AHSGS Colloquium for Graduate Student 2015

1. AHSGS Colloquium for Graduate Student 2015 EPISTEMOLOGY Prof Dr Haji Abdullah Haji Abdul Ghani IBS COB Seminar Hall School of Computing Building 25 January 2015

2. What is a PhD/DBA? A phd/DBA is not merely a vague title but actually means what it implies: it is an award to an expert who has proven their scientific worth and not to someone who stayed in a tolerant group for long enough

3. What is research ? • Re-search: The art of dis-covery • Organized Study: Methodical Investigation Into A Subject In Order To Discover Facts, To Establish Or Revise A Theory, Or To Develop A Plan Of Action Based On The Facts Discovered

4. Philosophy • Philosophy derives from A combination of the greek words philos meaning love and sophia meaning wisdom. What philosophy is, or should be, is itself A philosophical question that philosophers have understood and treated differently through the ages. • Philosophy can mean the academic exploration of various questions raised by philosophers; or to the collective works of major philosophers; it can also mean a certain critical, creative way of thinking.

5. Epistemology • Theories of knowledge or studies of knowledge • Branch of philosophy that asks whether we know things and, if so, how • The study of source, nature, varieties and limitations of knowledge • It attempts to answer the basic question • True (adequate) vs false (inadequate) knowledge • The above Q lead to sc.Fic methodology: to improve existing theories or models

6. Some typical problems classical epistemology addresses • What can we know • How do we know • What, if anything, does the subject contribute to his knowledge • What is truth • How can we recognize truth • What is probable knowledge as opposed to certain knowledge • Is there a priori knowledge, and if so what • How action and language are related to knowledge • What is the status of concepts and propositions

7. Knowledge • The act or state of knowing; clear perception of fact, truth, or duty; certain apprehension; familiar cognizance; cognition. • That which is or may be known; the object of an act of knowing; a cognition; -- chiefly used in the plural. • That which is gained and preserved by knowing; instruction; acquaintance; enlightenment; learning; scholarship; erudition. • That familiarity which is gained by actual experience; practical skill; as, a knowledge of life.

9. KNOWLEDGE TRADITION • The history of knowledge and science not begins from West but from East. • The most important area are Egypt and Mesopotamia (Babylon) which located at Nil Valley and Tigris-Euphrates River Valley • These area are so special because of the knowledge heritage and development of science and technology

10. Estern Tradition • Egypt & Mesapotamia • Archeology, mathematic, geometry, medicine, architecture • India • mathematic, medicine, astronomy • China • natural science

11. WHAT ARE THE SIGNIFICANCE OF KNOWLEDGE CIVILIZATION IN EGYPT AND BABYLON? • Knowledge tradition or civilization begins from East not West • Holistic knowledge activities was parallel with religious activities. In other word, knowledge scholar at the same time also religious scholar. • The founder of knowledge in Egypt and Babylon were the prophet and messenger of God. • In Islamic tradition, Adam not only the first man, but also pioneer of all knowledge. He taught his children with technical knowledge, especially Syith. • Syith was the teacher of Idris, who born in Babylon. He was the founder of geometry, astronomy, medicine, and continued by Daniel.

12. Integrated Knowledge Civilization • The development of knowledge that started from East had flow to West. But the development was just for a few decades, before conquered back by East. • Along the middle age (10 centuries), Islamic world was in the knowledge brightness, but in the West was in the Dark Ages. • Islamic knowledge civilization are IlmuNaqliah or Syar’iyyah (revealed science) and IlmuAqliyah (rational science). • IlmuNaqliah : Ulum Quran, Ulum Hadith, IlmuTauhid, IlmuFiqh and IlmuAkhlak, the history of prophet, and Arabic Language. • IlmuAqliyah: philosophy, history, geography, science, mathematic, and astronomy. • Famous scholars: al-Khindi, al-Farabi, Ibn Sina, Ibn Tufail Ibn Rusyd, al Khawarizmi, al Ghazali.

