National association of auditors comptrollers and treasurers 2005 annual conference portland oregon
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 10

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF AUDITORS, COMPTROLLERS AND TREASURERS 2005 ANNUAL CONFERENCE Portland, Oregon PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 59 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF AUDITORS, COMPTROLLERS AND TREASURERS 2005 ANNUAL CONFERENCE Portland, Oregon. ERP Systems – Independent Auditor Perspective Presented by: Jim KreiserTom Marks Senior Manager, Ernst & YoungDeputy Auditor General for Audits

Download Presentation

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF AUDITORS, COMPTROLLERS AND TREASURERS 2005 ANNUAL CONFERENCE Portland, Oregon

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


National association of auditors comptrollers and treasurers 2005 annual conference portland oregon

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF AUDITORS, COMPTROLLERS AND TREASURERS2005 ANNUAL CONFERENCE Portland, Oregon

ERP Systems –

Independent Auditor Perspective

Presented by:

Jim KreiserTom Marks

Senior Manager, Ernst & YoungDeputy Auditor General for Audits

Technology and Security Risk ServicesPA Department of the Auditor General

Central Pennsylvania Market Leader


Erp systems auditor perspective

ERP Systems – Auditor Perspective

Agenda/Overview:

  • Benefits

  • Training

  • Audit Approach

  • Audit Challenges


Benefits

Benefits

  • ERP provides a basis for full accrual and budgetary reporting (simultaneously)

  • Better access to data (and tracking of historical information) to review and analyze estimations

  • Enhanced ability to review data on a consolidated basis


Benefits continued

Benefits (continued)

  • Possibilities for leveraging a controls approach for the audit (due to entity wide control implementation)

  • ERP Packages are working to develop and enhance modules and functionality for government entities such as tax collection, grant accounting, and budgetary statements


Training

Training

  • Based on the significance of the change from legacy systems to ERP, significant training and “learning curve” time is typically needed

  • Current customization needs and unique configurations for governments create a distinctive obstacle regarding auditing the ERP


Audit approach

Audit Approach

  • Audit efforts need to be re-evaluated to ensure the right approach of controls testing and substantive work

  • Challenges exist regarding “cultural” changes. Approaches taken for many years may need to be significantly altered, updated, or even omitted

  • Auditors must adjust to changes in reporting, changes in data formats, changes to processes, changes in controls, etc.


Audit challenges

Audit Challenges

  • Auditing of two systems during system implementation, including general controls and review of data from multiple systems (extent of this is dependent on the timing of “cutover” during the fiscal year)

  • Auditing of customized features and functionality poses a unique challenge

  • Updating, understanding, and auditing the various interfaces that may exist to and from the ERP can be more involved than anticipated


Challenges continued

Challenges (continued)

  • ERP systems provide a variety of methods to perform similar tasks. This can result in a lack of consistency across various agencies, departments, offices, etc. Such inconsistency results in greater effort for walkthroughs, testing, etc. and challenges auditors to question reliance on specific controls or processes

  • Auditing of data conversion processes during implementation often involve extensive effort


Challenges continued1

Challenges (continued)

  • Challenges exist related to Single Audit reporting, specifically around control processes which may not be as robust in a new system implementation as in the legacy applications

  • Auditors must ensure they understand data sources, data flows, and how to use the data appropriately (i.e. business warehouse, R/3, legacy systems, Treasury, etc.) An ERP or BW may provide reports regarding Medicaid for example, but this data and detail may reside in the actual Medicaid application


Summary

Summary

  • ERP packages provide an array of potential benefits from a user and auditor standpoint

  • ERP packages also pose unique obstacles and challenges, particularly during implementation and early years following implementation until processes and controls are more robust

  • Auditors and users alike face challenges regarding training/learning curve and cultural changes

  • Early involvement of auditors in implementation and proactive communication is essential


  • Login