Dissemination Science:
This presentation is the property of its rightful owner.
Sponsored Links
1 / 36

Dissemination Science: Designing for impact, and implications for SCTC PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 70 Views
  • Uploaded on
  • Presentation posted in: General

Dissemination Science: Designing for impact, and implications for SCTC. Douglas Luke, PhD. May 1, 2014. Goals. Problem: Discovery to delivery gap Solution: Designing for Dissemination & Impact Examples from tobacco control Tobacco control guides SCTC. Problem: Discovery to Delivery Gap.

Download Presentation

Dissemination Science: Designing for impact, and implications for SCTC

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Presentation Transcript


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Dissemination Science:

Designing for impact, and implications for SCTC

Douglas Luke, PhD

May 1, 2014


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Goals

  • Problem: Discovery to delivery gap

  • Solution: Designing for Dissemination & Impact

  • Examples from tobacco control

    • Tobacco control guides

    • SCTC


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Problem: Discovery to Delivery Gap


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Scurvy!

http://greas.ca/publication/pdf/melaniebarwickenglish.pdf


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

The Promise of D&I Science

…there is still an enormous gap between what we know can maximize the quality of health care and what is currently being delivered in practice and community settings.

…to optimize public health we must not only understand how to create the best interventions, but how to best ensure that they are effectively delivered within clinical and community practice.

NIH, OBSSR


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

http://www.thepermanentejournal.org/files/Fall2010PDFS/PerinatalResearchUnit.pdf


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Dissemination also takes too much time in tobacco control


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Consequence of Dissemination & Implementation Gap

  • Poor quality health care

  • Ineffective and patchwork policies

  • Suffering, morbidity are prolonged

  • Nation doesn’t benefit from billions of US tax dollars spent on research to develop & test effective care and evidence-based policies


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Low Tax

No Statewide Smoke-free

State TC Disparities

Source: Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids

High Tax

Statewide Smoke-free


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Dissemination & Implementation Gaps in Tobacco Control

  • Dissemination

    • Awareness of evidence-based guidelines (e.g., Best Practices) is high among national and state TC leaders, but low among local and regional TC practitioners

    • Lack of useful implementation guides and training that translate science into program and policy development

  • Implementation

    • Half of states have no comprehensive smokefree policies

    • Many states have been slow to implement aggressive pricing policies


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

What is dissemination?

An active approach of spreading evidence-based information to the target audience via determined channels using planned strategies

– Brownson, et al., 2013, AJPH


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Historical context (abbreviated)

  • Seminal article in 1943 on diffusion of hybrid seed corn in two Iowa communities

    • Key findings

      • Adoption as key dependent variable, change agents, importance of different communication channels


Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

Diffusion of innovations

  • Diffusion = the process through which an innovation is communicated through certain channels over time among the members of a social system

  • Most influential theory guiding dissemination science (Rogers)

    • Early development emphasized temporal patterns and actor characteristics


  • Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Models for dissemination

    • Many dissemination models exist

      • Tabak and colleagues have identified 37 (Tabak, et al., 2012, AJPM)


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Solution: Designing for Dissemination to Enhance Impact


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Dissemination and Impact Pipeline Model

    Scientific

    Activity

    Scientific

    Dissemination


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Dissemination and Impact Pipeline Model

    Policymakers

    Community & Advocacy

    Partners

    Scientific

    Activity

    Scientific

    Dissemination

    Public Health

    Impact

    Practitioners & Clinicians

    Legal

    Audiences

    Funders


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Dissemination and Impact Pipeline Model

    Policymakers

    Community & Advocacy

    Partners

    Scientific

    Activity

    Scientific

    Dissemination

    Public Health

    Impact

    Practitioners & Clinicians

    Legal

    Audiences

    Funders

    Media


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Dissemination and Impact Pipeline Model

    Policymakers

    Community & Advocacy

    Partners

    Scientific

    Activity

    Scientific

    Dissemination

    Public Health

    Impact

    Practitioners & Clinicians

    Push

    Legal

    Audiences

    Funders

    Media

    Pull


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Barriers to Effective Dissemination (on the ‘Push’ side)

    • What factors get in the way of pushing science into effective policy & practice?

      • Putting dissemination ‘at the end’

      • Lack of funding and infrastructure

      • Reliance on single dissemination modes

      • Reliance on outmoded dissemination approaches and models

      • Lack of training, general media ‘savviness’

      • Lack of appropriate incentives

      • Professional jealousy

      • For tobacco control: Interference and misinformation from the tobacco industry


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Principles of Designing for

    Dissemination & Impact

    • Be active - passive dissemination does not work

    • Be repetitive - single messages do not work

    • Use multiple channels - single channels are less effective

    • Involve stakeholders early - otherwise information may not be heard and used

    • Be a translator – tailor information to specific audiences

    Adapted from Tabak, et al., 2012, AJPM; and Mueller, et al., 2008, JPHMP)


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Figure 2. A framework for dissemination of evidence-based policies

    Define EBPs

    Active Dissemination

    Policy content

    Audience Research

    Passive

    Dissemination

    Policy process

    Attributes affecting dissemination: relative advantage, complexity, cost

    5. Maintenance

    1. Innovation Development

    • Build the rationale for evidence-based policies

    • Development of the Community Guide and other sources on policy interventions

    • Build source credibility

    2. Awareness

    • Begin active knowledge transfer

    • Identify target audience factors

    • Identify communication channels

    3. Adoption

    • Uptake of the policy by the target audience(s)

    • Target adoption to attitudes and values of intended audience

    • Identify barriers to adoption

    • Improve the skills of adopters

    • Provide training and technical assistance

    4. Implementation

    • Ongoing implementation and continued use of the innovation

    • Ensure policy enforcement

    Policy outcomes


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Necessary Skills & Training

    • Health communications

    • Infographics and visual design

    • Marketing and science journalism

    • Social media

    • Organizational behavior

    • Dissemination & implementation science


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Examples


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Example: Tobacco Control Guides

    • Responding to practitioners’ need for translating Best Practices into practical program and policy implementation

    February 2014

    April 2014

    February 2014

    Available at: http://cphss.wustl.edu/Projects/Pages/Tobacco-Control-Guides


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Tobacco Control Guides

    Incorporating audience guidance and feedback

    Audiences: Advocacy, Practitioners, Legal, Science


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Tobacco Control Guides

    Tailoring scientific information for practitioner audience


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Tobacco Control Guides

    Telling stories


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Tobacco Control Guides

    Repeating information and using visual displays to emphasize the ‘take home message.’


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Tobacco Control Guides

    Using infographics to provide rich information and support story telling


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    Tobacco Control Guides

    Using pictures and graphics to enhance the attractiveness of the report, and to frame the content


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    It’s Not All on You…

    • Distinguishing between dissemination skills and strategies on the one hand…

    • And a dissemination system on the other hand

    • You (as the scientist) do not need to be the primary or exclusive disseminator

      • Good tobacco control science comes first…

      • But you should be connected to the dissemination system so that your work is communicated accurately


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    SCTC and Dissemination for Impact

    • Importance of dissemination for SCTC

      • Central position in evaluation logic model

      • Builds on history of strong dissemination partnerships

    • Getting off to a strong start

      • Workgroups, core projects, developmental projects

      • Diversity of dissemination products & activities (e.g., website, reports, training materials, DVDs, tailored products)


    Dissemination science designing for impact and implications for sctc

    For more information…

    Douglas Luke, PhD

    dluke@.wustl.edu


  • Login