1 / 24

Murphy Lives On – or, Anything that can go wrong already has….. In the Public Service too!

Murphy Lives On – or, Anything that can go wrong already has….. In the Public Service too!. With some observations on complaint handling Paul Kenny The Pensions Ombudsman December 2007. When a complaint is made…. Does the Complaint handler…. Lend a sympathetic ear? Attack the complainant?

neron
Download Presentation

Murphy Lives On – or, Anything that can go wrong already has….. In the Public Service too!

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Murphy Lives On – or, Anything that can go wrong already has….. In the Public Service too! Withsome observations on complaint handling Paul KennyThe Pensions Ombudsman December 2007

  2. When a complaint is made…. • Does the Complaint handler…. • Lend a sympathetic ear? • Attack the complainant? • Reach for their Lawyer? • Look up their Insurance Policy? • Actually look for the facts? • Agree that he has a case? • Apologise? • Refer the complainant to IDR?

  3. No Standard Response to complaints • Responses vary according to the “complainee” – some organisations more open to complaints than others • Culture in some cases is “save money at all costs” – even though there may be injustice

  4. And the Complainant • Some people are their own worst enemies • The nit-picker • When he cries “wolf”, nobody listens any more • The Chip on the Shoulder • Not again! • The Worrier • But it might happen…. …to name but a few

  5. Pitfalls • Don’t be tempted to batten down the hatches and hope he’ll go away – he won’t • Don’t treat complainants as dangerous lunatics • Do acknowledge the complaint and treat it seriously • Do try to deal with it as quickly as possible

  6. Remember • Most people who complain really do feel aggrieved • Many feel they have a strong case • They may not be correct but should be handled with respect • Even habitual complainers • A lot of people genuinely don’t know • Real “chancers” are rare enough • But they do exist

  7. An apology? • Remember that sometimes an apology is enough (“it’s the principle…”) • Complainants need to feel they are being listened to • Failure of the scheme /administrator /trustee to reply will escalate the problem • People who feel they are not taken seriously feel aggrieved • And complain to me

  8. One Little Word • A missing word – a missing clause • “… because….” • Many complaints could be avoided by giving an adequate – or a clear – explanation of the reasons for trustees’ or employers’ actions, or the factors that influence a decision

  9. More confusion and more complaints result from poor communication than from almost any other single factor. When a complaint arises, keep the lines of communication open

  10. Compliance with Disclosure Requirements • Most schemes are generally compliant, though there are always some problems • The requirements are straightforward (if potentially expensive) • Meeting them can be a problem! • Because of the weight of regulation, temptation is to tick boxes without regard for clarity of the message • Public Service short-cut to disclosure

  11. Perils of Communication • “You should keep this booklet in a safe place for future reference……” • That’s all they ever do • The Golden Rule of Pension Communication: Nobody Ever reads thesmallprint

  12. Public Service Schemes • Generally suffer from poor communication • May be worse as you get further from the centre • Circulars often incomprehensible – but very accurate! • Incomplete information, e.g., contributions to be repaid

  13. Problems I shouldn’t have…. • Some “complaints” can be disposed of quickly • I should not have to write to a complainant explaining the true meaning of a “communication” from scheme trustees • But it is the quickest way of closing the matter down

  14. A Revolutionary Proposal • Any chance of using Plain English?

  15. Internal Disputes Resolution in the Public Service • Most Public Service schemes are “Public Authority” schemes –but not all • Appeal to Minister • Possible appeal to Minister for Finance • Time limits are a joke • Three months will run from when sufficient information received

  16. IDR, continued • PO does not have power to waive the IDR requirement in a Public Authority Scheme • BUT can deem the process to be exhausted within its terms • I would prefer not to… but…

  17. Public Sector Pensions Administration • Unevenness • What you get should not depend on what Health Board region you worked in…. • Or the whim of some official • Lack of experience in pensions matters • Knowledge dispersed • Career structure • Pensions are not sexy! • Where there is tight control and specialist staff, far fewer problems • Shared Services…..

  18. Some complaints are unique to the Public Service • Added Years – delays in advising costs; disputes over calculation of added years; requirement for 9 years’ service • LGSS: Firefighters and Retirement Age: pay increase, supplementary pension • LGSS: Overtime – no consistency

  19. Public Service problems 2 • Some Equal treatment cases fail for lack of valid comparator • Pension Levy – opters-out – and non-pensionable gratuity • “Transfers” that are not transfers, and the Spouses’ and Children’s scheme • Sessional Employees and the Health Service

  20. Public Service problems 3 • Allowances often the subject of dispute • Service with grant-aided bodies • Co-ordination with State Pensions • Old Widows’ and Orphans’ schemes • LGSS 1956 Act Scheme – preservation • Attempts to fetter discretionary powers

  21. Public Service problems 4 • Divorce and Separation – Pension Adjustment Orders • In Public Service, 6 orders may be needed • Death Before commencement of Benefit – an insane situation

  22. Not all complaints are serious- to start with • Some should never get to my office, but escalate due to • Poor communication – both ways • Lack of knowledge of trustee duties • Failure to take complaint seriously • And some were never serious in the first place • Failure to switch investment in less than 5 days • Thursday to Monday!! • The Great PO Robber

  23. QUESTIONS?

  24. The Pensions Ombudsman • 36 Upper Mount StDublin 2 • Phone: 01 647 1650 • Fax: 01 676 9577 • info@pensionsombudsman.ie • www.pensionsombudsman.ie

More Related