Not all books are created equal: How to set realistic targets and give grades to learners of differe...
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 19

John Bankier Extensive Reading World Congress September 4, 2011 PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 50 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Not all books are created equal: How to set realistic targets and give grades to learners of different reading levels. John Bankier Extensive Reading World Congress September 4, 2011. Discussion Questions. How many books would you hope students would read in a 14-week semester?

Download Presentation

John Bankier Extensive Reading World Congress September 4, 2011

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


John bankier extensive reading world congress september 4 2011

Not all books are created equal: How to set realistic targets and give grades to learners of different reading levels

John Bankier

Extensive Reading World Congress

September 4, 2011


Discussion questions

Discussion Questions

  • How many books would you hope students would read in a 14-week semester?

  • How many books do your students actually read?

  • How do you set targets for your students? Number of books, words, pages, or something else?

  • Are you required to give a grade for your students’ ER performance?


Teaching context

Teaching Context

  • ER program across 90 students of mixed abilities

  • Variation in

    • abilities in classes

    • nationalities and reading experience

  • Necessity to

    • set targets across classes and the school

    • give reliable grades to students based on effort


Approaches to setting targets

Approaches to Setting Targets

  • Large variety but consistently either in terms of books or pages/words

  • Both systems have disadvantages when used for mixed ability groups

  • Key assumption: We need to set a target for all students to meet, which can then be used to determine grading


Book based targets

Book-based Targets

  • 12 books a semester, one or more books a week

  • Ideal when

    • targets can be adjusted depending on student level

    • targets are only targets: not used for grading

  • Problems

    • exponential increase in number of pages/words through levels

    • variations between publishers (headwords are fairly consistent, but actual page/word counts are not)


John bankier extensive reading world congress september 4 2011

Average number of pages


Number of words read

Number of words read

Note: Based on a partial sampling of Penguin Readers, Oxford Bookworms Library and Cambridge English Readers. Adapted from http://www.seg.co.jp/sss/shohyou/word-count.html


John bankier extensive reading world congress september 4 2011

  • Higher and lower level students will be reading much more or much less

  • Some students read faster, but not to this extent

  • One book a week is not sufficient for those reading lower level books

    • develop reading fluency

    • less work for the same grade

  • One level 5 or 6 book a week is not a realistic target

    • more student time for the same grade

  • Rewards underachieving

    • encourages students to read the shortest books

    • discourages students from reading longer books

  • Not all publishers are consistent across their own levels: e.g. Ladder Series (ラッダーシーリズ)


Page based targets

Page-based Targets

  • 500-1000 pages a semester

  • Advantages over book-based targets

    • fairer for those reading mid- to high-level books

    • encourages reading of longer books

  • Potential problems for mixed levels

    • 1000 pages is not an achievable target for many

    • a lot more work for low level students

    • encourages students to read longer, more difficult books


A credit based system

A Credit-based System

Major assumptions

1.

  • As it is hard to test for achievement in ER, grades should reflect effort, represented by time spent reading

    2.

  • 12 books at Cambridge or Oxford Level 3 per semester is used as a benchmark: an achievable midpoint

    3.

  • Pages rather than words were used rather than words

    4.

  • Lower level books should be worth more credits because students read more slowly

  • Higher level books should be worth less credits because students read more quickly

  • However, the disparity should not be as great as publishers’ levels

  • No data exists to show how fast students read, hence a “best guess” is necessary


John bankier extensive reading world congress september 4 2011

  • 12 level 3 books a semester = average 700 pages

  • 700 pages is the target

  • One page = 0.1 credit

  • One semester = 70 credits, 12.7 books

  • 70÷700=0.1

  • This calculation is used to work out credits for each level


John bankier extensive reading world congress september 4 2011

* Based on achieving 70 credits


Examples

Examples

(Rounded up or down to the nearest 0.5)

  • Level 6 book of 95 pages: (70÷1000=0.07)×95=6.65 (6.5 credits)

  • Level 2 book of 40 pages: (70÷600=0.12)×40=4.6 (4.5 credits)

  • Level 4 book of 75 pages: (70÷800=0.09)×75=6.5 (6.5 credits)


Comparison of different systems

Comparison of Different Systems


Grades

Grades

  • Can be set based on credits achieved

  • Example: 70 credits = A, 60 credits = B, 50 credits = C

  • Consistent across all classes and levels of students


Advantages of credit based targets

Advantages of Credit-based Targets

  • Students spend a more equivalent amount of time reading: grades are fairer

  • Encourages students to move up levels but discourages reading the hardest books right away

  • Discourages students from reading books that are too easy for them


Conclusion

Conclusion

  • Book-a-week and page-based targets work well with non-mixed groups, or when grades do not need to be set

  • A credit-based system allows teachers to set targets across a whole institution or mixed-level group

  • These targets translate into letter grades, representing the amount of time spent reading


John bankier extensive reading world congress september 4 2011

  • Please email [email protected] to receive a copy of the spreadsheet or visit


  • Login