1 / 10

Hajj-going from Britain The Pilgrimage Industry, Welfare Organisations & UK Government

Hajj-going from Britain The Pilgrimage Industry, Welfare Organisations & UK Government. Dr Se á n McLoughlin Theology & Religious Studies University of Leeds New Forms of Public Religion St John’s College, University of Cambridge 5-7 September 2012. Overview.

kirima
Download Presentation

Hajj-going from Britain The Pilgrimage Industry, Welfare Organisations & UK Government

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Hajj-going from Britain The Pilgrimage Industry, Welfare Organisations & UK Government Dr Seán McLoughlin Theology & Religious Studies University of Leeds New Forms of Public Religion St John’s College, University of Cambridge 5-7 September 2012

  2. Overview • 1) British Muslims and the Changing Hajj Industry • 2) Pilgrim Welfare Organisations • 3) UK Government & the Hajj

  3. Background • 2001 - previous work with British Pakistanis in Lancashire • http://www.leeds.ac.uk/hajj/research.htm • 2011 – 8 x 2hr initial interviews on the UK “Hajj industry” • In addition to 30 more interviews with British Muslim pilgrims • 2011/12 – survey @ https://www.survey.leeds.ac.uk/hajj • 211 responses - mid20s-40s, educated, ‘very’/‘somewhat’ religious • See also: the British Museum’s “Hajj stories” website • http://www.britishmuseum.org/whats_on/exhibitions/hajj/hajj_stories.aspx

  4. 1) British Muslims & the Changing Hajj Industry • Changing expectations of Hajj going with migration • Survey: 35% of grandparents had been, 80% of parents • Survey: religious duty key in determining when go (53%) • But personal need / spiritual journey important too (30%) • “Guests of God” – an invitation from Allah • But also financial, family, work & other constraints • Intensely foregrounded by media compared to the past • Information widely available - guide books, satellite tv, etc • but still anxiety / concern about fiqh (law), adab (manners) & modernisation

  5. 1) British Muslims & the Changing Hajj Industry • 18-25k go for Hajj, 100k for Umrah (highest in Europe) • High risk for operators, tight deadlines, rising costs • but demand has grown – British Muslim youth demographic; so potentially lucrative profits - £1k+pp (estimated) • Transformation of Hajj organisation from the mid-2000s • Saudi Kingdom’s response to overcrowding, health & safety, and logistics • Pilgrims must book a hotel room through an operator (group size = 150-500) but flights can be booked separately • Operators must be Ministry of Hajj approved (UK=75) • Professionalisation & consumer choice, £6k for 5* to < £3k • Pyramid of operator sub-agents at the bottom end - don’t always deliver • In making their arrangements, many pilgrims still often rely upon an informal bond of trust with family, imams - not contracts

  6. 2) Pilgrim Welfare Organisations • “I think the Hajjis from the non-Muslim countries are treated like orphans ... There is no kind of Hajj mission at the government level” (Government officer, British Muslim background) • In Muslim countries government has a key role in planning & facilitation of the Hajj in Saudi Arabia • “I wish there was a mufti of the UK who would dictate all those things ... but I don’t see that happening at all” (as above) • Question of religious authority but also organisational capacity is an issue • “We're not here for profit. It's solely for the purpose & pleasure of the Almighty Allah to ensure that his guests get the ultimate experience” (Pilgrim Welfare Organisation representative) • Religious service (khidmat) & the complexities of British Muslim voluntary organisations/civil society, their relationship to the state and ‘communities’

  7. 2) Pilgrim Welfare Organisations • Association of British Hujjaj • Established 1998, Birmingham • Migrant generation Pakistani businessmen / professionals • Lack of support for British-Muslims if death, theft, etc while on Hajj • Need to educate pilgrims on health & safety, as well as the industry. • Lobbied government • Taken up by Lord Ahmed • Idea of a Hajj delegation from 2000 • Need for special state regulation of UK Hajj / Umrah industry.

  8. 2) Pilgrim Welfare Organisations • Council of British Hajjis • Established 2006 • Gujerati Indian networks, Bolton-based. NB Lord Patel connection. • British-born generation • Key messages still not reaching the grassroots - “Put your faith in God but tie a camel!” • Operators need leadership • Code of practice? Self-regulation? • One voice to address the Saudis - a British Hajj & Umrah Council?

  9. 3) UK Government & the Hajj • 2000 - New Labour & the first UK Hajj Delegation • Regulation – responding to public health through partnerships • Recognition, soft power & good relations at home & abroad • First time that a non-Muslim country took such an initiative • Led by a political dignitary (Lord Ahmed, Lord Patel) • FCO consular advice & funded trips of several volunteer medics • Base in Makkah. No need to travel to Jeddah or Riyadh. • Thousands treated over 2-3 weeks; cost up to £85k with some sponsorship • The new Coalition government, Big Society and a ‘smaller state’ • 2010: FCO discontinued support for volunteer medics • Not about the financial crisis and cuts? • A service without precedent, reduced demand & improved local provision?

  10. 3) UK Government & the Hajj • Trading Standards in a London Borough (Tower Hamlets) • 34 complaints in the last 2 years • Civil complaints – changes to verbal agreements, e.g. different routes, stopovers, rooming, other services. • Criminal investigations of documented fraud • Case of Qibla Hajj Kafela Services (2009) • Cheap packages & absconded with £500k+, hundreds of passports • Response demanded by British Bengali mayor / councillors • Trading Standards visited mosques. NB addressing religious & cultural reasons for not complaining. • Held seminars for operators with FCO, CAA, BIS. Emergence of a self-policing association (10-12 members, 80% of local industry, ATOL registrations up). • Little local awareness of ABH or CBH

More Related