The Shrinking Dead Sea: Causes and Efforts at Restoration - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

The shrinking dead sea causes and efforts at restoration l.jpg
Download
1 / 18

The Shrinking Dead Sea: Causes and Efforts at Restoration Stephen McCaffrey Pacific/McGeorge School of Law Transboundary Freshwater Ecosystem Restoration: The Role of Law, Process and Lawyers The Dead Sea: A Piece of World Heritage Unique cultural, religious and political significance

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.

Download Presentation

The Shrinking Dead Sea: Causes and Efforts at Restoration

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


The shrinking dead sea causes and efforts at restoration l.jpg

The Shrinking Dead Sea:Causes and Efforts at Restoration

Stephen McCaffrey

Pacific/McGeorge School of Law

Transboundary Freshwater Ecosystem Restoration: The Role of Law, Process and Lawyers


The dead sea a piece of world heritage l.jpg

The Dead Sea: A Piece of World Heritage

  • Unique cultural, religious and political significance

  • Known to Aristotle

  • Lowest point on Earth

  • Actually a lake


Locating the dead sea the middle east l.jpg

Locating the Dead Sea: The Middle East


Locating the dead sea israel palestine jordan l.jpg

Locating the Dead Sea: Israel/Palestine/Jordan


Locating the dead sea the jordan river basin l.jpg

Locating the Dead Sea: The Jordan River Basin


Five jordan river riparians l.jpg

Five Jordan River Riparians

  • Lebanon

  • Israel

  • Syria

  • Jordan

  • Palestine


An arid region l.jpg

An Arid Region

  • All three lower riparians (Jordan, Palestine & Israel) are in a state of “absolute water scarcity”

    • Israel: 330 m3/year per capita

    • Jordan: 160 “

    • Palestine 70 “


Dead sea key characteristics l.jpg

Dead Sea: Key Characteristics

  • Lowest point on Earth – ca. 400 m/1340 feet below sea level

  • High salinity: ca. 10 times that of sea water (33% vs. 3% in Mediterranean)

  • As of 1996, ca. 50 mi. long and 11 mi. wide at widest point


Why is the dead sea shrinking l.jpg

Why Is the Dead Sea Shrinking?

  • Two reasons: evaporation and upstream diversions

  • Evaporation: ca. 2 billion m3/year (but nothing new)

  • Upstream diversions:

    • Lebanon: 10 mcm/yr

    • Jordan: ca. 320 mcm/yr

    • Syria: avg. of 260 mcm/yr

    • Israel: ca. 700 mcm/yr – out of the basin

    • Palestine: 0

  • Israel’s diversions into the Lower Jordan: saline and waste water


Efforts at restoration the red dead canal l.jpg

Efforts at Restoration:The “Red-Dead Canal”

  • History

    • Med -Dead Canal first proposed in 19th c

    • Israelis originally proposed Med-Dead and Jordanians the Red-Dead – originally to generate electricity

    • 1996 study by Harza Engineering of Chicago proposed production of freshwater via a Red-Dead Canal


A red dead conveyance current impetus l.jpg

A Red-Dead Conveyance: Current Impetus

  • Jordan and World Bank the main promoters; Israel also directly involved

  • 2002 Johannesburg Summit on Sustainable Development: Jordan and Israel state “shared vision” for a Red-Dead “Peace Conduit”

    • Saving the Dead Sea

    • Making affordable drinking water available

    • Building a symbol of peace and cooperation in the Middle East


Red dead canal features l.jpg

Red-Dead Canal: Features

  • Canal would carry saltwater from the Red Sea 180 km down the Wadi Araba into the Dead Sea

  • Would refill Dead Sea to level of 1930s over period of 10-20 years

  • When Dead Sea reaches its historic levels and inflow matches evaporation rate, flow of canal will be reduced

  • Construction would take 10 yrs and cost ca. $5 billion


Project design overview l.jpg

Project Design: Overview


Benefits of a red dead canal l.jpg

Benefits of a Red-Dead Canal

  • (Water supply project with environmental benefits or environmental project with water supply benefits?)

  • Environmental: Restoration of Dead Sea

  • Water supply: 850 mcm/yr to Amman (2/3) and Israel/Palestine (1/3)

  • Economic: tourism, potash & salt industries

  • “Peace dividend” (?)


Problems factual l.jpg

Problems: Factual

  • Cost of water: ca. $1.30 per cubic meter once pumped uphill to Amman and Jerusalem

  • Possible adverse environmental effects – e.g.:

    • Mixing of Red Sea and Dead Sea waters

    • Possible impacts of Red Sea coral reefs;

    • Possible impacts on wildlife migration in Wadi Araba


Problems legal l.jpg

Problems: Legal

  • No notification of upper riparians (Lebanon & Syria) as required by international practice

  • Dispute over Oct. 2003 TORs for Feasibility Study

    • Original Bank draft accepted by Jordan and Palestinians but not Israel, which insisted on eliminating all references to the PA as a “riparian”

  • Palestinian concern that acceptance of desalinated water will be used by Israel to avoid reallocating surface and ground water shared with Palestinians


Conclusions l.jpg

Conclusions

  • It looks as though the Dead Sea will be restored to its former level, given strong support especially by Jordan and also by World Bank

  • If project seems far-fetched, it just goes to show how important freshwater is in the region and the lengths international actors will go to in order to produce it

  • The jury is still out, and may be for some time to come, on the project’s

    • economic viability and

    • environmental effects


Thank you l.jpg

Thank You!


  • Login