1 / 24

Intentional Torts

Intentional Torts. When someone intentionally injures someone or interferes with a person’s use of property Differs from unintentional torts on the basis of intent

matty
Download Presentation

Intentional Torts

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Intentional Torts • When someone intentionally injures someone or interferes with a person’s use of property • Differs from unintentional torts on the basis of intent • Demonstrated by the persons actions – desire to bring about a specific result or consequence or be substantially certain that those actions will have that result or consequence • Actions do not have to result in injuries or interference to the originally intended subject • E.g. striking another person while trying to strike someone else

  2. Intentional Torts & Criminal Acts • Criminal act can result in criminal as well as civil legal action • Criminal law = protection of society/justice • Civil law = compensation to the victim(s) • Burden of Proof • Criminal = beyond reasonable doubt • Civil = balance of probabilities

  3. Torts and Crimes • Crime • Assault • Forcible confinement • Break and enter • Theft • homicide • Tort • Battery • False imprisonment • Trespass to land • Conversion, or trespass to goods • Wrongful death

  4. Intentional Interference with the Person • Examples: • Assault, battery, medical battery, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, intentional infliction of mental suffering • Assault • Different from criminal assault • No physical harm necessary • Proof that the plaintiff believed there to be a threat of imminent harm and the ability of the defendant to carry out that harm

  5. Intentional Interference with the Person • Battery • Physical contact without consent • Beyond normal “bumping” in a crowd • Physical contact does not need to harm, only needs to offend • Often tried in combination with assault charges • Sexual Assault • Compensation of victims • Public condemnation of the assailants/perpetrators

  6. Intentional Interference with the Person • Medical Battery • Doctor must obtain a patient’s informed consent before carrying out a medical procedure • Procedure different than that agreed to • Consent obtained via fraud or misrepresentation • Procedure carried out against patient’s wishes (DNR, religious convictions)

  7. Intentional Interference with the Person • False (wrongful) imprisonment • Confinement without legal justification • Location is not specific to jail/prison • Consent obtained under duress does not constitute consent • I.e. consenting to a store detective to go to a back office to avoid embarrassment or situations where you don’t believe you can refuse

  8. Intentional Interference with the Person • Malicious prosecution • Wrongful prosecution without a reasonable and probable cause • Someone must be charged with a crime when there are no reasonable grounds for a charge • The individual or continuing the proceedings must be motivated by malice (desire to harm another) • Proceedings must be resolved in the defendant’s favour • Defendant must suffer damage as a result of the proceedings

  9. Intentional Interference with the Person • Nervous Shock and Mental Suffering • Deliberate shock or acting in a way so as to cause a person mental anguish resulting in emotional stress and illness • Defendant’s actions must be extreme and intentional • Victim must be able to prove mental suffering or physical harm as a result of the defendant’s actions

  10. Intentional Interference with the Person • Invasion of Privacy • Evolving area of law • Some jurisdictions don’t yet recognize this as a tort • May have enacted “protection of personal information acts”

  11. Intentional Interference with Property • Trespass to Land • Intentionally entering property without permission • Person does not need to be aware that the property/land is private • Damage to the property is not required • Invited persons who refuse to leave voluntarily (may be removed by reasonable force) • Certain occupations/duties are permitted by law to enter your property (assessment, meter reading)

  12. Intentional Interference with Property • Nuisance • Prevention of the use/enjoyment of your property = Private nuisance • Noxious fumes, barking dogs, loud noises • Unreasonable and you must have suffered damage of some sort • Varies based on neighbourhood/area • Prevention with the public interest in areas of safety, health, comfort, convenience, or morality • Oil spill, pollution of drinking water

  13. Intentional Interference with Property • Trespass to Chattels • Movable property • Jewelry, bicycles, furniture, CDs • Intentional interference with a person’s chattels • Damage to the chattel need not have occurred

  14. Intentional Interference with Property • Conversion • Civil law equivalent of theft • Convert your property for the defendant’s use, even if temporary Defences to Intentional Interference • Plaintiff must prove the defendant intentionally committed the tort that caused suffering

  15. Defences to Interference with the Person • Consent • Must be voluntary and specific • Proof of consent is on the defendant • Self-Defence • Use of reasonable force to protect oneself against injury • Defendant must prove immediate danger and that the force was necessary to prevent harm

  16. Defences to Interference with the Person • Defence to a Third Party • Use of reasonable force to prevent harm to a third person • Same rules apply – threat/danger must be immediate and force must be reasonable • Legal Authority • Right to perform a certain actions based on legal authority

  17. Defences to Interference with Property • Consent • Permission to be on the property • Does not permit you to intentionally damage the property or abuse the permission • Defence of Property • Reasonable force to protect property or remove/eject trespassers

  18. Defences to Interference with Property • Legal Authority • Police, public officials • Statutory Authority • Main defence against nuisance liability • Statute authorizes the activity resulting in the nuisance • E.g. loud noises as the result of construction

  19. Defamation of Character • Unfounded accusations or statements causing injury to a person’s fame, reputation or character

  20. Defamation of Character • Slander • Oral statement or gesture that damages a person’s reputation • Statements must have been made by someone other than the plaintiff and must have referred to the plaintiff • Statements must have lowered the plaintiff’s reputation in the eye’s of reasonable person

  21. Defamation of Character • Libel • Defamation in a permanent form • Written, recorded, printed, filmed • Cartoons, drawings, carvings • Libel is considered more serious than slander since the publication is more widespread • Court presumes your reputation has been harmed provided the libel is proven (special or actual damages need not be proven) • Damage does not need to be intentional

  22. Defences to Defamation • Truth • Strongest defence to defamation suits • Fair Comment • Comments were honest and made without malice • Opinion statements

  23. Defences to Defamation • Absolute Privilege • Performance of official duties • Politicians in Parliament/Legislative Assembly • Statements must be made during court or legislative proceedings • Even malicious statements are protected

  24. Defences to Defamation • Qualified Privilege • Statements made in certain situations are protected as long as the statements are made without malice • Applies in situations where someone has a duty to make the statement, or an interest to protect, and the person receiving the statement has an interest in receiving it • E.g. letters of reference

More Related