1 / 29

The Future of Post Acute And Long-Term Care

The Future of Post Acute And Long-Term Care. Jonathan M. Evans MD MPH CMD FACP. Predicting the Future:. When you think about the future of health care in general, and PALTCM in particular, what do you see? Why? How do you feel about it? As a health care professional? As a future patient?.

ldion
Download Presentation

The Future of Post Acute And Long-Term Care

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Future of Post Acute And Long-Term Care Jonathan M. Evans MD MPH CMD FACP

  2. Predicting the Future: • When you think about the future of health care in general, and PALTCM in particular, what do you see? • Why? • How do you feel about it? • As a health care professional? • As a future patient?

  3. Population aging: More older, sicker people. Greater need for care • More hospitals? • More nursing homes? • More of us? (Doctors, Nurses, NPs, PAs, Therapists, CNAs, etc) • Why/why not?

  4. Population Aging: Proportionally fewer younger people to care for, pay for needs of older population • Will you get paid more? Why/why not? • Law of supply and demand: how does that work in health care? • Will you be more respected? Why/why not? • Will care get better? Why/why not?

  5. America, like most of the world, is aging • There are more humans alive today in the world aged 65 and older than ever lived to that age in all of history combined! • More older Americans in absolute numbers, and the proportion of older people as % of population also increasing • Subsequent generation (gen x) is smaller than baby boomers • More people will need our care. • There are not enough of us to provide it • (Why is there a shortage of us?)

  6. Population aging affects all of society • Revenue from taxation • Priorities in government, personal spending • Affects economy for all • Many benefits to (younger) society from having large cohort of well seniors • Childcare, volunteerism, philanthropy, historical memory

  7. Life Expectancy/ Population Health/ Health Care Quality • Life expectancy among Americans is falling • Life expectancy lags behind the entire industrialized world and many other countries (43rd) in the world now • Expected to drop further to 67th in the world in next 20 years • America ranks number one worldwide in cost of healthcare

  8. Positive things for you • More people will value expertise in understanding needs, concerns of older persons • Values of older society may be more aligned with your values • Baby boom generation may exert power in ways that benefit you professionally and/or personally

  9. Goals • Discuss past, current issues, factors, and trends affecting PALTC • Develop/discuss a framework for how you can predict the future, in order to have a greater sense of power and control over your life. Greater about to succeed in caring for others

  10. Predicting the Future of PALTC/PALTCM • Conceptually, how (on what basis) does one go about predicting the future? • Identify forces that influence the behavior of individuals, organizations, governments, etc to change • Collect Facts (demographics, health statistics, economics about current situation) • Study past events, current trends re: rates of illness, health care utilization, impact of regulation/laws, payment schemes on health care delivery • Make assumptions, including extrapolating current trends to future • Who actually decides what happens? Why does that matter?

  11. What assumptions do you make in order to predict future?(are those assumptions valid?) • People behave in predictable ways (?) • Understanding what drives behavior predicts the future (?) • People act in their own self interest (?) • They behave rationally (?) • Demography is destiny (?) • People have choices (?)

  12. Assumptions You Make About Future, Continued • Societal needs will dictate how resources are allocated to meet those needs? (Think roads, bridges, infrastructure) • That businesses (ie. health care (hospitals, SNfs) will behave in certain ways that are predictable based upon certain rational behaviors according to business values (i.e revenue/profit maximization above all else? • What does one need in order to make rational decisions?) • Certain societal/moral values will guide planning/decision making? • That there will be planning? (planning for what?)

  13. Predicting the Future: My Assumptions • Follow the money. Major changes in health care delivery and outcomes over last 3 decades have been driven more by a desire on the part of payors to reduce spending (and on the part of providers to make more money/reduce costs) than anything else • Patients, individual practitioners have had much less impact • Promise of better quality for more money never materialized and is no longer believed by payors • Major dislocation of patients to lower cost care sites without commensurate shift in resources • Quality of care keeps going down • Major changes, decisions not based on public health needs

  14. My Assumptions, Continued • There is not/will not be substantially more money to pay for care needs of aging population • Zero sum game • More money isn’t necessary overall • The biggest challenges we can’t buy our way out of • Politics/powerful interests (including within medicine), are impediments to achieving public health goals, care goals, and economic goals

  15. Predicting The Future: Continued • Past is prologue: what has happened thus far and why? • Financial motives of powerful interests will continue to dominate even at the expense of public health, health care (goal is avoid/reduce payment/expense) • Desire to reduce overall costs to payors, will decrease the role, responsibility (but not power) of hospitals, ostensibly (but not actually) to save money • Governments’ role/effect of politics/power different from governing • Health care is reactive, inability to innovate is cultural, educational: ignorance of health care delivery/systems, turnover, inability to provide basic care

