1 / 15

Tom Clark, W3IWI DC AMSAT Group April 1 st , 2001

Clark's Scaling Laws: A.C.V.O.W.I.T.T. Build a Satellite in Your Basement a.k.a. AMSAT and SmallerCheaperFasterBetter. Tom Clark, W3IWI DC AMSAT Group April 1 st , 2001.

patty
Download Presentation

Tom Clark, W3IWI DC AMSAT Group April 1 st , 2001

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Clark's Scaling Laws: A.C.V.O.W.I.T.T. Build a Satellite in Your Basementa.k.a. AMSAT and SmallerCheaperFasterBetter Tom Clark, W3IWI DC AMSAT Group April 1st, 2001

  2. A.C.V.O.W.I.T.T. . . . . .ACurmudgeon’s View of what it takes to Build a Satellite in your Basementa.k.a. AMSAT and SmallerCheaperFasterBetter____________ • Curmudgeon: • “… crusty, ill-tempered, or difficult and often elderly person…” [Webster’s 3rd Int’l Dictionary] • “COF” • “geezer”

  3. My views are based on 25+ years of observing the “AMSAT Process”______________ • AO-8 • “ORBIT” Software • PSK Modem • AO-7 • P3A • AO-10 • AO-13 • SAREX Packet Hardware (Robot”) • The Microsats: -16, -17, -18, -19, -26, -30 • AO-40 • AMSAT’s BoD, ExVP & President

  4. Some Caveats and Disclaimers …( Truth in Advertising ) • My comments are based solely on my own ideas. They do not represent any official opinion of AMSAT-NA, its Officers or its Board of Directors. • Although I work for NASA, the concepts I will discuss are definitely not NASA policy. • Some of these ideas may disturb you and you may disbelieve. That’s Fine! • Please feel free to try to disprove some of my more pessimistic views. I’d be happy to be proven wrong.

  5. AMSAT is Two (Several?) Different Organizations • A membership organization composed of ~6000 users and supporters in USA and Canada (AMSAT-NA) • A group of a few hundred tekkies that build satellites • A similar similar distribution of like-minded folks elsewhere in the world (AMSAT-DL, AMSAT-UK etcetera) • Some folks who get their jollies from running organizations (“I gave up amateur radio to take up amateur bookkeeping!) I’m mainly a tekkie, so my comments are biased!

  6. How many times have you heard: Dear Mr. AMSAT: For your next satellite, you guys should ,,, - or - Hey AMSAT: You Guys are Idiots to use a French Rocket ... - or - Hey AMSAT: Here are some new laws of physics (or communi-cation link budgets, or …) you need to use ...

  7. AMSAT is US and not “You Guys” Dear Mr. AMSAT: For your next satellite, you guys should ,,, • Every AMSAT project (at least that I can remember) happened because of a few factors: • A few members decided that something needed to be done, • They made sure that the mission was practical and technically feasible, • They identified the critical resources that would be needed: • Launch • Community Support • Funding • Then they came to AMSAT (meaning the members, the Board and the Officers) for support.

  8. There’s No Such Thing as a Free Launch ! • Of all these factors, two have proven to be the most critical: • Technical Feasibility of the Concept • - and - • Availability of a suitable launch. • In the “early” days, NASA was a dependable source for LEO launches. • Recently, Arianne has had more available space, both to LEO and GTO. • More people (Commercial Users, Educators & Government) now want “niche” launches. • Launches have become a commercial commodity.

  9. A Big Surprise: • Only ~10% of the content of an Amateur Satellite is what people would call “Amateur Radio” ! • So what’s the other 90% ? • Mechanical, Thermal, Power, Computers, etc. • AstroGeoOrnithology (Political Birdwatching): • Launch vehicle interfaces (The cost of doing no harm) • Export permits (You mean my satellite is a munition?) • Fund Raising (OSIF: everything costs more than you planned) • Frequency Coordination (i.e. learning international politics) • Publicity (i.e. answering stupid questions kindly) • Soothing over bent egos(i.e. conflicts between prima donnas) • Worrying about all the things you probably forgot. • Etcetera (including imminent divorce) . . . . .

  10. Scaling Laws (1)Complexity: Experience has shown that Complexity (= C) increases as the number of subsystems N like C = [ N  a ] + [ N  (N-1)/2  b ] - or - C = [A  N] + [B  N2]

  11. Scaling Laws (2)Time: Experience has also shown that increasing the Complexity C increases the length of time T that it takes to do a project. T = K1 • C [ where my experience says  1 ]  T = K1•[A  N + B  N2]

  12. Scaling Laws (3)Cost: The cost of a project $ increases with both Complexity and Time: $ = K2 • C • T but we already saw that C = A  N + B  N2 and T = K1•[A  N + B  N2] with  &  both  1  $ = K1K2  [AN + BN2]•[A  N + B  N2]

  13. Scaling Laws (4)Cost -- The law of “Feature Creep” ( It’s VooDoo Math Time! ): $ = K1K2  [AN + BN2]•[A  N + B  N2] Assume for simplicity that ,  and  all  1  CO$Tscales as[AN + BN2]• [A  N + B  N2] with terms proportional to N, N2 , N3 and N 4 Or, in short, complexity, duration and cost all grow astronomically as more and more systems are added! Don’t try to fly the kitchen sink. The “optimum “N” may very well be  1

  14. AMSAT’s Secret of SmallerCheaperFasterBetter All these factors optimize for a small number N of systems. Prudence Dictates the KISS Principle -- KEEP IT SIMPLE, STUPID And (IMHO) NASA still doesn’t understand why their satellites cost so much ! They never have paid heed to AMSAT’s experiences!

  15. Some Other Topics Too Mentionable to be Numerous ( at least not today ): • AMSAT’s experience and philosophy on reliability • How do we encourage volunteers? • How do we keep it fun? • What should AMSAT do next? • Who are the next generation of leaders? • Where are the launches coming from? • AMSAT’s relations with the educational community (both K-12 and universities). • Whither Amateur Radio? • ... 73 de Tom Clark W3IWI

More Related