1 / 11

Domain Name Registrant Data: The Privacy Questions

Domain Name Registrant Data: The Privacy Questions Alan Davidson Center for Democracy and Technology http://www.cdt.org Understanding the Privacy Questions Goal: A framework for considering potential privacy questions raised by collection of and access to DNS registrant data.

johana
Download Presentation

Domain Name Registrant Data: The Privacy Questions

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Domain Name Registrant Data: The Privacy Questions Alan Davidson Center for Democracy and Technology http://www.cdt.org

  2. Understanding the Privacy Questions • Goal: A framework for considering potential privacy questions raised by collection of and access to DNS registrant data. • Context: What data is collected, why is it needed, and who is it collected about? • Privacy: What privacy questions are raised? • Best practices: Ideas for reconciling privacy questions and data access needs. 1

  3. Context: The Need for Registrant Data • Technical stability • Law enforcement • Consumer protection • Intellectual property protection • Competition 2

  4. A Spectrum of DNS Registrants • Range of domain name registrants: From large companies to individuals pursuing non-commercial purposes. • Increasing number of individuals in gTLDs. (Verisign estimate: 15% “non-business” and growing) • Note: Very different privacy expectations for different types of users. 3

  5. Data Collection and Access Requirements The gTLD experience: • Data collected: Technical, billing, and administrative contact. Require name, address, phone, and email. • Access to data: Full public access, as quickly and completely as possible, for anyone online. • Bulk access: Both individual queries and bulk transfer to compilers and resellers of registrant info. 4

  6. Privacy Questions • Note: Wide range of cultural perspectives and national laws. • Is personal information collected? For businesses, almost certainly not. For individuals, data can be personally identifiable and sensitive. (ex. home phone number) • Is there an expectation of privacy? For businesses, should be no. But for individuals, possible expectation of privacy today. 5

  7. Privacy Questions II For individuals with a privacy expectation: • Are Fair Information Practices followed? Key issue is use of data. • Is the data used solely for the purpose for which it was collected? Difficult to enforce against secondary uses today. Possible unintended uses: Marketing and unsolicited email. Criminal use. Government persecution. • Other concerns? Some will not want to sacrifice privacy in order to access the DNS. 6

  8. Reconciling Privacy Questions Some ideas for dealing with individual privacy:: • Public education: Good notice, clear understanding of alternatives • Meaningful alternatives to registration • Allow proxy contacts (like “unlisted” numbers in the telephone book) for some registrant data 7

  9. Reconciling Privacy Questions II Other ideas, raising implementation difficulties: • Limit secondary uses (allow bona fide requests, prohibit others) • Make only some data widely available (such as tech contact, legal address) • Separate commercial actors and non-commercial individuals (difficult!) • Create audit system and allow review of database queries (with delay as needed) 8

  10. Conclusion • Range of important demands for fast access to registrant data. • Privacy questions limited in commercial setting, but raised by individual registrants and secondary use of information. • Look forward to working on ways to balance these concerns and reconcile privacy questions. 9

  11. Fair Information Practice Principles • Openness (Notice) • Consent (Choice) • Access • Security • Accountability (Enforcement) • Collection Limitation • Data Quality • Use Limitation

More Related