13. Reality Of Knowledge (continued) • At least 3 well established paradigms in the development of science: • Classical paradigm: knowledge-curiosity-driven. • 2nd paradigm: Technology-military-power-driven. • 3rd paradigm: Market-wealth-driven paradigm. (Shaharir Mohd Zin, 1998, Towards A Quantum Leap in the Development Of Islamic Science in Malaysia)

14. Philosophy of knowledge • Ontology-root and division • Epistemology-method of getting knowledge • Inductive, deductive, falsification & hypothetical-deductive method. • Axiology • value & responsibility

15. Ontology Definitions • Concerned with the study of being, of reality in its most fundamental and comprehensive forms. • The theory of objects and their ties. • The unfolding of ontology provides criteria for distinguishing various types of objects (concrete and abstract, existent and non-existent, real and ideal, independent and dependent) and their ties (relations, dependences and predication). Ref: www.atf.org.au/papers/glossary.asp Ref: www.formalontology.it/

16. Types of Ontology • There are four different types of ontology: • Domain ontologies, representing a target domain, as engineering, medicine etc. • Generic or common sense ontologies, capturing general knowledge about time. Space, events, etc. • Method ontologies, describing specific task, as diagnosis. • Metadata ontologies, describing the content of on-line information sources.

17. EpistemologyTHEORY & SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE • In epistemology a common definition of knowledge is that it consist of justified true belief. For most philosophical history, knowledge was taken to mean a belief that was justified as true to an absolute certainty. Any less justified beliefs were called mere “probable opinion”. To be a knowledge, a belief has to have some positive epistemic feature; it can’t be arbitrary or random or irrational. (Source:http://en.Wikipedia.Org/wiki/knowledge)

19. Rationalism • The human reason, or understanding, is the sole source and final test of all truth. • Renes Descartes (1596-1650) using mathematical and geometrical analytical method.

20. Empiricism • Is the philosophical doctrine that all human knowledge comes at first from sense and experience. Empiricism denies that human have innate ideas that anything is knowable prior to any experience.

21. Classical Empiricism : Aristotle argued that all form of knowing come from induction. Modern Empiricism :All knowledge must be attained by our consciousness through internal and external sensations. (David Hume, John Locke and George Berkeley) Radical Empiricism : All human knowledge is purely empirical. (William James) Naïve Empiricism : Our ideas and theories need to be tested against reality and not be affected by preconceived notions. Constructive Empiricism : According to this view of science coined by Bas Van Fraassen (The Scientific Image, 1980), we should only ask that theories accurately describe observable parts of the world. Theories that meet these requirements are considered “empirically adequate”. If a theory become established, it should be accepted. What that means is the theory is believed to be empirically accurate, use to solve further problem, and use to extend or refine the theory. Empiricism

22. Conformism • Term used to describe a state of orthodoxy, the suspension of actions or opinions in favor of obedience to the mandate or conventions of one’s peer group. The old saying expresses this well : when in rome, do as the roman do. By definition, conformism present the antithesis both of creativity and of innovative leadership and hence oppose change or progress.

23. Intuitism • Immediate apprehension by mind without reasoning. The belief that primary truths and principles especially of ethics and metaphysics are known directly by intuition. • The knowing of something without prior knowledge or the use of reason. All stands revealed the hearts, the motives, the causes all events. Able to sense the invisible and the impalatable. Prophets are often intuitive. Acquire through spiritual intelligence (SQ)

24. Revelation • The kind of knowledge that is given by god to man through direct revelation. Unveils the mystery of being and existence and reveals the true relationship between man’s self and his lord, and since for man such knowledge pertains to the ultimate purpose of knowing, it follows that knowledge of its prerequisites become the basis and essential foundation for the knowledge of the second kind (knowledge of science). (Source : SYED MUHAMMAD NAQUIB AL-ATTAS)

