This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 42

Retro-Commissioning June 21, 2010 Ed Tinsley, PE TME, Inc PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Retro-Commissioning June 21, 2010 Ed Tinsley, PE TME, Inc. Agenda. Today’s Problem Today’s Opportunity Retro-Commissioning Process Retro-Commissioning Case Studies Recommendations. Today’s Problem. A Legislator’s Quandary LEED is not Enough Performance Contracting is not the Answer

Download Presentation

Retro-Commissioning June 21, 2010 Ed Tinsley, PE TME, Inc

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript

Retro commissioning june 21 2010 ed tinsley pe tme inc


June 21, 2010

Ed Tinsley, PE

TME, Inc



  • Today’s Problem

  • Today’s Opportunity

  • Retro-Commissioning Process

  • Retro-Commissioning Case Studies

  • Recommendations

Today s problem

Today’s Problem

  • A Legislator’s Quandary

  • LEED is not Enough

  • Performance Contracting is not the Answer

  • Act 1494 and Executive Order 09-07 are a Good Start

A legislator s quandary

A Legislator’s Quandary

  • Moral Obligation as a Human Being to Conserve Natural Resources

  • Fiduciary Responsible as a Legislator to Conserve Taxpayer Funds

  • Is there a Conflict?

Leed is not enough

LEED is not Enough

  • 25% of LEED Certified Buildings do not Achieve their Predicted Energy Savings

  • In the Real World, LEED Certified Buildings are not more Energy Efficient than other Buildings

  • 53% of LEED Certified Buildings do not Qualify for the Energy Star Label

  • 15% of LEED Certified Buildings have Energy Star Ratings less than 30

“Some Buildings Not Living Up to Green Label”

August 31, 2009

Performance contracting is not the answer

Performance Contracting is not the Answer

  • Complex Legal Issues

  • 35 to 70% Cost Premium

  • “Fuzzy” Guarantees

    • Weather

    • Rates

    • Utilization

  • Not a Good Track Record

  • May be Better than Doing Nothing

At least this is better than my last job managing Performance Contracts

Act 1494 and executive order 09 07 are a good start

Act 1494 and Executive Order 09-07 are a Good Start

  • Act 1494

    • Mandates Energy Efficient Design, Energy Modeling, Commissioning, and M&V

    • 20% Reduction by 2014 and 30% Reduction by 2017

  • Executive Order 09-07

    • Strategic Energy Plans

    • Promotes Operational Changes to Reduce Environmental Impact

Today s opportunity

Today’s Opportunity

  • Natural Gas Rates

  • Electricity Rates

  • Projected 2010/2011 Surplus

  • Spending our Gift Wisely

Natural gas rates

Natural Gas Rates

Entergy rate increase docket 090 084 u

Entergy Rate Increase (Docket 090-084-U)

  • UA System Intervened

  • Other Participants (AEEC, FEA, Kroger, Hino, Audubon, Attorney General and Staff)

  • 12.86% Increase in Base Rates (Large Commercial Class)

  • Loss of CA Rider

  • Indemnification Language Issue Referred to ATU Complaint

  • Pilot Real Time Pricing (“RTP”) Program

  • Securitization of Storm Damage Costs Referred to Separate Docket

  • Formula Rate Plan Referred to Separate Docket

Electricity rates

Electricity Rates

Projected 2010 2011 utility budget surplus

Projected 2010/2011 Utility Budget Surplus

  • Electricity - $9.75 Million

  • Natural Gas - $4.50 Million

  • Total - $14.25 Million

Spending the gift wisely

Spending the Gift Wisely

  • Largely Due to Lower Natural Gas Costs

  • The Surplus is Short Term

  • Surplus can be Absorbed into General Funds or

  • Surplus can be Converted to Recurring Savings by Investing in Energy Conservation

Retro commissioning


Retro-commissioning (RCx) is a systematic, documented process that identifies and implements low-cost operational and maintenance improvements in existing buildings intended to improve energy efficiency, indoor air quality, and thermal comfort.

RCx focuses on the major energy consuming systems (HVAC and lighting) and optimizes existing system performance, rather than relying on major equipment replacement or other items requiring large capital expenditures.

Retro commissioning process

Retro-Commissioning Process

  • Obtaining Data

  • Benchmarking

  • Supply-Side Audit

  • Develop the Plan

  • Execute the Plan

  • Measure and Verify Results

Obtaining data

Obtaining Data

  • Utility Bills

  • Record Drawings

  • Site Inspections

  • Equipment Testing

  • Equipment Submittals

  • Control Diagrams

  • EMS Review

  • TAB Report

  • Maintenance Staff

  • Data Harvesting Tool

Utility bills

Utility Bills

  • Alternative Service Arrangements

    • Master Metering

    • Combined Billing

  • Alternative Rates

    • Time of Use

    • Real Time Pricing (RTP) Rates

    • Interruptible Rates

  • Alternative Riders

    • Transformation Credit

  • Demand Side Management Programs

    • Grants

    • Rebates

Review energy management system

Review Energy Management System

  • Graphic Displays

  • Trend Data

  • Alarm Log

  • Control Programs

  • Setpoints

  • Schedules

Maintenance staff

Maintenance Staff

  • Chronic Operating and Maintenance Problems

  • Actual Equipment Operation

  • Actual Setpoints

  • Desired Outcome/Goals

  • Potential Energy Cost Reduction Measures

  • The Maintenance Staff must be Stakeholders in the Process

Using a commissioning tool to harvest data and find opportunities

Using a Commissioning Tool to Harvest Data and Find Opportunities

  • Find all Air Terminals with Air Flow < 100 CFM and Damper Positions > 90%

  • Air Terminals with Defective Air Flow Measurement Devices

Benchmarking energy consumption and costs

Benchmarking Energy Consumption and Costs

  • IFMA Handbooks

  • ASHRAE Standard 90.1

  • Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED)

