1 / 27

PHIL106

PHIL106. Contemporary Ethical Issues. Lecture Etiquette. Asking questions Arriving late & leaving early Cell phones Sleeping. PHIL106: Contemporary Ethical Issues. The issues The morality of advertising The morality of the death penalty The morality of euthanasia The abortion debate

jase
Download Presentation

PHIL106

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. PHIL106 Contemporary Ethical Issues

  2. Lecture Etiquette • Asking questions • Arriving late & leaving early • Cell phones • Sleeping

  3. PHIL106: Contemporary Ethical Issues • The issues • The morality of advertising • The morality of the death penalty • The morality of euthanasia • The abortion debate • Life boat ethics • The morality of cloning • The morality of genetic engineering • The method • Discussion of justified arguments

  4. Is Advertising Immoral? • Does advertising manipulate us into buying things that we don’t need? • Does advertising coerce us into buying things that are bad for us? • Does exposure to advertising make us unhappy?

  5. The Morality of the Death Penalty • The death penalty is still doled out in many places around the world • Should the death penalty ever be used as punishment for wrong doing?

  6. The Morality of Euthanasia • Should doctors be able to kill people if all of the following criteria about those people are met? • They’re in chronic pain, • They’ve no chance of recovery, • They’ve little time left to live, and • They want to die

  7. The Abortion Debate • Should parents be allowed to abort their unborn children if they choose to? • Is there a point of the pregnancy after which abortion should not be permitted?

  8. Life Boat Ethics • What do you do when the life boat is full to capacity and there are more people trying to get in? • They will die if you leave them • You might all die if you let them on

  9. The Morality of Cloning • Identical twins (and triplets!) are effectively genetic clones • Many animals have been cloned in the lab (sheep, dogs, mice etc.) • Should human cloning be banned?

  10. The Morality of Genetic Engineering • Some people are born with genetic diseases or advantages (better looking etc) • Should genetic engineering of humans be allowed at all? • And, if so, what things should we be allowed to use it for?

  11. For Next Time • Read: • The Course Outline, • ‘The Debate over Utilitarianism’ (1997) by James Rachels, and • ‘A Simplified Account of Kant’s Ethics’ (1997) by Onora O’Neill. – See PHIL264 - 2008 reader • Get ready to discuss: • How to justify ethical claims

  12. PHIL106 Justifying Ethical Claims

  13. Types of Claims • Descriptive (usually amoral) • “Those seats are red” • Evaluative (can be amoral) • “Her essay was excellent” • Moral (never amoral) • “Dan is a (morally) bad person” • Assume there are such things as morally right and wrong

  14. Ethics • Concerned with justifying moral claims • Can use theories • Should use consistent and rationally compelling reasoning • We are going to apply ethics to contemporary moral controversies in this course

  15. Why Do We Need It? • If we want to make the world a better place… • People have different moral beliefs • Ethics allows for better discussion • And, might help us find the answer

  16. A Test Case • 18 year old brother and sister on holiday together alone • After much consideration, they have protected consensual sex • They never tell anyone about it or ever do it again • They both enjoyed it and remain very good friends • Is what they did morally wrong?

  17. Brother-Sister Incest • In Germany people are regularly prosecuted for this • Sent to jail, fined • Have their children taken away • The risk of genetic disease is similar to two consenting adults when one has a genetic disease • Which is allowed, but incest isn’t • Article (more info on this couple)

  18. Ethical Theories • Can be applied to situations and should provide a moral verdict • No theory seems to work perfectly • This may be a problem with our moral beliefs • No general agreement on a ‘best’ theory

  19. Utilitarianism • The morally right act is the one that maximises overall happiness • Look at the options • Try to predict how much happiness and suffering will be produced by each option • Choose the one that should produce the most ‘net happiness’

  20. Utilitarianism – E.G. • You have cheated on your partner • Morally speaking, should you tell them? • Weigh up the options • How much happiness and suffering would you expect to be produced by each option?

  21. Kantianism • Always act in a way that respects the rationality of others • Think before you act • Will this action treat anyone as a mere means? • Basically, you mustn’t use people without their consent

  22. Kantianism – E.G. • You have cheated on your partner • Morally speaking, should you tell them? • Which action would best respect their rationality? • Would you be using them as a mere means? • If they ask, you mustn’t lie

  23. Argument by Analogy • To argue that an act is moral: • Show that it is the same as something your opponent thinks is moral • It only needs to be the same in the morally relevant ways • Reverse for immoral acts

  24. Arg. by Analogy – E.G. • Genetic engineering kids to be smarter • Some say it is morally the same as sending them to a better school • Is this a good analogy? • Are these two acts morally equivalent?

  25. Divine Command Theory • An act is moral or immoral if God thinks it to be so • E.g. for Catholics: • GE of people is a sin, • But good schooling is not • But, why would God endorse one and not the other? • The answer to this question could be your justification

  26. The Law • An act is immoral if it breaks a law • But, the law is usually thought to follow morality

  27. Another Test Case • Mike bought a bunch of Rugby 7s tickets when they first went on sale. • He later auctioned them on trademe, making $500 profit. • Is what Mike has done immoral? • What factors might your verdict depend on?

More Related