120 likes | 125 Views
The effect of unions on company performance. 1. Trends in union density & union coverage 2. Theory 3. Empirical evidence. Internal factors affecting company performance. (a) HRM policies TQM benchmarking training (b) Pay policies - incentives (n) Unions & union agreements wages
E N D
The effect of unions on company performance • 1. Trends in union density & union coverage • 2. Theory • 3. Empirical evidence
Internal factors affecting company performance • (a) HRM policies • TQM • benchmarking • training • (b) Pay policies - incentives • (n) Unions & union agreements • wages • productivity
1. Trends in union density • Union density = percentage of the workforce in a union • Blanchflower (1996) - see Table 1 • US - continuous decline • UK - more recent decline • variation • Causes of decline?
Union coverage • Coverage = percentage of the workforce ‘covered’ by an agreement • What is more important, density or coverage?
2. Theory • No single model • (i) Monopoly union • (ii) Right-to-manage • (iii) Efficient bargaining • (iv) Seniority • Model (I) ignores bargaining - unrealistic
(i) Right-to-manage model • Bargain over wages • Firms decide level of employment Real wage W/P A B Wm P C Wc P DL Employment
Outcomes • Point A & point C = range • Point B = outcome of a bargain • not an equilibrium • depends on relative strength • union? • Firm?
Efficient bargains • Firms & workers benefit from trade • Bargaining Real wage F B DL Employment Membership
Contract curve • Positively sloped - E & W increase • over manning • W>MPL • Firm must earn supernormal • No trade-off under the Monopoly union & RTM models
3. Empirical evidence • Effect of unions on company performance • (a) Wages & hours • mark-up = 10% in UK, 3.4% in Germany & 16-20% in USA • reduce total hours I.e. ‘standard’ hours • increase paid overtime • (b) Productivity
(c) Profits • Increase W, so effect on depends on productivity • UK = negative • (d) Technical change & investment • union recognition increases investment • ‘voice effect’ • (e) Turnover & employment
Conclusion • Unions are not always bad for companies • Beneficial for workers - ‘sword of justice’