25. Overview of Logical Knowledge Conditional Proposition (Al-syartiah) (Al-Qadiayah) Unconditional Comparison/ Deduction (Al-hamliah) Validation (Al-Qias/ syllogism) (Tasdiq) Argumentation Complete Induction (Muhajjah) Conclusion/ Induction Logical Knowledge (Al-Istiqra’ al-Tamm) Precise Definition (Al-Istiqra’) Limited Induction Conceptual (Ta’rif bil hadd) (Tasawur) (Al-Istiqra’ al-Naqis) Connotative Definition (Al-Istiqra’ Riyadi) Natural/Physical science Chemistry, physic, biology (Ta’rif bil Rasm) (Al-Istiqra’ ilmii) mathematic TYPES OF METHODOLOGY Logical Thinking -- The Source of Methodology

26. TYPES OF METHODOLOGY Overview of Methodology • Types of Methodology • Deductive • Inductive • Hypothetical Deductive • Rabbani General Understanding/ Conclusion Observations Observed phenomenon Conclusion/ Understanding from specific observation Conclusion/ Understanding Based on general rules/ understanding

27. DEDUCTIVE METHODOLOGY – WHAT IS IT? • Definition: • Make an inference to explain specific observed phenomenon based • on existing general understanding, rules or knowledge • Originated from the Latin words “de” ( From) and • “decere” (Lead towards) • Syllogism (Al-qias) – Introduced by Aristotle (384~322BC) • Classic logical Knowledge General Understanding/ Conclusion Observed phenomenon Conclusion/ Understanding Based on general rules/ understanding

28. DEDUCTIVE METHODOLOGY – PROCESS • Move from General understanding (postulate & Axiom) as • Premise  Specifics phenomenon • Postulate – Something that believe to be true but not proven • (without empirical study or observation) • Axiom – Formal rule or principle that generally to be true, • dominated in Mathematics • Minor Premise + Major Premise  Conclusion • Example: (Muqaddimah al-Sughra) (Muqaddimah al Kubra) (Natijah) All vegetables is nutritious Nutrition is good for health All Vegetables is good for health (Muqaddimah al-Sughra + (Muqaddimah al Kubra) (Natijah) =

29. General Understanding/ Conclusion Observations Conclusion/ Understanding from specific observation INDUCTIVE METHODOLOGY - DEFINITION • Definition: • Generalizing a knowledge, understanding, conclusion from the • understanding of specifics observation to a general rules or • knowledge with the elements of probability • Modern Logical Knowledge based on empirical study • Types of Induction: Completed(Al-Istiqra’ Tamn)& Limited(al-Istiqra’ Naqis)

30. Falsifiability as a criterion for theories • Theories shown to be false through observation and experiment. Example: proton cars never breakdown or ice will not melt if room temperature is 0 celcius • To be part of science, any hypothesis must be falsifiable; logically possible observation of any hypothesis • Thus statements which is vaguely form and is not falsifiable is not scientific. Example: proton savvy may be better than myvi but it may not be as good.

31. Degree of falsifiability, clarity and precision • Any theories which can be proven in terms of falsifiability is a good scientific law. Example, newton’s theory proven to be more resistant to falsifying than Kepler’s Theory. • Science progresses by trial and error; theories which were not falsified yet meant they are the currently most accurate ones and not guaranteed to be true forever. • Thus, any theories should be clearly stated and not vague.

32. Falsificationism and progress • Science starts from problems. Hypotheses are formed as solution to problems. • Falsificationist seeks ways to continue rigorous tests to falsify a certain theory after which a stronger theory emerges. • Aristotle’s theory being taken over by newton’s theory. Newton’s theory was able to account for more issues which Aristotle’s theories did not mention. This was followed by Einstein’s Theory which proved to be a challenge to falsify for current modern physicists. • There is no truth, only the current most correct answer.

