education) • Do the poor and disadvantaged have equal access • How does the quality of service provided vary by location and social group (poor/non-poor, urban/rural) • Cost and allocation of resources by user group • Do the poor get a proportionate allocation of resources • Is there a gender balance in resource allocation • Unit cost of delivery/subsidy • Are the poor (or other groups) disadvantaged by user charges • Or the cost of accessing services • Impact of proposed policy interventions • Are policy interventions costed/assessed for pro-poor impact

  13. Budget and Economic Implications MDG 2 to 6 • Poor educational attainment and gender inequality: • Cost of additional teachers/classrooms/books and teaching materials • Loss of productive potential from poor educational attainment • Additional budget burden from consequences of poverty • Poor health: • Additional costs for clinics, hospitals, medications and treatment • Current burden on the budget • Better priority would be prevention rather than cure • Loss of production from sick workers • Loss of tax revenues • Poor health in childhood leads to poor health as adult • Future burden on the budget

  14. Budget and Economic Implications: MDG 7 & 8 • Social tensions: • Additional cost of law and order • Additional cost of other social welfare services • Pressure on infrastructure and public services: • New investment needed in roads, water, sanitation, power, health and education services to meet increased urban population • Additional maintenance costs • Urban/Rural migration: • Rural transport services and public utilities become (even) less financially viable • additional subsidies required • or higher charges place additional burdens on the rural poor – or their working relations in the urban centres • Unit cost of rural social service delivery (education, health) increases as rural populations decline

  15. Pro-Poor Policies: Summary and Conclusions • Growth alone is not enough • Patterns of growth are important • Growth in sectors in which poor are more likely to be involved, agriculture, fisheries, informal activities • Rural sector must be made more attractive • Enabling environment for economic opportunities to be created for the poor in their sectors • Access to resources and assets • Access to basic services • Access to rural financial services, credit facilities and financial literacy programmes • Decentralization, local empowerment and participation • Good governance • Land reform • Access to transport and markets • Access and other support to extension services

  16. Pro-poor Policies: A Virtuous Circle • The Growth Strategy • Creating sound macroeconomic and fiscal policy framework • Developing pro-poor, performance oriented budgets • Delivering cost-effective, efficient and quality services to all • Creating enabling environment for private sector • leads to • Creation of Employment • Generation of new economic opportunities • Increasing incomes • Resulting in • Economic growth and reduction of poverty • Raising welfare and progress towards MDG achievement

  17. Thank You David Abbott Regional Macroeconomic and Poverty Reduction Advisor UNDP Pacific Centre david.abbott@undp.org regionalcentrepacific.undp.org.fj

More Related