  16. Predicting the Future: Continued • fragmented care/ responsibilty expensive overall, increased waste, errors • also based on inability to set prices • Contributes to culture of scarcity: focus on limiting expense/effort • Health care workplace culture unhealthy, adds to cost, inefficiency, poor quality (Burnout, anyone?) unlikely to improve soon • Self interests of PALTC industry/PALTCM providers/Patients/Payors often in conflict • There will be no increase in money/payment per patient/ medicare beneficiary beyond small adjustments (2.4% for SNF care in 2019)

  17. Predicting the future: Continued • Workforce issues (labor) • Business (real estate/finance) issues drive PALTC more than other health care sectors • Government (state and federal) issues affecting PALTC • Revenue (tax) vs obligations (Medicaid/Medicare) affected by demography, politics • Annual or biennial allocation of funds for healthcare (Medicare/Medicaid) vs. pay as you go spending

  18. Past is Prologue

  19. Key moments/forces in history of PALTC • Medicaid late 1960s- ushered in real estate boom/ LTC industry/ community NHs • By 1980s: Limits,on NH construction in almost all States, Medicaid payment less lucrative • Focus on private pay/ higher rents, CCRCs beginning • 1987-1992 OBRA 87/ NHRA • 1990- present: Prospective payment for hospitals resulting in reduced hospital length of stay, changing Ethos of hospitals, health care • 1990’s -now: Post-acute care (Medicare Part A reimbursement) chasing higher rents • 1990’s beginning of Assisted Living Industry • Mid 2000s: Medicare alternative plans (Managed Medicare) • Mid 2000s Medicare Payment based on RUG • Mid 2010s: Decreasing skilled LOS in SNF, declining occupancy rates • 2018: Proposed change in Medicare reimbursement (‘pay for performance’, diagnosis based payment) for 2019

  20. The (real estate) business (financing) of PALTC • Real estate business model • Buildings owned by one legal entity (Real estate (LLC) separate from the company providing the care (operating LLC) • Building is least to an operating company: rent paid based on number of beds/square footage as well as percentage of gross revenue (Retail/shopping mall model) • Value of the real estate asset is a multiplier of rent/revenue and/or census (give hospice example)

  21. Real Estate LLC • Often owned by institutional investor(s)/ REIT • Share holders receive dividends/distributions and or value increased over 3-5 years then sold • Value of the real estate enterprise (just like your home equity) is “trapped capital” • Trapped capital is “released’ by borrowing against it (loan). • Loan proceeds (distributions) are tax free (not income) • This borrowing to buy or refinance is referred to as “leverage” • Economic goals: maximizing assets and releasing them as cash, minimizing tax (by minimizing taxable income)

  22. Real Estate Culture • Maximize revenue per square foot (rent) • Pay commission/finder’s fee for new tenants • Debt driven industry: commercial loans vs. hospital model: Municipal bonds/endowment • Short-term, long-term care are different businesses in same physical place (often same bed) goals/interests/customers may conflict • Many facilities are in the wrong place to e successful SNFs

  23. SNF Operating Company • Lease arrangement with owner of real estate • Borrow money to pay rent, overhead (labor) • Unlike a home loan, no collateral in the form of real estate in the event borrower unable to pay • Lender agrees to extend credit based upon the historical and current revenue/census • Should revenue drop below a certain predetermined level, credit worthiness drops and interest rate automatically increased (or worse)

  24. Decreasing Revenue/ Census in SNF/NF • Nationwide, occupancy rates have decreased from 88% to 80% over 3 years (why?) • Approx 300 NH closures per year over 3 years • From roughly 16,000 down to 15,000 facilities nationwide • Number of people receiving PALTC increasing • Length of stay decreased (27 days for Medicare) • Complexity of patients increasing • Core business (elective joint replacement) has gone away (why?) • Borrowing costs rising, cost to provide care increasing • Good outcomes take time. Shorter LOS= worse outcomes

  25. How Does Your Understanding of This Business Model Affect Your Thinking About the Future of PALTC?

  26. Form Follows Finance • Financial concerns affect decision making including admissions, discharges • Budgets often top down needs/wishes rather than best estimate of reality • Operators may not identify cost of care as well as you can • What will happen if census keeps dropping nationwide? (AZ example)

  27. Proposed Pay for SNF Performance • Payment based on outcomes not minutes of therapies provided • Payment based on medical diagnoses • Penalties for 30 day discharge all cause • What changes do you expect as a result? • Unintended consequences? • What/who determines outcomes?

  28. Labor Issues • Shortage of nurses, shortage of CNAs, Physicians • Causes/potential solutions, consequences • Changing PALTCM work force/consolidation • Hospital based practices • ‘strategic alliances’ • Commoditization of PALTCM • Often irrelevant medical director • Fee used as retainer/subsidy to get practioners to show up • Mismatch between skill set of health care workers and care needs across all care settings

  29. Future of PALTCM: Predictions • Many challenges now and in near future • Nation is torn re: role of government, immigration, etc. that affects PALTC • An extended period of turmoil is likely • Need for excellent, compassionate care has never been greater • AMDA/ PALTCM can promote professional standards, advocate for quality care or risk being run over

More Related