1 / 21

Undergraduate Concerns

Undergraduate Concerns. Brought to you by the representatives of: AUWiCSEE, CSUA, HKN, IEEE, UPE, XCF. Overview. Transfer Student Difficulties Upgrading Infrastructure Course Concerns Curriculum. Transfer Student Difficulties. Transfer students feel lost

loyal
Download Presentation

Undergraduate Concerns

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Undergraduate Concerns Brought to you by the representatives of: AUWiCSEE, CSUA, HKN, IEEE, UPE, XCF

  2. Overview • Transfer Student Difficulties • Upgrading Infrastructure • Course Concerns • Curriculum Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  3. Transfer Student Difficulties • Transfer students feel lost • want more guidance, before and after admission • Buddy System • Recommendation: designate one EE and one CS professor to advise transfer students Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  4. Upgrading Infrastructure • Courseware on Unix • Reallocating EE 40 lab • Faster Machines Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  5. Infrastructure: Courseware on Unix • A machine running Unix can serve 10 students • A Windows machine serves only 1 student • Unix software helps ease the space crunch • Courses which could do better • CS 160: gcc tools for PDAs • CS 184: bmrt and OpenGL for Unix • CS 186: Postgres or MySQL, instead of Access Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  6. Infrastructure: EE 40 Lab • EE 40 lab has very high end equipment • EE 40 students don’t need all that power • Upper division EE classes could use more equipment • Recommendation: move the equipment to the upper division labs and buy cheaper components for EE 40 Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  7. Infrastructure: Faster Machines • Unix machines in Soda are too slow • under load, machines cannot keep up with typing • Need about $50k a year to upgrade Unix lab machines and servers • Recommendation: Add a $20 course fee to CS 61 series • every other science class with major infrastructure has a course fee Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  8. Course Concerns • Single person projects in lower division • We feel a number of classes could be improved • CS 162 • CS 184 • CS 186 • EE 20 • EE 40 and 42 • EE 122 Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  9. Course Concerns: Single Person Projects • We like single person projects • ensure that all students do the same amount of work • CS 61B and CS 61C students who do single person projects are more prepared • Recommendation: make all CS 61A projects single person except for the first project Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  10. Course Concerns: CS 162 • Nachos project is poorly architected, does not reflect reality • Too much work for TAs and professors to support the courseware • Solution: a crack team of students is working on designing new courseware • should be ready for Spring 02 • contact babylon@csua for more details Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  11. Course Concerns: CS 184 • Course is out of step with current trends in computer graphics • Recommendation: more time on splines and surfaces, less time on 2D graphics • if students complain about the algebra, enforce the math prerequisite Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  12. Course Concerns: CS 186 • Students want more in-depth coverage • “not a design course” • Course project framework is broken • Bugs mar the learning experience, frustrate students • Recommendation: bring back Prof. Wang’s projects (Spring ’99: 6.6/7.0 HKN rating) Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  13. Course Concerns: EE 20 • Inconsistent from semester to semester • Disconnect between book and lecture • Material not appropriate for freshmen • Math 54 should be a prerequisite • Driving students away from EE • Recommendation: institute surveys every half semester - works for CS 61C Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  14. Course Concerns: EE 40 and 42 • EE students feel unprepared for upper division classes after 40 • Recommendations: • less time on IC fabrication • bring back important topics • BJTs, op-amps, Bode plots • merge EE 40 and 42 Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  15. Course Concerns: EE 122 • Inconsistent material and projects • Fewer topics, more depth • Must have stronger textbook • use Richard Stevens’ texts • industry-standard, used by students today • Recommendation: a faculty member needs to take charge of the course Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  16. Curriculum • Foreign Language Courses • Positive Changes • Guaranteed Course Sequences Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  17. Curriculum: Foreign Languages • Very difficult for EECS students to become proficient in a foreign language • need to take 20 units per semester to satisfy EECS requirements while learning a foreign language • Recommendation: Allow two advanced courses in one foreign language to count towards breadth requirements Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  18. Curriculum: Positive Changes • Relaxing L&S CS requirements • makes L&S CS as flexible as EECS • TA Track • helps get motivated TAs • doesn’t aggravate class overcrowding Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  19. Curriculum: Guaranteed Course Sequences • Overwhelming majority of students think it is a BAD idea • Inflexible if student’s interests change • Limits student choice of professor • against the spirit of academia • Unfairly penalizes students who break the sequence • professors not willing to commit to teaching courses • Delays graduation of seniors Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  20. Key Recommendations • Institute transfer student pre- and post-admission advising system • Implement course fees for lower division lab courses • use funds to improve computing infrastructure • Abandon guaranteed course sequences Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

  21. Authors • Galen Hancock – galen@csua - CSUA Treasurer, undergraduate TA • Joe Jamp – jjamp@hkn - HKN • Peter Loer – ploer@upe - UPE President • Paolo Soto – paolo@xcf - root@cory, XCF • Paul Twohey – twohey@csua - CSUA President, HKN, undergraduate TA • Byron Yu – byu@hkn - HKN Department Relations Undergraduate Concerns - Faculty Retreat 2001

More Related