33. Limitations of falsificationism • Theory-dependence of observation and the fallibility of falsifications • Theory acceptance is always tentative (for now) • Theory rejection is decisive (forever) • Note that observation might be wrong! • Thus many instances whereby rejections of observation statements and the retention of the theories they clash

34. Falsificationism inadequate on historial grounds • Theories may have been rejected due to historical grounds. Example: newton’s gravitational theory was falsified by observation of the moon’s orbit. Only after 50 years that this is deflected to other causes than newton’s theory.

35. Hypothetico-deductive • Philosopher Karl Popper suggested that it is impossible to prove a scientific theory true by means of induction, because no amount of evidence assures us that contrary evidence will not be found. • Instead, Karl Popper proposed that proper science is accomplished by deduction. Deduction involves the process of falsification. • Falsification is a particular specialized aspect of hypothesis testing. It involves stating some output from theory in specific and then finding contrary cases using experiments or observations. • The methodology proposed by Popper is commonly known as the hypothetico -deductive method. • Popper's version of scientific method first begins with the postulation of a hypothesis. • A hypothesis is an educated guess or a theory that explains some phenomenon. The researcher then tries to prove or test this scientific theory false through prediction or experimentation

36. SCOPE OF KNOWLEDGE RATIONAL EMPIRICAL GOD KNOWLEDGE INTUITION REVELATION RABBANI METHOD

37. Axiology- The valueof TRUTH • In everyday life, people distinguish between truth and falsehood as a matter of survival. People who are unable to recognize lies, mistakes or inaccuracies, at least most of the time, suffer greatly. • The philosophical problem of truth has been described as the search for the nature of truth. It applied to a statement or belief.

38. Theories About Truth • Correspondence theory of truth : truth is correspondence with objective reality. Thus, a sentence is said to be true just in case it express a state of affair in the world. Eg. “Snow is white is true”. • The coherence theory : truth is coherence with some specified set of sentences or, more often, of beliefs. For example, one of a person’s belief is true just in case it is coherent with all or most of her other beliefs. • Pragmatic theory of truth : based on the foundation of the principle of evolutionism. An idea can only be considered true if posses practical value or vital benefits. Pragmatism believed “absolute truth do not exist” (Charles Sanders Pierce, William James). Nature of truth statement by working hypothesis, focus on similarities and differences.

39. Type Of Truth • Subjective vs Objective • Subjective truthAre those with which we are most intimately acquainted. Metaphysical subjectivism holds that all we have are such truths. That is, that all we can know about are one way or another, our own subjective experiences. This view does not reject realism. But at least it claim that we cannot have direct knowledge of the real world. • Objective truthAre suppose to be one way to be independent of our subjective beliefs and tastes. Such truth would subsist not in the mind but in the external object.

40. Relative vs Absolute • Relative truths are statements or propositions that are true only relative to some standard or convention or point-of-view. Everyone agrees that the truth or falsify of some statements is relative: the fork is to the left of the spoon depends on where one stands. Relativism entails that what is true varies across cultures and eras. • Absolute truths are statement or propositions that are taken to be true for all cultures and eras. Example: for muslim, Allah is great expression an absolute truth; for economist, that the law of supply and demand determine the value of any consumable in the market economy is true in all situations. • Absolutism in particular domain of thought is the view that all statements in that domain are either absolute true or absolute false: none is true for some cultures or eras while false for other cultures or eras. Example “abortion is wrong” or “charity is good”.

41. The Concept Of Doubt From Islam Viewpoint • The doubt (shakk), conjecture and guess disputation and contention, inclination of mind or soul towards natural desire (hawa), are all generally considered blameworthy-the more so when applied to an masquerading as knowledge. We must take note of the significance that, in the case of western culture and civilisation, and with reference to sociology of knowledge, the west defined knowledge in terms of the effort of science as control of nature and society. (Syed Naquib Al-Attas) • There are situations and issues which do not require thinking. One does not need to conduct lengthy experiment and engage in extensive study to prove something that is plainly obvious from every day experience. • According to Al-Ghazali, doubt is the first stage of certainty (yaqin). His concept of doubt is not based on scepticism but more on methodological. When the doubt is clear, certainty will emerge.