  • Performance Metrics

  • EPA Energy Star

  • ASHE E2C

  • ASHE Benchmarking Program

Supply side utility audit

Supply-Side Utility Audit

  • Locate all Utility Meters (electricity, gas, & water) on a Site Plan

  • Identify the Buildings Served by each Meter

  • Check for Billing Errors

  • Identify and Evaluate all Potential Metering Arrangements, Utility Rates, and Riders

  • Implement the Procurement Strategy (Metering Arrangements, Rates, and Riders) that Yields the Lowest Unit Cost

  • Update the Supply-Side Audit on an Annual Basis

Electricity rate analysis

Alternative Rates and Riders

Ratchet Clauses

Delivery Voltage

Meter Location

Power Factor Penalties

Combined Billing

Master Metering

Electricity Rate Analysis

Natural gas rate analysis

Unbundled or Transportation Service

Purchasing Groups

MDQ vs. Contract Demand

Physical Hedging Strategy

LDC, Pipeline, and Commodity Rate Structures

Index plus Basis plus Margin

Fuel and LUFG Cost Recovery

Nominations, Imbalance Penalties, and Cash-In/Out Requirements

Natural Gas Rate Analysis

Developing the retro cx plan

Developing the Retro-Cx Plan

  • Set a Primary Objective

  • Identifying Available Resources

  • Identifying and Evaluating Potential Energy Cost Reduction Measures

  • Prioritize and Select Potential Energy Cost Reduction Measures

  • Obtain Capital Funding

  • Set Intermediate Goals

Developing the retro commissioning plan continued

Developing the Retro-Commissioning Plan (continued)

  • Establish a Timetable

  • Implement Energy Cost Reduction Measures

  • Measure and Verify Progress

  • Mid-Course Corrections

  • Acknowledge and Celebrate Success

  • Update and Extend the Plan

Identifying and evaluating potential energy cost reduction measures

Identifying and Evaluating Potential Energy Cost Reduction Measures

  • Comprehensive Review of Entire Facility

  • Consider all Available Data

  • Consider New and Proven Technology

  • Computer Simulation Programs

  • Conceptual Designs

  • Conceptual Cost Estimates

  • ECRM Interdependencies

  • Simple Payback (cost to benefit ratio)

Ecrm summary

ECRM Summary

Obtain capital funding

Obtain Capital Funding

  • Promote Energy Conservation within Department and Organization

  • Capture Savings from Gas Hedging Activities and Electricity Rate Savings in Same Budget Year

  • Participate in Utility Energy Efficiency Programs

  • Participate in Revolving Loan Fund

  • Capture Savings from Prior Energy Conservation Projects and Reinvest in new Projects

Set intermediate goals

Set Intermediate Goals




Energy Star



Reinvesting energy savings

Reinvesting Energy Savings

Retro commissioning june 21 2010 ed tinsley pe tme inc

Executing the Retro-Commissioning Plan

  • Lighting

  • Air Terminals

  • Fan Coil Units

  • Chilled Water System

  • Heating Water System

  • Steam System

  • Operating Rooms

  • Cath Labs

  • AII Rooms

  • Exhaust Fans

  • Kitchen Hoods

  • DHW System

  • Air Handling Units

Air terminals

Occupied Air Flow Setpoints

Cooling Minimum and Maximum

Heating Minimum and Maximum

Unoccupied Air Flow Setpoints

Cooling Minimum and Maximum

Heating Minimum and Maximum

Temperature Setpoints

Occupied Minimum and Maximum (68 to 75 deg. F)

Unoccupied Cooling and Heating Setpoints

Occupancy Sensors and/or Weekly Schedule

Reheat Valve opens before Air Flow is Increased

Most Significant Energy Conservation Opportunity in a Healthcare Facility!

Air Terminals

Retro commissioning june 21 2010 ed tinsley pe tme inc

VAV Air Terminal with Minimal Reheat

Best Practice: Modulate HW Valve to a Discharge Setpoint and Reset the Setpoint from Minimum up to Maximum before Increasing Air Flow.

Measuring and verifying retro commissioning results

Measuring and Verifying Retro-Commissioning Results

Case study results

Case Study Results

Case study retro cx costs

Case Study Retro-Cx Costs

Case study pump balancing

Triple Duty Valves at Pump Discharge Nearly Closed

VFD’s Operating at Full Speed

Bulk of Motor Energy Wasted at Balancing Valve

Case Study Pump Balancing

Triple Duty Valve





  • Do not Stop with LEED

  • Performance Contracting should be a Last Resort

  • Develop an Act 1494 Compliance Handbook for State Agencies (stress LCC based decision making)

  • Spend Your Gift Wisely

  • Develop a State Facility Energy Consumption and Cost Reporting System

  • Benchmark all State Facilities



  • Open the Revolving Loan Fund to Higher Education

  • Increase Participation in Utility Energy Efficiency Programs

  • Implement Supply-Side Audits

  • Increase Participation in Utility Purchasing Group

  • Implement Lighting Audits and Lighting Retrofits

  • Implement Retro-Commissioning



  • Reinvest Energy Savings

  • Increase State Facility Participation in the Utility Rate Making Process

    • Entergy System Agreement

    • Real Time Pricing Program

    • Indemnification Clauses

    • Combined Billing and Master Metering

    • Cost of Service Based Cost Allocation and Rate Designs

  • Login