Ass. Prof. Dr. Suzana Dzamtoska-Zdravkovska University Goce Delcev, Stip, Republic of Macedonia

1. 1st International Conference "South-East European Countries towards European Integration“, Economic Faculty of the University "Aleksander Xhuvani", Elbasan FREE ACCESS TO PUBLIC INFORMATION - MORE TRANSPARENCY, LESS CORRUPTION: THE CASE OF REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA Ass. Prof. Dr. Suzana Dzamtoska-Zdravkovska University Goce Delcev, Stip, Republic of Macedonia

2. Transparency is one of the highest qualities of democracy based on ethics and good governance where the interests and needs are focused on the citizens.

3. “Open government”, as the value of highly developed democratic societies, and extremely important standard in the functioning of the administration, means a high level of transparency. • This means that public administration is available for testing from outside and that everyone has a RIGHT TO KNOW the reasons which led to a particular decision or action of the administration, especially if the citizens are affected by decisions.

4. The traditional model of not transparent administration today disappears step by step. Citizens are increasingly becoming an equal entitywith state institutions which have responsibility to ensure protection of their rights, accountability, openness and transparency in its operations - as the basic principles upon which rests the principle of good governance.

5. Adoption of a law of free access to public information in many countries in the world which seek to enhance democracy in their societies today is a trend (process) that can not stop. • Nowadays, countries that don’t have such a law can not claim that they have full democracy. • One of the reasons for passing this law is reducing corruption – which is based on secrecy. Citizens and institutions become corrupted when the public has no insight into their work. • If the work of public institutions is transparent and offered for public inspection, then the chance for them to be corrupt is smaller.

6. Free access in the Republic of Macedonia • The legislative in the Republic of Macedonia emphasizes the principles of legality and transparency in the work of the public administration. According to the Law on Organization and Operation of the State Administrative Bodies, the governmental institutions are obliged to “inform the public about its work in accordance with the Constitution and the law“. • Republic of Macedonia has adopted the Law of Free Access to Public Information in 2006 • Application of the law began on 1 September of the same year

7. The Law on Free Access to Public Information emphasizes the obligation of the institutions to provide information with precise deadlines, ensuring transparency in the operation of the holders of information, allowing individuals and legal entities to exercise their right of free access to public information, and obliging the holders of information to provide information to the public. • Law on Free Access to Information of the Republic of Macedonia guarantees free access to all domestic and foreign legal entities or natural persons.

8. September 1, 2012 - exactly six years have passed since the beginning of the implementation of the Law in the Republic of Macedonia. • Latest Annual Report on the work of the Commission for Protection of the Right to Free Access to Public Information, from January 1 to December 31, 2011: The Commission notes that this new democratic right not only gets a stable position in the Republic of Macedonia, but speaking comparatively with countries of the wider region and some European countries, it is in an enviable position. According to research carried out by the relevant institute "Centre for Law and Democracy," Macedonia is in the high 14th place on the world ranking list of states that have the most functional Law on Free Access to Public Information, regardless that this democratic right was transformed into legislation in a relatively recent period.

9. The main problem for the application of the idea "I have the right to know" is the not so small degree of ignorance, apathy and lack of understanding, resulting in its slow acceptance, and the silence of the administration - as the basis for most complaints from citizens. • According to the records of the Commission in 2011, 70% of complaints (324 of a total of 409 complaints) were filed due to silence of the information holders • It is still necessary to take a series of activities for raising awareness of public bodies, getting them used to providing information and helping them realize that it is their duty to provide them.

10. “I HAVE A RIGHT TO KNOW”IN THE BATTLE AGAINST CORRUPTION • One of the main objectives of the Law on Free Access to Public Information isincreasing transparency of the public administration and reducing the corruption in a society which endangers economic development and prosperity of the country in every field. The example of the Republic of Macedonia is on the way of proving the claims that countries which have adopted the law on free access to information and have greater transparency, have less corruption.

11. According to the Transparency International Corruption Perception Index: • 2005 - Macedonia was on the 103rd place. • In 2009 and 2010, three/four years after the implementation of the Law, there has been a significant improvement of the situation: • 2009, the Republic of Macedonia has climbed onthe 71st place; • 2010 - 62nd place; • In 2011 the country shared the 69th place on the TICPI which surveyed 183 countries worldwide

12. The number of applications submitted by citizens can be taken as a kind of an indicator of the acceptance of the right to be informed, i.e. of the rising awareness of their right to seek information.The situation in the Republic of Macedonia in 2011 is much better than in 2006 when implementation of the Law began. • The record number of 3.496 requests submitted in 2011 indicates that applicants used the new democratic right to a much greater extent than ever before. Table 1: Comparative view since the initial application of the law (source: Annual Report on the work of the Commission for Protection of the Right to Free Access to Public Information, from January 1 to December 31, 2011)

13. But despite all these information, the following data indicates the need for greater affirmation of the law and raising awareness about the possibilities it offers and for the acceptance of the idea “I have a right to know“: • * According to the Report of the Commission, the highest percentage of applicants, i.e. complainers, are citizens' associations and foundations. In 2011, 70% of the requests come from non-governmental organizations and associations. • * Citizens participate as requestors in 30% of submitted cases. Furthermore, the total numbers of complaints, 98 were submitted by individuals, and the remaining 311 from citizens' associations and foundations.

14. The free access to information in order to prevent corruption could not survive on its own and develop in its implementation,unless all of the society’s stakeholders actively engage in its affirmation. * In affirming the right of citizens to request and access information, the media can and should play a significant role. However, before that they need to use the benefits provided by this law themselves. * So far, in the Republic of Macedonia the Law on Free Access to Information of Public Character is still not widely applied by journalists.

15. Conclusions: * The legal grounds for free access to information enables active participation of the citizens. * The level of participation depends on the competence of the resources, the dynamic of the civil society, the activities of non-government organization that ensure transparency, the level of professional investigative journalism, as well as the capacity of the citizens to use the benefits of the Law.

16. The legal basis for free access to public information in the Republic of Macedonia has been well placed. • The government has articulated its commitment for transparency and combat against corruption, all in order to achieve the EU criteria, among which the criteria for good governance and open government. • Although the corruption is still not on a satisfactory level, yet the Law has influenced its reduction.

17. * In order to ensure a more successful application of the Law in the following period it is necessary to concentrate on: • Educating citizens through the mass media regarding their "I have Right to Know"; • Educating the journalists to ensure greater participation from them in the application of the access to information, especially in the area of investigative journalism; • Establishing a system for exchange of information within the institutions in order to ensure that the officials for public information mediation receive the requested information in a timely manner, and provide itto the requestors.

18. All of this will strengthen the implementation of the Law, as one of the mechanisms that ensures removal of comfortable positions behind closed doors and with its constant presence is a powerful tool in the fight against corruption and misconduct of governments and public authorities.

19. Thank you for your attention!