1 / 20

Concussions in sports

Concussions in sports. Mary Tovornik, MA, ATC Assoc. Athletic Trainer, Head Football Athletic Trainer Stony Brook University May 11, 2012. Introduction. Overall: Give a REAL picture of the current situation of head injury management in sports 1. Recent changes/updates in protocols

mala
Download Presentation

Concussions in sports

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Concussionsin sports Mary Tovornik, MA, ATC Assoc. Athletic Trainer, Head Football Athletic Trainer Stony Brook University May 11, 2012

  2. Introduction • Overall: Give a REAL picture of the current situation of head injury management in sports • 1. Recent changes/updates in protocols • 2. Various case examples • 3. Challenges facing sports med professionals • 4. Research and future testing

  3. Concussions in sports- the reality

  4. Recent policy updates • NCAA • No same day clearance IF Dx = concussion • MD/or designee consult for clearance • Written and signed yearly educ for athletes/coaches • VA Tech “STAR” Helmet Grading System Research; HITS

  5. Recent policy updates • NFL • No same day clearance IF Dx = concussion • As of April 2012: 1300 lawsuits filed by former NFL players • Kick-off spot moved up 5 yds (2012 NCAA) • Independent neurologist clearance after game • Knee Jerk Reactions (McCoy- Browns 12/8/11) • Neutral ATC in press box of games (12/20/11) • Med staff allowed to review injury film immediately on sidelines • Likely independent neurologist on sidelines • Authorities not yet convinced of HITS system

  6. Summary of sbu head injury management • Educational Component • Baseline Testing • PHx forms, BESS, ImPACT • Diagnosis • Same Day Management • Follow Up and Management • Medical Clearance • Return to Play • 4 phases (Light aerobic, Heavy aerobic and/or resistance, non-contact/limited px, contact) • Yearly review of policy

  7. Specific Possible case examples • Med staff sees the hit, athlete stumbles getting up, you walk off field with athlete, they “stumbled due to unrelated injury,” pass all sideline tests

  8. Specific Possible case examples • Athlete is in pile on far sidelines, eval on field and sidelines,but didn’t see the hit, Passes all sideline tests • Next day players reveal more details

  9. Specific Possible case examples • Ath took hit to head during game, evaluated for concussion; only s/s is a headache, which he had complained about PRIOR to the game • Ath typically throws up in 1st half of game, due to nerves. Takes a hit on kick-off, vomits a few minutes later, no other s/s. • Player that waves off medical staff as they approach • Do you pull these athletes from activity???

  10. Specific Possible case examples • Concurrent health problems: • Flu- nausea, fatigue • Migraine- vision changes • General cold- fatigue, headache • Heat- headache, dizzy, fatigue, nausea • Headache only • FB PLAYERS MAY HAVE MINOR HEADACHE “NORMALLY” • Post acute? • How do these possibilities affect our RTP decisions?

  11. Challenges facing sports medicine professionals • Concussions are still not fully understood • It just doesn’t fit neatly in a management plan based on medicine, research and logic • There will never be a way to account for every possible variable • Being too restrictive that athletes hide any and all symptoms from you • Judgment and reaction by those outside of sports medicine who do not understand full scope • As the team doctor or ATC, you HAVE to make athlete’s well-being a priority

  12. Challenges: the football culture- toughness, play hard

  13. Challenges: Culture- NFL Player’s perspective (1) "The bottom line is: you have to be able to put food on the table,” Maurice Jones-Drew has been quoted to say and surely this is a common view. “No one's going to sign or want a guy who can't stay healthy. I know there will be a day when I'm going to have trouble walking. I realize that. But this is what I signed up for. Injuries are part of the game. If you don't want to get hit, then you shouldn't be playing."  (RB Jacksonville Jaguars) 12/26/11, USA Today

  14. Culture: NFL Player’s perspective (2) • Anon NFL Player: rule changes are good, “but the truth remains, players are still hiding concussions, because they want to protect their careers. In some cases, teams know a player is concussed and let it go. Yes, that still happens.” (www.cbssports.com) • Polamalu (Steelers LB): “…I have the fear…but I’m willing to fight it.” (www.cbssports.com)

  15. Culture: NFL Player’s perspective (3) • Gilmore (Saints TE): “I think a lot of it has to do with where a player is in his career and life. When you start having kids and families, your perspective on things kind of changes…” (www.cbssports.com) • 23 of 44 NFL players admitted they would hide a possible “C” rather than miss one game (Dec 2011, AP Survey, ESPN)

  16. We are left with more questions than answers • How do sports medicine professionals manage the “grey area” head injuries? • Does a headache alone indicate a concussion acutely and post-acutely? • How do we educate coaches and players to not hit helmet-to-helmet, to at least reduce potential number of concussions? • How will research and society affect the sport of football in the short term and the long term? • What IF the player is willing to take the risk?

  17. Recent , possible future findings and assessments • Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy • Research at BU • Links to suicides, depression? • 5/2/12 death of Junior Seau? • Is it definitive though…???

  18. Recent, possible future findings and assessments • SCAT2 (updated 2009) • Not full proof, but well accepted • Blood Tests- Cleveland Clinic • S100B marker • King-Devick Test • Dyslexia • Visual test for rapid precise eye movement • Ahead System • UMD • Why can some sustain hard hit w/o “C” and others get a “C” with a low impact collision? (www.cleveland.com)

  19. So now what…..? • Yes, helmets can be improved and tackling technique can change, but reality is: • In a contact sport your brain is still at risk for concussion- anatomy of brain/skull • Whiplash, hitting the ground, hit under the jaw • Our responsibility to know changes in laws and protocols, but also to educate players, parents, coaches, health care professionals • ***Did the health of the athlete take priority in my decision?

  20. Thank you for your time

More Related