1 / 24

Working with Qualitative Data: Exploring Educational Research and Analysis Methods

Join this session to discuss educational research assumptions, contrasting it with scientific research, and learning about qualitative analysis terms. Explore the use of ATLAS.ti software for qualitative analysis and understand the inherent tensions in qualitative data. Discover how to ensure validity and reliability in your research through triangulation and participant input.

mdenise
Download Presentation

Working with Qualitative Data: Exploring Educational Research and Analysis Methods

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Working with Qualitative DataChristine Maidl PribbenowWisconsin Center for Education Researchcmpribbenow@wisc.edu

  2. Session Outline • General discussion about educational research, assumptions and misconceptions • Contrast educational research with research in the sciences • Define common qualitative analysis terms • Provide example using ATLAS.ti– qualitative analysis software program • Code some text

  3. Free Association…

  4. DATA

  5. QUALITATIVE

  6. Qualitative Data: Oxymoron or inherent tensions? • Hard vs. soft (mushy) • Rigor • Validity and reliability • Objective vs. subjective • Numbers vs. text • What is The Truth?

  7. What are some of the assumptions that you have about educational research?How are they helping or hindering the development of your study?

  8. “Soft” knowledge Findings based in specific contexts Difficult to replicate Cannot make causal claims due to willful human action Short-term effort of intellectual accumulation– “village huts” Oriented toward practical application in specific contexts “Hard” knowledge Produce findings that are replicable Validated and accepted as definitive (i.e., what we know) Knowledge builds upon itself– “skyscrapers of knowledge” Oriented toward the construction and refinement of theory Research in the sciences vs. research in education

  9. What are some sources of qualitative data? • Lab notebooks • Open-ended exam questions • Papers • Journal entries • On-line discussions • Email • Notes from observations

  10. Qualitative Data Analysis Qualitative analysis is the “interplay between researchers and data.” Researcher and analysis are “inextricably linked.”

  11. Qualitative Data Analysis • Inductive process • Grounded Theory • Unsure of what you’re looking for, what you’ll find • No assumptions • No literature review at the beginning • Constant comparative method • Deductive process • Theory driven • Know the categories or themes using rubric, taxonomy • Looking for confirming and disconfirming evidence • Question and analysis informed by the literature

  12. Example Research Questions Why do faculty leave UW-Madison? Do UW-Madison faculty leave due to climate issues?

  13. Definitions: Coding and Themes • Coding process: • Conceptualizing, reducing, elaborating and relating text– words, phrases, sentences, paragraphs. • Building themes: • Codes are categorized thematically to describe or explain phenomenon.

  14. Let’s Code #1 Read through the reflection paper written by the student from an Ecology class and highlight words, parts of sentences, and/or whole sentences with some “code” attached and identified to those sections.

  15. What did you highlight? Why?

  16. Let’s Code #2 Read through this reflection paper and code based on this question: What were the student’s assumptions or misconceptions before taking this course?

  17. What did you highlight? Why?

  18. Let’s Code #3 Read through this reflection paper and code based on this question: What did the student learn in the course?

  19. What did you highlight? Why?

  20. Can we say that the students learned something in the course using reflection papers? Why or why not?

  21. Ensuring “validity” and “reliability” in your research • Use mixed methods, multiple sources. • Triangulate your data whenever possible. • Ask others to review your design methodology, observations, data, analysis, and interpretations (e.g., inter-rater reliability). • Rely on your study participants to “member check” your findings. • Note limitations of your study whenever possible.

  22. Does the redesign of an ecology course to include concept maps derived from current journal articles help students to gain a more current and realistic view of ecological issues?

  23. Questions?

  24. The plural of anecdote is data. -Donna Shalala

More Related