1 / 19

Activity 9.

Activity 9. Module versus ad hoc survey. Maria Giuseppina Muratore. There is the need for an integrated approach to violence gender based, to have accurate data that meet users and community needs highlight the hidden violence phenomenon and contribute in eliminating stereotypes

kyley
Download Presentation

Activity 9.

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Activity 9. Module versus ad hoc survey Maria Giuseppina Muratore

  2. There is the need for an integrated approach to violence gender based, to have accurate data that • meet users and community needs • highlight the hidden violence phenomenon and contribute in eliminating stereotypes • define priorities for policy makers • allow social and cultural change in combating violence against women But it’s necessary a • Balance between the opportunity to focus in depth on violence issue and the respondent burden • depending on the type of survey, if dedicated or a module

  3. Need of methodological and procedural dedicated tools to guarantee women safety, help women disclosure, have sounded data • Risk to underestimate data if collected within a no specialized survey (the life course rate of rape or attempted rape was 2,9% in Italian safety citizens’ survey (a victimization survey) against the 5% of violence survey (since the age of 16teen)

  4. In the last decade, two major approaches in survey methodology have been used to survey violence. 1. the dedicated survey, a survey primarily designed to gather detailed information on the extent of different forms of violence against women. 2. special module on violence against women, added to an ongoing survey on a wider topic, such as victimization or health.

  5. Surveys designed primarily for other purposes can play an important role in: • documenting the extent of violence against women, particularly when resources are scarce for conducting dedicated surveys. Disadvantages: • information generated on violence against women is more limited than the information from dedicated studies • greater risk of under-reporting violence • no all surveys are fit to include a module

  6. If ad hoc modules are to be added to ongoing surveys careful consideration needs to be given to the following issues: • the possibility of adding a full instrument to the existing survey and not only a limited number of questions • consequent decision regarding which information are the best and the most important • how to design the module and the impact on the other survey • appropriateness of the topic of the ongoing survey (for example health, victimization, quality of life) • ensuring that women’s safety is not compromised • big attention in creating a good climate interviewer-interviewee, helpful to disclosure

  7. Problems regarding the victimization (crime) context survey: • good for some topic, for instance harassment at work (mobbing, sexual unwanted touching, sexual blackmail, rape and attempted rape) • and for sexual harassment (verbal harassment, exhibitionism, obscene telephone calls, to be followed) • good to link different topics of the phenomenon, as social decay, own safety perception, public life and social behaviour with sexual harassment and violence • less good for rape and especially for rape in intimate relationship and domestic violence

  8. because: • The contest is that of crime collections • Victim have to be aware of abuses • The perception of the partner is negative, as a criminal

  9. Comparing the two Italian surveys • Different aims • Different topics and information • Different data victimization survey AND violence survey

  10. 1. Different aims objective and subjective citizen’s safety • volume of crime (bag snatching, pickpocheting, burglary, robbery, fraud, assault, threats, vehicle theft….) • dark figure of crime • prevalence, incidence, concentration rate in the last 12 months • economic losses • injuries • crime incident details • safety perception • crime risk area where people live module on sexual violence: • to have an idea of the phenomenon

  11. 1. Different aims (VAW) • Prevalence and incidence rate of different types of violence a specific attention has domestic violence by current or former partner • psychological • economical • physical • sexual • Characteristics of those involved and characteristics, consequences and costs of violence, the history of violence • Risk and protective factors related to individuals as well to socio-demographical domain • The every day life context in which violence can arise

  12. 2a. Information collected on violence forms

  13. 2a. Information collected on violence forms

  14. 2a. Differences on the way to collect violence episodes • VAW  3 screening for non partner, actual partner, former partner • CVS  only 1 question for all authors

  15. 2b. Information collected on violence episodes regarding rape

  16. 2c. Other differences in collecting data • Difference in target population • Difference of reference period • Difference in number of questions on the same topic

  17. 3. Differences in data

  18. In conclusion It’s possible to collect data through a module: • It is cheaper • it can be more quick But attention to: • the context of the ongoing survey • tool construction (type of questions and sequence) • information collected • women safety • women trauma • methodological rigorousness • disclosure

More Related