1 / 19

Key food security policy issues

Key food security policy issues. SARPN Conference: Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes . Overview. The analysis of the 2001-03 crisis The current food security situation and programmatic response Contemporary food security policy discussions

knox
Download Presentation

Key food security policy issues

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Key food security policy issues SARPN Conference: Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes

  2. Overview • The analysis of the 2001-03 crisis • The current food security situation and programmatic response • Contemporary food security policy discussions • Challenges and opportunities for CSOs in regional policy SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  3. The analysis of the 2001-03 crisis • Several retrospective studies of the 2001-03 crisis (SADC/ FANRPAN, ODI, Wiggins, Drimie, UK-IDC) • Regional crop production loses of 22% in 2001/02 and 36% in 2002/03 compared to 66% in 1991/92 • Not a ‘traditional’ drought induced food crisis SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  4. The analysis of the 2001-03 crisis • Livelihoods crisis with its’ roots in process on-going since the 1970’s. • Outcome has been growing poverty, increased human vulnerability and food insecurity SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  5. The analysis of the 2001-03 crisis • ‘Underlying causes’ understood to include: • Contraction of formal employment in the mines and industry • Withdrawal of state support to agriculture in developing Countries … • … while continuing agricultural subsidies in developed nations • Removal of price controls and failure of markets • Population pressure and soil degradation • Country related Governance factors • HIV-AIDS SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  6. The analysis of the 2001-03 crisis Adapted from Wiggins (2005) SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  7. Current food security situation • Current overviews of national and regional food insecurity are primarily driven by the CFSM and VAC processes • Crop production region wide falls: Zimbabwe (down 45% on last year), Malawi (36% on 5 year avg.), Zambia (12% on 10 year avg.) and southern Mozambique (48% down in southern Provinces) • Zimbabwe also affected by continuing macro-economic crisis, hyper-inflation and the urban clean-up campaign • Acute food insecurity evident in (parts of) Zimbabwe, Malawi, Mozambique, Zambia, Swaziland and Lesotho SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  8. Current food security situation Source: FEWS NET September 2005 SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  9. Current food security situation • In terms of assessed needs still lower than 2001-03 (VACs estimated that 14,400,000 people in six countries would require 1,000,000 MT of cereals in September 2002) • Limited nutritional data indicates wasting rates well below levels in Sudan, Ethiopia or Somalia • Regional maize availability and prices are relatively good (record SA crop) and being imported by Zimbabwe and Malawi • The potential for a rapid deterioration in conditions provides a major justification for intervention SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  10. Current food security situation • The VACs are struggling to disentangle the overlapping crises in their analyses • The recommendations continue to be dominated by food aid (equivalents) and agricultural inputs • Response being organized through Flash Appeals (Malawi, Zimbabwe) and an expansion of existing instruments • Resources are flowing relatively slowly • Overall WFP appealing for $621m and received $246m • Malawi Flash Appeal 32% funded SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  11. Current food security situation • SADC/WFP RVAC meeting in July agreed on the overall magnitude of needs, but called for further analysis on appropriate responses. • Unanimous call to broaden response from short-term emergency responses (food aid specifically) towards longer-term development interventions. • Call to work under frameworks of: • SADC RISP / Dar declaration • Inter-Agency Regional Humanitarian Strategic Framework • Little evidence of expanded development funding • Collective response has not addressed underlying causes – crisis as a recurring feature SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  12. Contemporary policy debatesShort-term response • Food Aid • Concern over trade and production disincentives • Agenda for change includes untying food aid, end to monetization, increased local purchase and improved targeting • Strong technical arguments for change • How to generate political support for change? • Safety nets • Ensuring access to the chronically poor, prevent transiently food insecure falling into poverty and provide opportunities for households to escape from poverty • Cash transfers receiving particular scrutiny • How can this be done most effectively? How much will they cost? How will they be sustained? SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  13. Contemporary policy debatesShort-term response • Strategic grain reserves • Dual purpose of emergency buffer stocks and price stabilization • Expensive to maintain a large physical stock • What are the alternatives to a physical reserve? • Possibilities: SAFEX futures (Malawi), weather based insurance (Ethiopia) and expanding private warehousing (warehouse receipts systems) • Early warning systems • Maintaining a strong capacity (‘Failures’ in Malawi and Niger) • Would more competition help? Should CSOs maintain an independent voice? • Linking livelihoods analysis to policies and programs that enhance welfare SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  14. Contemporary policy debatesLonger-term response • Agricultural development • Central to NEPAD and SADC strategies • Objectives of improved availability, lower market prices and increased smallholder incomes • How to bring livelihoods approaches to scale efficiently? • Balancing resources to growth and welfare objectives. • HIV-AIDS • Management of HIV-AIDS as a health problem • Maintaining agricultural productivity • Mitigating the impact of HIV-AIDS through safety nets • Nutrition, ARVs and HIV-AIDS linkages SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  15. Contemporary policy debatesLonger-term response • Trade liberalization • Consensus on liberalization (‘maize without border’) • Question on how to maximize benefits while mitigating negative impacts • Trade policy work on removing constraints (NTBs, infrastructure, information, govt behaviour) • What would be the impacts of removal of EU/US ag. subsidies on African consumers? • Disaster risk reduction • Mainstream into development programming (Hyogo framework, NEPAD) • Policy and legislative frameworks are being put in place • Methodologies to implement these policies? SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  16. Challenges and opportunities • CSOs need to stay ‘relevant’ amidst a changing humanitarian aid architecture • Donor channelling funds through SWAPs and DBS • UN restructuring to support national capacity building (Triple Threat) • CSO experience, grounded in field level programs, key. Emphasize continuous learning • Contribute to food security policy formulation, implementation and review SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  17. MONITORING & IMPACT ASSESSMENT (Policy data) ANALYSIS OF POLICY OPTIONS Policy Change Cycle POLICY DIALOGUE/ REVIEW POLICY IMPLEMENTATION Challenges and opportunities SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  18. Challenges and opportunities • Excellent examples of effective CSO contribution to policy at a national level • What is best addressed at the regional level? (co-variant, cross border and regional problems) • Refine agenda with a lens of: • Areas of expertise and practice – greatest traction • Potential for collective action SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

  19. Challenges and opportunities • Provide advocacy around two key messages: • Livelihoods crisis, not a food crisis • Balancing policy attention to economic growth and social transfers • In addition to the current technical agenda two possible themes to be brought into the debate: • Nutrition, health and education • Climate change • Use a regional voice to influence • Governments • Donors – allocation of ‘developmental resources’ SARPN Conference on Enhancing Civil Society Participation in SADC Food Security Processes: 14th – 15th November, 2005

More Related