Legislative history
1 / 29

LEGISLATIVE HISTORY - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

LEGISLATIVE HISTORY. Introduction and Uses Victoria K. Trotta ASU Ross-Blakley Law Library. INTRODUCTION. What is ‘legislative history’? Why do we need to know about it? Where is it in the legal research cosmos? What goes into one? Why do lawyers want one? How do courts use it?.

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about ' LEGISLATIVE HISTORY' - kermit-mcfadden

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Legislative history


Introduction and Uses

Victoria K. Trotta

ASU Ross-Blakley Law Library


  • What is ‘legislative history’?

  • Why do we need to know about it?

  • Where is it in the legal research cosmos?

  • What goes into one?

  • Why do lawyers want one?

  • How do courts use it?

The issue in a nutshell
The Issue in a Nutshell




What is legislative history
What is Legislative History?

  • “Information embodied in any legislative documents that provide the meaning and interpretation of the statute”

How are legislative histories used by the federal and state courts
How are Legislative Histories Used by the Federal and State Courts?

  • State courts differ in their use

  • Federal courts make greater use of them

  • West Digest System

    • topic: Statutes

    • keynumbers: 213 - 217.4

      • 217 “history in general”

      • 217.2 “legislative history of act”

In federal and state court
In Federal and State Court Courts?

  • General rule: Plain language

  • Resort to legislative history not necessary when language of statute is plain

  • But, when statute is ambiguous, OK to consult legislative history

More….. Courts?

  • But, ambiguity is not always considered a prerequisite for use of extrinsic aids - the plain meaning rule is not to be used to thwart the intent of congress by excluding…enlightenment from the legislative files

And finally
And Finally, Courts?

  • The plainer the language, the more convincing a contrary legislative history must be to overcome the natural purport of a statute’s language

Thought for the day
Thought for the Day Courts?

“I don’t care what the legislature

intended, I just want to

know what the words mean.”

Chief Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes


Sources for investigating legislative histories
Sources for Investigating Legislative Histories Courts?

  • Sands [Sutherland], Statutory Construction

  • Cohen, Berring, Olson, How to Find the Law 9th ed

  • Kunz, et al, The Process of Legal Research, 4th ed

  • Jacobstein and Mersky, Fundmentals of Legal Research, 6th ed

  • Arizona Legal Research Guide

Intrinsic aids
“Intrinsic Aids” Courts?

  • Context

  • Titles, preambles, enacting clauses

  • Definition provisions, savings clauses

  • Headings, punctuation

Extrinsic aids a spectrum
“Extrinsic Aids” - A Spectrum Courts?

  • Enactment history

    • This is the stuff of a classic ‘legislative history’

    • Bill as introduced

      • highly useful

    • Amendments to the bill

      • highly useful

    • Hearings held

      • not too useful.Statements made by outsiders - nope!

More extrinsic aids
More Extrinsic Aids Courts?

  • Committee Reports - Standing

    • highly useful, esp if reasons bill is being recommended

  • Committee Members - Standing

    • some use; more than debaters

  • In most states, the standing committee merely recommends passage - not much detail!

Extrinsic aids iii
Extrinsic Aids III Courts?

  • Committee Reports - Special

    • Very useful!

  • Conference Reports

    • Very useful!

Extrinsic aids iv
Extrinsic Aids IV Courts?

  • Statements

    • By bill draftsman

      • some say yes, some say no!

    • By committee person in charge of shepherding the legislation

      • maybe!

    • By other committee persons

      • Not usually unless there appears to be consensus

    • Sponsor of the bill

      • Be somewhat skeptical!

Extrinsic aids v
Extrinsic Aids V Courts?

  • More Statements

    • Debates on the floor

      • As a general rule, too speculative

      • Court doesn’t want to rule on credibility of members

      • But, if committee person in charge of the bill, explains it, might have some weight.

    • The Feds will sometimes take debate as a whole if statements all tend to show common agreement.

Extrinsic aids vi
Extrinsic Aids VI Courts?

  • Motives of the members of the legislature

    • disregarded, unless expressed in the statute itself

  • Initiative and Referendum Explanations

    • ballot pamphlets favored

  • Executive Messages

    • As part of state’s special session; but not considered if part of signing ceremony

Extrinsic aids vii aka any port in a storm
Extrinsic Aids VII Courts? aka Any Port In a Storm

  • Pre enactment history

    • economic conditions

    • prevailing business practices

    • prior state of the laws

    • activities of pressure groups

When to research and compile
When to Research and Compile Courts?

  • Time is $$$

  • Will depend upon

    • age of statute under review

    • number of amendments to research

    • what is available and where

    • whether some research has already been put together

    • how badly does the lawyer need it?

Fantasy vs reality
Fantasy vs Reality Courts?

  • Lawyers often have unrealistic expectations of what you will find, and how much

  • What you find might itself be ambiguous or inconclusive

  • There might not be much to find!

  • Experience will help you build realistic budgets - from 30 minutes to 4+ hours, plus your hard costs

How lawyers use them
How Lawyers Use Them Courts?

  • To buttress a position, but not as primary argument

  • The statute is ambiguous as applied to the case at hand, and/or no case law exists

  • Some practice areas rely more heavily on legislative histories: tax, securities, food and drug laws

  • Risk averse might want one done as a matter of routine

Administrative law

Administrative Law Courts?

A Brief Introduction and Basic Sources

Administrative law the executive branch
Administrative Law: The Executive Branch Courts?

  • Chaos! Then, FR & CFR Acts of 1936-7; Administrative Procedures Act of 1946

  • Enabling Statutes

  • Quasi-legislative:

    • rules, regulations (EPA)

  • Quasi-judicial

    • decisions, orders (NLRB)

Administrative rules and regulations
Administrative Rules and Regulations Courts?

  • Proposed federal regulations published in the Federal Register; state in Administrative Register/Digest

  • Notice Period 30 - 90 days

  • Final regulation reprinted when adopted

  • In Arizona, some agencies blow off this requirement (can you believe it?)

Administrative rules and regs
Administrative Rules and Regs Courts?

  • Codified at the Federal level in Code ofFederal Regulation

  • Codified at the State level in Arizona Administrative Code

  • Neither is annotated

  • Indexing ranges from poor (CFR) to non-existent (AAC)

  • But! Tables from statutes to regulations!

Updating administrative regs
Updating Administrative Regs Courts?

  • CFR - quarterly recompiling and re-issuing of 25% of the entire code

  • CFR updated by List of Sections Affected (LSA) pamphlets. Points to Federal Register text

  • Arizona - quarterly updating (looseleaf interfiling). If you are lucky, first appears in Arizona Administrative Register.

Administrative regs online
Administrative Regs OnLine Courts?

  • Lexis/Nexis and Westlaw

    • CFR

    • Federal Register

  • Internet

    • CFR

    • Federal Register

    • Email daily FR table of contents!

    • Arizona Secretary of State - AAC Supplements and Register (1998)

Administrative decisions and orders
Administrative Decisions and Orders Courts?

  • Quasi-judicial function

  • Major administrative agencies have their own judicial process

  • Some are published; some aren’t

  • Federal courts will review

  • “Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies”

  • In Arizona - Lots of Luck!!!

Research options
Research Options Courts?

  • Davis, Administrative Law

  • Annotations of State/Federal statutory code compilations

  • Loose-leaf services *

  • Specialty Newsletters

  • Online services will have decisions and orders of major agencies

  • Internet, too