1 / 19

Understanding Urban White Poverty

Understanding Urban White Poverty. Andrew Sears Executive Director, TechMission. True or False. White poverty is mostly rural. Urban poverty is mostly non-White. Lower income White individuals can experience more intense oppression than individuals from other racial groups.

paul
Download Presentation

Understanding Urban White Poverty

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Understanding Urban White Poverty Andrew Sears Executive Director, TechMission

  2. True or False • White poverty is mostly rural. • Urban poverty is mostly non-White. • Lower income White individuals can experience more intense oppression than individuals from other racial groups. • Some White ethnic groups faced oppression in the past, but that is now over for all White people. • Because no White people experience systemic oppression, poor white individuals are entirely responsible for their own poverty.

  3. Invisibility of Urban White Poverty Urban Poverty by Race/Hispanic Origin (metro area) From USDA, 1996 data, http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/rcat/rcat92/rcat92n.pdf

  4. Invisibility of Urban White Poverty Urban Poverty by Race/Hispanic Origin (central city only) From US Census 2003 Data and NARPAC http://www.narpac.org/RCA.HTM

  5. Rural Poverty is Mostly Non-White Rural Poverty by Race/Hispanic Origin From USDA, 1996 data, http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/rcat/rcat92/rcat92n.pdf

  6. Understanding White Poverty: Poverty Rates Source: US Census Data 2003

  7. Understanding White Poverty: Geographic Poverty Concentration Source: NARPAC http://www.narpac.org/RCA.HTM

  8. White Poverty Is Complex • White poverty makes up the majority of urban poverty • Rural stereotypes of White poverty are wrong • Difference in poverty rates is significant • White people often are assumed to be middle class based on their race • Differences in poverty concentration is significant • Effects of poverty are much more intense than for dispersed poverty

  9. Why is UrbanWhite Poverty Invisible? • Political Alliances • Racialized politics makes Black and Latino poverty a priority through power of Black and Latino middle/upper classes • Rural politics makes White rural poverty a priority through power of rural White middle/upper classes • Poor urban Whites have no political advocacy group with significant power to make White urban poverty a priority • We live in a Class-blind society • Myth of a classless society • Class discussion is significantly suppressed • White poverty only becomes visible once class becomes visible • Any significant recognition oppression of white people is an admission of classism, which is a significant threat to power structures especially in the USA

  10. Class and Level of Oppression Reality: some poor white individuals experience more oppression than individuals from other racial groups.

  11. White Poverty and Responsibility • Assumption: poor white individuals are entirely responsible for their own poverty • Reality • Class oppression can significantly affect life chances • Group trauma from classism can have significant generational effects even when oppression is removed

  12. The Invisibility of White Poverty and Assumptions on Poor White Anger • Assumption: white kids/people who are angry have no real reason to be so angry • Reality: • Class oppression and white poverty are invisible, so anger and pain has no identifiable source • The primary feeling of oppression from white poverty is anger and pain that has no identifiable source • Much of poor white music (heavy metal, punk, etc.) is expressions of deep anger and pain with no identifiable source • Anger of experiencing classism often gets displaced into racism because the actual source cannot be identified because it suppressed by society

  13. True or False: Part 2 • Poor White culture has no redeeming value or Godly strengths. • White people cannot experience systemic oppression. • Once class access changes, then oppression is over for White people. • The assumption that all White people are middle class benefits all White people. • White people’s ability to class assimilate benefits all White people. • It is better not to discuss class. • Race and class are the same thing in the USA.

  14. Assumptions about Poor White Culture • Assumption: Poor white culture has no redeeming value or Godly strengths • Reality: poor white culture has many Godly strengths that upper classes could benefit from • Poor white culture is an extremely ridiculed cultural group because it has no middle/upper class group to defend it • Poor white culture is significantly devalued, but academia rarely acknowledges this

  15. Classism and Group Oppression • Assumption: Class doesn’t count as a “group” in considering systemic or collective oppression • “White people can’t experience systemic oppression” • Racialized views often only perceive historical ethnic oppression but ignore class oppression • Since most historical oppression of ethnic groups has ended, then White people do not experience systemic collective oppression • Reality: class counts as a group and classism is systemic although more subtle • Poor whites have experienced class oppression throughout history but that is only told for some groups • What group oppression you experience is based on identity in race, class, gender and ethnicity

  16. Assumptions About Class Access • Assumption: If your class access changes, then the oppression is over • Reality 1: Majority of class oppression is determined by your class identification • Only economic oppression is determined by class access • Lose access to most power structures based on identification • Reality 2: Group trauma from classism has lasting effects to individuals and families generationally • Denying this can be like telling a Jewish holocaust survivor that now the effects of your oppression are over • Generational tendencies toward addiction • Reality 3: Class assimilation causes significant psychological damage similar to racial assimilation

  17. Effects of Class Assimilation on Poor White People • The “imperial middle” is the tendency of everyone to identify as middle-class • Poor white people who gain class access have overwhelming pressure to class assimilate and change their class identity • Other racial groups may have stronger solidarity with lower class people in their racial group and can use their power to defend lower class groups • Rural poor whites gain access to rural power • Result is that almost no one with power defends urban poor white people • Explains why urban white poverty is invisible

  18. Race-Based Assumptions onClass of Poor Whites • Assumption: All White people are middle or upper class • May have “positive” effects for those trying to upwardly class identify • Negative effects for those maintaining lower class identification • In urban ministry, this assumption significantly undermines credibility • Creates pressures to class assimilate

  19. White Poverty and Class Blindness • Class blindness is the inability to see or discuss class or classism • Not recognizing the class dimension of cultural/interpersonal conflict • Not recognizing class power structures at play in conflict • Making wrong assumptions about class or a person’s class identity • Class-blind examples • Avoiding talking about class or avoiding using terms like “poor” • “Race and Class are the same thing” • Poor whites most commonly feel the effects of the class blindness of others • Because people assume all whites are middle/upper class

More Related