1 / 18

Chapter Fifteen

Chapter Fifteen. Theories of Media and Society. Agenda Setting Theory. A broad-scope view of agenda setting considers three agendas: Media agenda Public agenda Policy agenda

Download Presentation

Chapter Fifteen

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Chapter Fifteen Theories of Media and Society

  2. Agenda Setting Theory • A broad-scope view of agenda setting considers three agendas: • Media agenda • Public agenda • Policy agenda • Agenda Setting Theory in the communication discipline has concentrated on the relationship between the media agenda and the public agenda

  3. Agenda Setting Theory:The Core Proposition • Agenda setting is the process in which the news media lead the public in assigning importance to various public issues • Agenda setting scholarship began with an investigation of the 1968 presidential campaign by Max McCombs and Donald Shaw

  4. Agenda Setting Theory:The First Study • The researchers first conducted a content analysis of newspaper and television coverage of the campaign • The researchers then interviewed undecided voters about what issues were important • These two agendas (media and public) were virtually identical

  5. Agenda Setting Theory:Establishing causality • The correlation found between the media agenda and the public agenda could be interpreted two ways • Does the media agenda cause the public agenda, or vice versa? • Further research suggests that the major causal direction is from media to public (though there is some “mutual” influence)

  6. Agenda Setting Theory:Theoretical Developments • Contingency factors • Audience need for orientation • Obtrusiveness of the issue • Effect of media on each other • Distinction between first and second-level agenda setting • Consideration of more complex dependent variables

  7. Spiral of Silence Theory • Spiral of Silence Theory (SOS) was developed by Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann as an “all-encompassing” theory of public opinion • SOS relates several levels of analysis: psychological processes, interpersonal communication, and mass media

  8. Spiral of Silence Theory:Major Components • SOS begins with the proposition that individuals are driven by a fear of isolation • Individuals also have an ability to assess the nature of public opinion through a quasi-statistical sense • When individuals believe public opinion is against them, they will thus be unwilling to speak

  9. Spiral of Silence Theory:The Spiral Process • As these three factors work together, public opinion will spiral down and reflect dominant perceptions • The spiral of silence will be mitigated by several factors: • The spiral only applies to moral issues • “Hard core” advocates will always speak • The educated and affluent will often speak

  10. Spiral of Silence Theory:Evidence and Extensions • Evidence for SOS has been relatively weak; thus extensions have been proposed • First, some suggest that the spiral of silence will work only with regard to valued reference groups • Second, some have looked at other factors that will predict an individual’s willingness to “speak out”

  11. Spiral of Silence Theory:Critiques • SOS has been critiqued for its weak empirical support • SOS has also been critiqued with regard to its ideological base • SOS was “foreshadowed” in Noelle-Neumann’s early academic and journalistic work • This foreshadowing suggests the conservative base of SOS

  12. Cultivation Theory • Cultivation Theory (CT) concentrates on one specific medium: Television • CT considers the ways in which television influences our socially constructed views of reality • CT developed by George Gerbner and his colleagues through longstanding research efforts

  13. Cultivation Theory:Assumptions • Assumptions about the Nature of Television • Television is pervasive • Television is accessible • Television is coherent • Assumptions about the Nature of Viewing • We do not watch particular shows or genres of shows, but we view by the clock

  14. Cultivation Theory:The Cultivation Effect Given these assumptions about television and viewing, the following effect is proposed: Cultivation describes the long-term and cumulative impact of television on our views of reality—the nature of the world and people within that world.

  15. Cultivation Theory:Methods for Testing • Content Analysis: The “television world” is assessed through content analysis • Cultural Indicators: Viewers’ perceptions of the world are assessed through survey • In comparing light viewers with heavy viewers, researchers find that heavy viewers’ perceptions of reality are most in line with the “television world” view

  16. Cultivation Theory:Critiques and Extensions • Major critique: The cultivation effect is generally found to be very small • Response to critique: First, any effect on views of reality is important. Second, several factors can be added to enhance predictive value of theory: • Mainstreaming • Resonance

  17. Cultivation Theory:Critiques and Extensions (cont.) • Cultivation Theory has also been criticized with regard to assumptions about television and viewing • These critiques are especially relevant in view of changing technology • Cable and satellite offerings might mitigate assumption of coherence • Videorecording technology might mitigate assumption of viewing by the clock

  18. Cultivation Theory:Critiques and Extensions (cont.) • Extension has been proposed to distinguish between first-order and second-order cultivation effects • First-order effect: Statistical descriptions of the world • Second-order effect: General nature of the world • Extension has been proposed to evaluate nature of cultivation relationship

More Related